Italian pie (Centerville Hwy , by the publix grocery)

When my food arrived it was probably the best deal and best for I’ve ever had we ordered wings pizza garlic knots best thing of my life service is amazing food fresh crispy and the taste was amazing. I hardly recommend to eat this as a family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best good food ive ever tried best to eat with family take out food great service great and a great prices for food definitely recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great mom and po feel. Fresh food and great prices. Must try

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you like Italian food.. you won't be disappointed eating here. The food is great. And they always make you feel appreciated for coming. Nice.

(Sorry for the photos.. I started eating b4 I snapped the photos. Was hungry😬😝)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Finally.
Real pizza.

We are very picky New Jersey Pizza lovers. We've been in the Atlanta area now for about 3 years, and challenged to find a really good pizzeria...but we finally did! Italian Pie both on Centerville Road near Loganville as well as Lawrenceville, offer authentic Italian New York style pizza... thin crust, great sauce. (I always suggest you don't ask Georgians where there's good pizza because GA doesn't know NJ/NY....I mean no offense!) But thank you guys for this great pie. Had a mushroom sausage tonight. Licking my chops! Ciao! David
Loganville GA
🇮🇹🍕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They charge for water. You must purchase bottled water with your meal. They don’t offer a cup of water. We left. We go to the location on Lawrenceville Highway quite often and came to this one based on that. We’re glad we didn’t eat there. We will not be back. We will go to the one on Lawrenceville Highway.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I got my food to go. I ordered the food there. The service was fast and the calzone was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food here is always a hit. The crust doesn't taste like a cardboard, it taste how it's doe is supposed to taste. Everything is made to order. The staff is very nice and friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I used to order from this place all the time, and the food and service was much better in the past. It's ridiculous now, don't go and patronize this establishment. They over charge and the order is wrong with no apologies or nothing to make it right.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Wings, Strombolis

I came in to get a slice of pizza and while I was waiting I added on a small salad, charged incorrectly for the large salad by the girl at the register. Then she refunded me but that had taken most of the money that I had budgeted to spend that evening and refunds take up to 4 days. I couldn't get the small salad unless I wanted to use the money I had planned to use to buy other things that evening. I was so mad I couldn't even eat the pizza it tasted awful the sauce was too sweet. It's not Italian at all. Not a single Italian person there. Normally I'd cut my losses but I was so mad about the mischarge I came back to get a refund for the pizza I'd taken two bites of. Brought it right up.tonthe counter and opened the box. It was getting thrown away either way. It was disgusting. The guy there with the swollen jaw was insulting in Spanish- yea, my guy, the PIZZA is lousy, not me -assuming I was ignorant of the language.
Instead of responding in Spanish, i left and decided to post this review and not catch a charge.
10 out of 10 would NOT reccomend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

I wasn’t expecting my food to be as crappy as it was so unfortunately I don’t have any pictures. I will say, though 100% believe the reviews. I had a taste for pizza and wanted something besides Papa John’s and Little Caesars so I found this place and saw that they have pizza by the slice and a kid’s pizza which was perfect because it’s just me and my seven-year-old so I gave them a try. I would say I messed up by ordering online, but considering these reviews, looks like we’re all having the same experience I absolutely blame the establishment. I don’t live far from this location at all, so I’m not sure why all my food was cold. I got a huge single slice of cheese pizza, that absolutely looked and tasted like cardboard. I ordered my daughter a pepperoni kids pizza they gave her cheese. I ordered an eight count of garlic knots, I was wondering why the box was so heavy turns out they weren’t fully cooked. The insides weren’t cooked at all. And I ordered us some churros. I wish the description said they put some pink sauce on the inside because I wouldn’t have gotten them. It was disgusting whatever it was overpowered the churros and all I tasted was whatever that pink stuff was. I’m really upset because I hate wasting money and this was just a really nasty horrible experience.

Food: 1

I’m not sure what happened to this business. The first one was located in Lawrenceville on 29. Food was delicious pizza was always fresh and tasted really close to NY pizza. Well this one in Centerville ain’t that. If I didn’t know better, I would think they ran out of Pizza went to Little Cesars bought a cheese pie topped it with imitation sausage and ran it back through the pizza oven. The Pizza was thin as cardboard which explains why it tasted like cardboard. Multiple slices had little to no cheese and the sauce was full of pepper. Not sure if this is a franchised unit and the original owner doesn’t have anything to do with it, but if it is still owned by the same owner then I suggest you stop in this location. They are ruining your name and seem not to care judging by the reviews. If looking for Pizza for you and your family do not spend money here. Go to Fratellis, Marcos, Papa John, Dominoes, Publix and make your own pie. Or just get Chinese food. This place is HORRIBLE!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Why advertise pizza by the slice and then claim to not offer anything other than a whole pizza. Sounds to me like someone was being lazy