5 Best Italian Restaurants in Tifton

“We are traveling and are staying at a campground close, so we are able to walk to the restaurants. Originally, went to a restaurant next to Olive Garden, walked out as no one came to seat us, walked into Olive Garden, was busy, took our name right away, sat us in about 5 min. Our server was Tara, great service, very friendly, we were served quickly and everything was hot. Food was very good. Only issue I had was, I ordered a Light Portion Spaghetti and Meatballs, and was charged for my 1 meatball. I asked my server, she said it is Spaghetti w/meat sauce, and charges for the meat ball, not what the menu says. Disappointed with that issue. Would go back, but not happy with my Light Portion item.“

“Our family of five had an AMAZING meal and exceptional service last night! Every person commented how great their dish was after the very first bite! SO good! We highly recommend what we had! Salumi Formaggi Appetizer Fragola Salad (to share w/table) Fettuccine Alfredo W/Steak Filet Mignon Shrimp Scampi Lobster and Shrimp Linguine Tortellini w/Pomodoro Sauce Crème Brûlée Our son is a student at ABAC so we travel to Tifton a good bit. We can't wait to eat here again! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I'm a few days late on posting this but earlier this week we had the best customer service at Your Pie in Tifton. I took my son by here to get lunch after his doctor's appointment next door. I ordered 2 Caesar salads but they were completely out of Caesar dressing. A lady (I think may have been the owner) went next door and not only got more Caesar dressing for the restaurant, she gave me a whole bottle to take with me. Now if that's not service, I don't know what is. It's so refreshing in this time we're living to have some one not only portray great customer service but go above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect. Thank you for a great meal and the friendly service! We'll definitely be coming back here.“

“We got pizza from here for the first time this weekend while visiting family. The pizza was great! And the prices are reasonable. We will be back for sure.“

“Marquez was a great help, I’ve never been before and the food was fresh and served to me at a fast time frame. This is a peaceful environment, if you need some quiet time. I will come every chance I come to Tifton

Update Amber was such a great help. She let me know that on Tuesdays you guys offered Bogo pizza which is amazing because my family loves pizza, my experience this time was really good I was greeted. She’s very patient and she made sure I had all my needs taken care of. I will definitely be back.“