5 Best Italian Restaurants in Tifton

“the manager tonight was fantastic!! making sure my order was right and treated right. he’s the reason i will continue to be coming back!! today started out as a rough day but completely changed my night around. great service, keep it up!!“

“I usually don’t leave reviews, but after the fantastic food and service we experienced yesterday, I had to share.

First off, the ambiance is gorgeous—a warm, intimate, industrial vibe. Perfect for a date night, gathering with friends, or even a solo meal.

Our server, Briana (hope I got that spelling right!), was outstanding! She knew the menu inside out and gave such great recommendations that I found myself ordering dishes I’d never normally try—and every single one was worth it. I’m already planning to request her next time; I’ve never felt that way about a server before!

The food? Incredible. Everything came out hot, perfectly seasoned, and beautifully cooked. We started with the fried ravioli, and even as someone who usually skips red sauce, theirs was delicious. I had the surf and turf (not on the menu but worth asking for!), and my date ordered the lasagna, which came in the cutest little baking dish. He took one bite, closed his eyes, smiled, and I knew he was sold. I might have to sneak back for that lasagna myself!

Long story short, if you’re looking for top-notch service, a lovely atmosphere, and delicious food, this place is a must. Hope you enjoy it as much as we did!“

“Have eaten there many times. That should be self-explanatory.., we keep going back! Always tasty! Staff always courteous, they fix my pizza just the way we like and request. The only thing that sometimes is not at the same level as the pizza is the salad. Sometimes it’s a little wilty or kinda skimpy, once when asked about this they made a fresh salad on the spot. Can’t wait till my next visit.“

“We drive from Moultrie anytime we want a great pizza. Always pleasant and friendly employees. Love they it is locally owned and operated. Keep up the great work.“

“The food was excellent. I don't give the 5 stars because the bathroom was nasty and there's a guy working in sandals with the toenails of 2 inches each one, he's feet were so disgusting. But apparently that's normal for them cause the owner and the manager were there and nobody said a word.“