Sundae Cafe at Tybee

304 1st St, Tybee Island
(912) 786-7694

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Debra Myers

Our waitress was so great and respectful. But another waitress with dark hair kept putting her hands over the top of the drinks she was carrying instead of holding on bottom. It was a bit gross as she was touching alot of things that people had touched also.
I was glad we had our waitress
Food was good, just my filet mignon was a little dry.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Anthony King

Great food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood, Hush Puppies

Kathy Mianecki

If I could give more stars for the food I definitely would!!! We had the calamari appetizer, scallops entree and the banana pudding cheesecake for dessert. We thought that the calamari was fantastic but the shining ? was definitely the scallop's ???!! Best scallops I have ever had and I'm a foodie who travels.

I also want to say that we were the very last patrons to leave the restaurant, staff had started cleaning up from the night and EVERYONE was still smiling, pleasant and kind.

It was a wonderful experience, highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding Cheesecake, Seafood

Nanette Martin

The food here is AMAZING! I had the tenderloin, hubby had the halibut. The atmosphere is lovely, our server was great. I have nothing negative to say about this spot! ??✨⭐️Kudos to this establishment! Thanks to our friends Steven and Dr. MK for joining us for dins and introducing us to their local favorite! Ps try the key lime ?‍? pie…just sayin

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish, Steak

Melynda Brown

My family loves this place. We even love bring pans home for our friends and family

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger, Steak, Seafood

allan wilson

Good but kinda pricey for what it is

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Seafood

ra Ra

I made reservations at this establishment ,but unfortunately, the experience was less than welcoming. Upon arriving with my wife, we patiently waited by the entrance booth, but none of the employees acknowledged us or provided any information about our reservation, despite seeing us waiting. After about 10 minutes, I took it upon myself to inquire about our reservation with a staff member. I was told that another employee , who was busy at the bar, would assist us shortly. The woman at the bar avoided eye contact with me and turned away. Feeling a since of dread now, I returned to the entrance booth to find my wife visibly uncomfortable. A few minutes later, the woman at the bar gestured for us to come over to the bar and then she abruptly slapped her hand down at a space at the end of the bar and told us to be seated. My wife and I exchanged looks, and when the woman returned to take our order, I politely declined and informed her that we would not be dining in after all. Her response was simply 'I'm not offended.' There was definitely an air of hostility here, not just an over-booked establishment with over-worked staff.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Chad Bodie

Absolutely amazing. This is one of the top 5 restaurants we've eaten at. Service was great, food amazing, atmosphere was spot on. Small and intimate, but not crowded. Make reservations. Worth the drive from Charlotte.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish, Pimento Cheese Fritters, Steak, Seafood, Biscuits with Peach Jam

Mallory Putnam

Excellent meal! We went on a Monday night, early, and enjoyed the best meal we had in Tybee. I hate I didn't get pictures. My daughter got the filet mignon which was perfectly cooked and served with their potatoes side dish which is a must try and broccolini that even my picky daughter loved. My husband got the special that might, halibut with grits and he loved every bite of his quite large portion. I got the "grilled cheese" which is actually a low country chicken sandwich with perfectly friend chicken, collard greens, cheese, and pork belly all on yummy sourdough. It was perfection and was featured on DD&D. Crystal, our waitress, was wonderful and even helped us celebrate our birthdays and anniversary with an excellent peach cobbler. Service was great and good was great. Don't let the outside or gas station next door fool you. This is an upscale date night restaurant. I wish I had room to tell you so much more.

Dietary restrictions: They were careful to recall my nut allergy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish, Steak, Biscuits with Peach Jam

Danielle Clouse

We absolutely loved the food and the service!! I had the filet, blue cheese bread pudding, Brussels, hot honey jerk shrimp, and Reese’s PB pie and it was all fabulous!! The espresso martini was so good also. This restaurant was amazing, don’t hesitate to make a reservation and go when your on Tybee!

lynda thomas

Despite being smushed between a gas station and another shop, this place shined. Great food and service at the bar. Thanks for the warm hospitality, Christy!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy M

Amazing food and service! Don’t let the location fool you being in the shopping center with a gas station! It was like stepping into another world as you walked through the door. Classy, warm atmosphere. It was the best meal we had while in Tybee. Definitely will be back on our next visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Seafood

Robin G

This has been my favorite restaurant on the island for many years. I should have known things had changed when the bar seating was mostly empty and tables were available at 7. I ordered greens as an app (wierd, but I love them) and the catch of the day, halibut with mashed potatoes and brocollini. The greens were just awful. They were served in a full bowl of hot water and there was no hint of seasoning. I told the server they were bad, his response was, "I will relay that to the kitchen." He didn't even ask what was wrong. Biscuits were served with them, they came apart when you picked them up and had a cake like texture. It was 40 minutes between my app and dinner which finally came when I asked about it. The mashed potatoes were awesome, the Halibut was overcooked and the brocollini was tough and stringy. One of the table servers yelled every time she read the menu to customers (apparently, illiteracy has become an issue here?) or spoke to staff which became pretty oppressive with such a long wait for dinner.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Don Sechelski

Excellent locally sourced food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood

Mary Real Grieshaber

Best restaurant on Tybee.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...