The service is quick, fresh and got plenty of flavor. Not just dough, sauce and meat. The staff were cool, quick and def good at what they do. I didn’t expect to like a small pizzeria on a island as much as like there’s. I’m so glad I tried them.
krissybee1979
The pizza was pretty good. We got pepperoni. Top and square, pricey at $3. Overall we were satisfied and we would go back if we're in the area.
elizabethzmar
This place is popular so put your order in early if you don't want a long wait. Even in the off season they're busy.
Paul Alexander
Ordered on a Saturday night and wait time was less than 15 minutes. Excellent pizza 5 stars. Hot, fresh & delish!!
Ned P.
The pizza was good, better than usual in a touristy place. Service was good - very nice people even though there were short-staffed (who isn't). They were out of a few things, but we improvised. Since it was so close to where we were staying, we went twice, so I guess we liked it.
chris logan
Awesome take away/eat outside pizza place. It’s a 4 minute walk from the Dunes hotel. We walked up placed our order went to the store next door and got a beer. Sat down on the picnic tables and by the time the beer was gone the pizza was ready. The Deluxe was delicious and my kids got a pineapple bacon that was excellent as well. Great crust on the pizza. Kinda like mellow mushroom but I think it was better. It was still streaming by the time we walked back to the hotel. Definitely order again.
Thomas S.
Best pizza on the Island, maybe the best in the entire state!!! We ordered on likely the busiest night of the summer (July 2nd), 3 larges, (one regular pepperoni, one fancy veggie style (awesome), and one pineappley pacific rim style). They were All amazing! Must do again!
Greg C.
Best pizza on the island, bar none, and the most reasonably priced. Good NY style pizza.
Terry Walters
After a couple hours. They realized they forgot our order or failed to associate my name with our order. Craptastic sh!t show. Everyone wondering where their order is. Cardboard pizza is a step up from this joint. You’ll have time to walk to the store, look at all options, select an assortment of frozen pies, walk home, and cook assortment all in less time than this joint will take for a small (12”) deluxe pizza.
Derek R.
Pizza is decent enough, nothing special. If they want a tip up front when you pay and before they make the pizza, they should be a little friendlier. I felt the weight of her vengeful glare as she waited for me to pick what preset percentage I was to choose as a tip for any service I was yet to receive. I mean the service of handing me my pizza when it is ready. I felt as if the fate of the quality of my pizza was on the line. I was very conflicted on what to do. How do you not tip when they are about to make your pizza behind closed doors? It's carry out only as well so what am I tipping on exactly? I will never understand that concept. I don't tip the Arby's or McDonald kids. When I see that it makes me think the owner is putting the burden on the customer to pay their hourly rate. They did what I paid for with the price of the pizza, nothing more. The blonde in the bandana shirt should have a little more of a personality. She matter of fact told me , "No 12" pizzas". Nothing more. No explanation , no "I'm sorry Sir but our 12" pizza crust mode is broken" or "Our 12" pizza dough tosser banged in sick" . Or maybe she was frustrated that all 12" pizzas have to be up sold to the 16" pizzas for the July 4th holiday. They have two sizes BTW, 12" and 16". Maybe that's why she was so grouchy. Her conscious was getting to her. Not sure this place would survive in a town with more than 2 pizza joints or with a customer base whose taste buds aren't skewed by vape and alcohol. On a positive note, order was filled quickly, especially for the 4th of July. Hmmm, am I missing something here? 3 stars is very generous here. The other two employees were friendly and I do appreciate any young adult today wanting to work so I hope my 15% "tip" goes to them. Again, decent enough for the kids but adults know better. I would choose Pizza Hut, Domino's, Papa John's pizza any day over this pizza.
Best pizza had in ages. Totally recommend not leaving Tybee without trying this pizza!
Marisa McLeod
The pizza is great, but the service is lacking. We placed an order and when we came to pick it up half of it wasn’t there. They told us they’d “try to push it” ahead of the rest of the people who we ordering. After telling us several times that it would just be 15 minutes or that it was in the oven, we waited well over an hour for two cheese pizzas. Mistakes happen and I understand that Saturday nights are busy, but an apology for the mishap would have at least been nice.
Brian F
I gave 3 stars because I’m nice. The breadsticks are good, but are no award winner by any means. The pizza is a 3/10. Bottom line. Still not sure if that was real pizza crust or greasy cardboard. Their pizza flops around more than the spotted sea trout my dad caught before dinner. Honestly, I would have rather eaten that. They don’t offer plates either which is a darn shame. “Here eat our floppy pizza right off our dirty table tops, pal”. I’m sure that’s what they were thinking. I saw it in their eyes.
Jamie W.
We grabbed pizza and sat on the beach to watch the sunset. Not sure if it was the scenery combined with these delicious slices, but man... one of the best meals we had and so affordable! Eat there!
M M
Very tasty pizza, got my large order done really quick. They don’t have delivery, but the island is small so who cares! Will be back!
The service is quick, fresh and got plenty of flavor. Not just dough, sauce and meat. The staff were cool, quick and def good at what they do. I didn’t expect to like a small pizzeria on a island as much as like there’s. I’m so glad I tried them.
The pizza was pretty good. We got pepperoni. Top and square, pricey at $3. Overall we were satisfied and we would go back if we're in the area.
This place is popular so put your order in early if you don't want a long wait. Even in the off season they're busy.
Ordered on a Saturday night and wait time was less than 15 minutes. Excellent pizza 5 stars. Hot, fresh & delish!!
The pizza was good, better than usual in a touristy place. Service was good - very nice people even though there were short-staffed (who isn't). They were out of a few things, but we improvised. Since it was so close to where we were staying, we went twice, so I guess we liked it.
Awesome take away/eat outside pizza place. It’s a 4 minute walk from the Dunes hotel. We walked up placed our order went to the store next door and got a beer. Sat down on the picnic tables and by the time the beer was gone the pizza was ready. The Deluxe was delicious and my kids got a pineapple bacon that was excellent as well. Great crust on the pizza. Kinda like mellow mushroom but I think it was better. It was still streaming by the time we walked back to the hotel. Definitely order again.
Best pizza on the Island, maybe the best in the entire state!!! We ordered on likely the busiest night of the summer (July 2nd), 3 larges, (one regular pepperoni, one fancy veggie style (awesome), and one pineappley pacific rim style). They were All amazing! Must do again!
Best pizza on the island, bar none, and the most reasonably priced. Good NY style pizza.
After a couple hours. They realized they forgot our order or failed to associate my name with our order. Craptastic sh!t show. Everyone wondering where their order is. Cardboard pizza is a step up from this joint. You’ll have time to walk to the store, look at all options, select an assortment of frozen pies, walk home, and cook assortment all in less time than this joint will take for a small (12”) deluxe pizza.
Pizza is decent enough, nothing special. If they want a tip up front when you pay and before they make the pizza, they should be a little friendlier. I felt the weight of her vengeful glare as she waited for me to pick what preset percentage I was to choose as a tip for any service I was yet to receive. I mean the service of handing me my pizza when it is ready. I felt as if the fate of the quality of my pizza was on the line. I was very conflicted on what to do. How do you not tip when they are about to make your pizza behind closed doors? It's carry out only as well so what am I tipping on exactly? I will never understand that concept. I don't tip the Arby's or McDonald kids. When I see that it makes me think the owner is putting the burden on the customer to pay their hourly rate. They did what I paid for with the price of the pizza, nothing more. The blonde in the bandana shirt should have a little more of a personality. She matter of fact told me , "No 12" pizzas". Nothing more. No explanation , no "I'm sorry Sir but our 12" pizza crust mode is broken" or "Our 12" pizza dough tosser banged in sick" . Or maybe she was frustrated that all 12" pizzas have to be up sold to the 16" pizzas for the July 4th holiday. They have two sizes BTW, 12" and 16". Maybe that's why she was so grouchy. Her conscious was getting to her. Not sure this place would survive in a town with more than 2 pizza joints or with a customer base whose taste buds aren't skewed by vape and alcohol. On a positive note, order was filled quickly, especially for the 4th of July. Hmmm, am I missing something here? 3 stars is very generous here. The other two employees were friendly and I do appreciate any young adult today wanting to work so I hope my 15% "tip" goes to them. Again, decent enough for the kids but adults know better. I would choose Pizza Hut, Domino's, Papa John's pizza any day over this pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza had in ages. Totally recommend not leaving Tybee without trying this pizza!
The pizza is great, but the service is lacking. We placed an order and when we came to pick it up half of it wasn’t there. They told us they’d “try to push it” ahead of the rest of the people who we ordering. After telling us several times that it would just be 15 minutes or that it was in the oven, we waited well over an hour for two cheese pizzas. Mistakes happen and I understand that Saturday nights are busy, but an apology for the mishap would have at least been nice.
I gave 3 stars because I’m nice. The breadsticks are good, but are no award winner by any means. The pizza is a 3/10. Bottom line. Still not sure if that was real pizza crust or greasy cardboard. Their pizza flops around more than the spotted sea trout my dad caught before dinner. Honestly, I would have rather eaten that. They don’t offer plates either which is a darn shame. “Here eat our floppy pizza right off our dirty table tops, pal”. I’m sure that’s what they were thinking. I saw it in their eyes.
We grabbed pizza and sat on the beach to watch the sunset. Not sure if it was the scenery combined with these delicious slices, but man... one of the best meals we had and so affordable! Eat there!
Very tasty pizza, got my large order done really quick. They don’t have delivery, but the island is small so who cares! Will be back!