The Mill Pizza Buffet & Games OPEN EVERYDAY AT 11 AM (WEEKENDS TOO)

1337 Baytree Rd, Valdosta
(229) 469-4369

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Not Your Momma's Cinnamon Toast Pizza
The Blues Brothers Blueberry Pizza
The Blazer Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Monsters Inc Meat Lovers Pizza
The Mill Towne Supreme Pizza
Pizza and Salad from Buffet
Monster's Inc Meat Lovers
The Apple of My Eye Pizza
Mario Bros Supreme Pizza
Georgia on My Mind Pizza

Menu

The Mill's Signature Pizzas
Capt Jack's Cheese Pizza
Our marinara sauce is topped with mozzarella and baked to a crisp, golden perfection. Each bite would absolutely satisfy any cheese lovers craving.
SGT. Pepperoni's Pizza
Not so lonely are pepperonis. They atop our marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
The UFO Pepperoni Pizza
Our marinara sauce is loaded with lots of zesty pepeproni, sizzling jalapenos, melted mozzarella and an unidentified topping.
Hawaii 5-O Pizza
Our marinara sauce is topped with fresh, sweet pineapples, ham slices, a sweet sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Blazer Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Some like it hot. Our special sauce is topped with mozzarella, spicy chicken, and drizzled with a ranch dressing.
That White Cheese Pizza
Simple, but ohhhh so delicious is our special white sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.
Cheese 2 My Macaroni Pizza
For all the macaroni and cheese lovers. Our special sauce is covered with oodles of cheesy noodles.
Veggie Tales Pizza
Our marinara sauce is topped with mozzarella cheese and fresh vegetables: diced onions, mushrooms, green bell pepers, diced tomatoes, and black olives.
Zombies BBQ Chicken Pizza
A scary barbecue sauce with a hint of sweetness is topped with diced chicken, diced onions, covered with a mix of cheese and baked to bubbly goodness.
Mill Towne Supreme Pizza
Our marinara sauce is topped with mozzarella cheese, sausage, pepperoni, diced onions, mushrooms, green bell peppers and black olives.
Italian Stallion Pizza
Our special sauce is topped with mozzarella, beef, onions and green peppers and is our version of a Philly cheese steak.
Mario Bros Supreme Pizza
Our special sauce is topped with mozzarella cheese, sausage, pepeproni, mushrooms and green peppers.
Popeye's Spinach Pizza
Our Alfredo sauce is topped with spinach and mozzarella cheese.
Mr. Potato Head Pizza
Our special sauce is topped with sliced potatoes, crispy bacon and mozzarella cheese.
Monsters INC. Meat Lovers Pizza
Our marinara sauce is topped with mozzarella cheese and generous amounts of pepperoni, ham, beef, bacon and sausage.
Porky's Pizza
Our special BBQ sauce is topped with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, ham slices and crispy bacon.

Appetizers and More
Garlic Knots
Comes with 6 garlic knots and one 4 oz marinara. These garlic knots are super soft, airy, and fluffy, and they are full of buttery garlic flavor and aroma.
Jalapeno Poppers
Gooey, creamy and oh-so delicious - our Jalapeno Poppers are the perfect side to add a bit of zing to your meal. Comes with one 2 oz container of our special Snazzy Razzy sauce!!
"J Loves" Guilty Pleasure
A Maple Bacon pizza delight
"Say Cheese" Bread Stick
Comes with 4 oz of marinara sauce.
"The Big" Pretzels
Comes with one 2 oz sauce of your choice.....marinara, mustard or nacho cheese!
Ultimate Cheesy Baked Spaghetti
Great for Adults and Kids LOVE it, too! We use THIN Spaghetti Pasta AND it is Topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan Cheese, Garlic Butter and Parmesan Cheese!
Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Standard comes with Cheese
Side Salad
Mixed Lettuce, Tomatoes, Bacon Bits, Croutons, 2 Pack of Wafer Crackers

Make Your Own Pizza

Make your Own Pizza
Begins with our Basic Captain Jack

Dessert Pizzas
Strawberry Fields Forever
An awesome strawberry pizza. Full of strawberries and topped with our sweet white icing.
The Apple of My Eye
Our version of the best apple pie you will ever eat and topped with our sweet white icing.
The Blues Brothers Blueberry
The best blueberry pizza pie. Loaded with blueberries and topped with our sweet white icing.
Georgia on My Mind
A Georgia must, a scrumptious peach pizza pie and topped with our sweet white icing.
Not Your Momma's Cinnamon Toast
Last on the list, but one our customers most favorites. Cinnamon toast has never tasted so good.
"J Loves" Guilty Pleasure
If you love bacon....you will love this!!! A Maple Bacon pizza delight

Additional Sauces

Sauces

Drinks
Soft Drink
Gallon of Tea
Apple Juice
Bottled Water
Milk

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+53 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+52 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pizza was good for thin crust salad bar was good. They also have spaghetti and nachos and cheese which was also good. Love the decor. The would be a great place for kids birthday parties .
October 2025
The pizza was okay, nothing special but for all you can eat the price was not bad. My issue is the arcade. My son earned 100ish tickets but only got credit for 30. The young lady working at the prize area said they don’t count all the tickets just some kind of percentage. This is absolutely ridiculous and I have never been somewhere that does that. Absolute insane, I would never allow my child back to this arcade. I don’t know if they do that to save money on prizes or what...
October 2025
Two of six grandchildren came to visit. Did a Google search for Game/Arcade Room and this establishment showed in the search. We drove to Remerton, Ga. and found a pleasant surprise. It is a quaint establishment, more than reasonable pricing but the plus one for me was how friendly the staff was. Come to find out he was the actual owner. I recommend! The buffet consisted of a variety of pizza, spaghetti, dessert pizza, salad bar and soft served ice cream. The games are children...
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Mulligan's Sports Bar - 1919 Baytree Pl
Sports Bar
Omelette House - 1337 Baytree Rd
American, Coffee & Tea, Waffles
Jimmy John's - 1337 Baytree Rd
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food

The Mill Pizza Buffet & Games OPEN EVERYDAY AT 11 AM (WEEKENDS TOO)

1337 Baytree Rd, Valdosta, GA 31602
(229) 469-4369