Starfish Home Bakery

I was visiting Tybee to celebrate my mother’s 70th birthday and wanted to make sure she had a special cake to accompany her special day. The cake was all we could have hoped for and more. The best part was it reminded her of the decedent chocolate cake her mother made her when she was young. We all highly recommend!!

Cathy recently made us two delicious cakes. The red velvet was delicious and the carrot cake was even better. Her lemon blueberry loaf and cinnamon buns were also amazing. She delivered to our door as well. Highly recommend her treats if you’re in the Savannah/Tybee area.

Starfish Home Bakery recently prepared two amazing cakes for my husband's 97th birthday celebrations. One was a 2-layer vanilla cake and the other was a huge sheet cake, both with real, heavy whipped cream and beautiful, fresh strawberries. The sheet cake was marbled with a fresh strawberry puree and was garnished with fresh strawberries and mint leaves. They were both sooo good! I highly recommend Cathy Liberatori and Starfish Home Bakery. She uses only the freshest ingredients and bakes in her emaculately clean kitchen. 💕

Soooo yummy!! Cathy helped me with a birthday cake for my husband and it turned out amazing. One of the best strawberry cakes we have ever had! Her communication was incredible and she made the whole process from order to pickup as easy as can be! Totally 100000% recommend!

Delicious and so easy to order. I just picked up a couple of frosted heart birthday cookies, rice krispie treats and brownies. The packaging is always so nice it's such a treat. The sourdough loaf was still warm so I was able to get one while I was there. Highly highly recommend!

I ordered three 6 inch cakes for a family birthday: chocolate with vanilla buttercream, chocolate with peanut butter buttercream, and lemon. All were moist delicious! The staff was very accommodating despite the special order and the fact that I wanted it the day before Thanksgiving. I would highly recommend Starfish Home Bakery! Thank you so much!

By far, THE best cinnamon rolls I’ve ever eaten! I picked them up still warm from the oven. They are soft and covered in the most delicious icing. Price was very reasonable. Can’t wait to try something else.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll

By far, THE best cinnamon rolls I’ve ever eaten! Picked them up still warm from the oven. They are soft and covered in the most delicious icing. Price was very reasonable. Can’t wait to try more!

The cinnamon rolls and the cupcakes were amazing. I was camping, placed my order, it was delivered on time the next day. Can't wait to try other goodies. 5 stars for sure. Thanks for making my day.

Food: 5

Service: 5

I highly recommend Starfish Home Bakery!! All items were DELICIOUS!! The packaging was lovely and professional and the service was above and beyond! Thank you for helping us celebrate my mom’s birthday!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll

Best Strawberry cake anyone in our group had ever had!! Also ordered a dozen chocolate on chocolate cupcakes and they were snatched up quickly! Wonderful service, so helpful in coordinating what I needed to get and helping deliver over the busy holiday weekend. Cannot recommend enough!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cathy makes the most delectable sweets! I ordered a Pistachio Pound Cake for my dad’s 93rd birthday in FL - He loved it, we all loved it! It was ready within 48 hrs., was buttery moist, delicious glaze with great pistachio flavor! She carefully & beautifuy packaged it to travel too! We also loved her Pistacio Quickbread. We highly Starfish Home Bakery! Look forward to ordering again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So impressed with everything about the lemon cake I ordered for my mom’s birthday. It was absolutely delicious! Each of us had to have a second slice, it was so good!

It was the most delicious carrot cake!! We all loved it especially my nonverbal son who’d never had carrot cake. When asked to rate it, he spelled “10”!!! Of course, we suspected this when he ate 2 big pieces in about 20 seconds!?

Oh.my.gosh! The lemon cake with lemon icing is to die for! She made it for my granddaughters birthday and it was by far, the best cake either of us has ever eaten! I highly recommend Starfish Home Bakery!