5 were gone within 3 minutes of arriving home with pistachio cupcakes! These are amazingly sweet moist and delicious!!! Price is insanely inexpensive for the quality!
Chelsea
I stumbled upon Starfish Home Bakery whileSearching for a cake, and I’m SO glad I did! The customer service was excellent! Quick to respond and very friendly! The cake was perfection! There were so many compliments and I gladly recommended Starfish home bakery! Cathy has all 5 star rating for a reason!! She is simply the best!! Will be a returning customer for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelsea Ward Posateri
I stumbled upon Starfish Home Bakery while
Searching for a cake, and I’m SO glad I did! The customer service was excellent! Quick to respond and very friendly! The cake was perfection! There were so many compliments and I gladly recommended Starfish home bakery! Will be a returning customer for sure!
Joel Snipes
If they are offering the pistachio cake, run don’t walk. So
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
Bobbie Sue LeFebvre
I recently ordered a birthday cake very last minute and she was able to accommodate me! The cake was very moist and delicious. I loved the packaging. I definitely recommend Starfish Home Bakery and will order again next time I’m in town!!
Steve Winiarczyk
Excellent cake. We will definitely buy another cake from Starfish Bakery. Cathy is the best!
Ashley Cali
Requested a keto birthday cake. It was DELICIOUS! Super fresh, moist and so flavorful. Highly recommend starfish bakery!Dietary restrictions: Keto friendly and delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clare Zeigler
I recently ordered a loaf of Irish Soda Bread and a pistachio loaf cake. Both were delicious. The bread was still warm when I picked it up and my husband and I promptly ate half the loaf! I am happy to support our local Starfish Home Bakery and will be ordering again very soon!
Ashley Cali
Best keto cake, ever! It was fresh, moist and super tasty. Will definitely return!
Regina Meeler
I cannot say enough about Starfish Home Bakery. I have loved every dessert I have tried. Cathy really helped me out with mylast event. I was not sure what to get. She came up with a tray of multiple desserts that not only was delicious, but was beautifully presented. Wonderful!!!
Ordered a gorgeous vanilla funfetti cake and cupcakes for a baby shower. Everyone raved about how amazing everything tasted!
Food: 5
Clare Zeigler
After seeing pictures on Facebook of beautiful cakes, desserts, and breads, I decided to try out the Starfish Home Bakery. The carrot cake was by far the best one I've ever had! Moist and delicious, and beautiful too. I can't wait to try more of her delectable desserts!
Sandra Parrott
Cathy Liberatori is an artist! She makes absolutely the most beautiful, delicious cakes and pastries ever. You can proudly serve anything she prepares. I highly recommend Starfish Home Bakery! :-)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Schnabel
Our cake from Starfish Home Bakery was so delicious. We enjoyed it and all our guests did as well. The cake was decorated so beautifully and my daughter loved that there was a unicorn decoration on top. Thank you again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Cucchi
Been hooked on the cinnamon rolls! I ordered the German chocolate cake yesterday for my daughter’s birthday. Oh my, so good! Will be trying the pumpkin pie today that I also picked up yesterday ?GetYouOneYou’ll love it, and Cathy!
5 were gone within 3 minutes of arriving home with pistachio cupcakes! These are amazingly sweet moist and delicious!!! Price is insanely inexpensive for the quality!
I stumbled upon Starfish Home Bakery whileSearching for a cake, and I’m SO glad I did! The customer service was excellent! Quick to respond and very friendly! The cake was perfection! There were so many compliments and I gladly recommended Starfish home bakery! Cathy has all 5 star rating for a reason!! She is simply the best!! Will be a returning customer for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stumbled upon Starfish Home Bakery while Searching for a cake, and I’m SO glad I did! The customer service was excellent! Quick to respond and very friendly! The cake was perfection! There were so many compliments and I gladly recommended Starfish home bakery! Will be a returning customer for sure!
If they are offering the pistachio cake, run don’t walk. So
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie
I recently ordered a birthday cake very last minute and she was able to accommodate me! The cake was very moist and delicious. I loved the packaging. I definitely recommend Starfish Home Bakery and will order again next time I’m in town!!
Excellent cake. We will definitely buy another cake from Starfish Bakery. Cathy is the best!
Requested a keto birthday cake. It was DELICIOUS! Super fresh, moist and so flavorful. Highly recommend starfish bakery!Dietary restrictions: Keto friendly and delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently ordered a loaf of Irish Soda Bread and a pistachio loaf cake. Both were delicious. The bread was still warm when I picked it up and my husband and I promptly ate half the loaf! I am happy to support our local Starfish Home Bakery and will be ordering again very soon!
Best keto cake, ever! It was fresh, moist and super tasty. Will definitely return!
I cannot say enough about Starfish Home Bakery. I have loved every dessert I have tried. Cathy really helped me out with mylast event. I was not sure what to get. She came up with a tray of multiple desserts that not only was delicious, but was beautifully presented. Wonderful!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered a gorgeous vanilla funfetti cake and cupcakes for a baby shower. Everyone raved about how amazing everything tasted!
Food: 5
After seeing pictures on Facebook of beautiful cakes, desserts, and breads, I decided to try out the Starfish Home Bakery. The carrot cake was by far the best one I've ever had! Moist and delicious, and beautiful too. I can't wait to try more of her delectable desserts!
Cathy Liberatori is an artist! She makes absolutely the most beautiful, delicious cakes and pastries ever. You can proudly serve anything she prepares. I highly recommend Starfish Home Bakery! :-)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our cake from Starfish Home Bakery was so delicious. We enjoyed it and all our guests did as well. The cake was decorated so beautifully and my daughter loved that there was a unicorn decoration on top. Thank you again!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been hooked on the cinnamon rolls! I ordered the German chocolate cake yesterday for my daughter’s birthday. Oh my, so good! Will be trying the pumpkin pie today that I also picked up yesterday ?GetYouOneYou’ll love it, and Cathy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5