A great casual seafood restaurant in Kihei. I come here every time I come to Maui. I recommend getting the Cajun style Mahi Mahi. Everything is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arika P
The food was ok. I had shrimp tacos and my daughter's fish taco. The shrimp taco was better. Cole slaw was blah. For the prices, I would try another place. There is limited seating and we had to share our table with another party. Overall it was ok!
Tracy Holick
Best fish in Kihei. You cant go wrong. We got the opakapaka grilled and fish and chips! Been here many times, it never disappoints. Come early!
Gianina Mastroeni
This is a great place to get a few favorite fresh fish/seafood dishes. Starting from Blackened Sashimi, Burgers, Seafood Pasta, Salads and more. Dishes are super fresh and big. Very tasty and well made. Considering sharing if you are not a huge eater since everything is big and extremely reasonable for the price. Place has opened seating tables outside only but it does have covering. No inside tables. Ambiance is like eating right at the beach super relax. They do offer margaritas and have a nice wine selection to be a beach restaurant. Service is fast. We did come at a quieter time when there are no lines, but be aware that it does have its rush hour with lines to order and pay. You order at the counter, pay and then sit down at an available table.
My favourite restaurant in Paia. The seafood is always excellent n's reasonably priced. It has become a little crowded and there is always a line for ordering food which stretches onto the pavement - and often around the corner.
Elaine
Delicious & fresh fish, generous portions!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alessandro Tempia Calvino
Best fish restaurant I tried on the island in my opinion. The fish plate is great, with a choice of 4 fishes and 4 styles of preparation. Prices are good compared to other similar restaurants on the island. I highly recommend
Adam Tomczyk
Great staff, lines that are a bit longer but it goes quickly. Overall good food.
Recommended dishes: Seafood Pasta, Blackened Mahi Mahi with Cajun Rice and Coleslaw
Expect to wait in line for excellent fish at reasonable prices. There's not a ton of seating but enough and there are lots of other places to explore within walking distance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Gabe Harris
Easily the best place my wife and I ate this week. We came multiple times and tried multiple renditions of different fish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aana W
Delicious food and friendly staff. I eat here every time I come to Maui. It’s the first place I want to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jordi Fabrega
If you are looking for ultra-fresh, high-quality seafood 🐟 Kihei, Paia Fish Market is an absolute must-visit! 🏝🌊 The fish here is consistently excellent perfectly cooked, flaky, and packed with flavor. 🔥🐟 While their dinner plates are great, the real star of the show is the fish sandwich option (you can choose your catch, like Mahi Mahi or Ono). 🥇🥖 What takes the sandwich to an entirely different level is their house tartar sauce. It is honestly amazing, perfectly creamy, and pairs beautifully with the fresh fish! 🤤 Sauce lovers, rejoice! 🙌🥣 The kitchen staff runs a tight ship, so the service is incredibly quick ⚡💨 even when they are slammed. That speed is a massive plus because this place gets very crowded! 👥👥 The interior has a casual, counter-service setup with minimal seating, meaning finding an open table to dine in can be a real challenge during peak hours. 🪑❌ If the indoor seating area is packed out, just order your fish sandwich to go and take it down to the beach for a classic Maui picnic! 🏖🌅🧺
chris anderson
Incredibly fresh fish / food every time we’ve visited. The team is incredibly friendly and although busy plenty of seating.
A great casual seafood restaurant in Kihei. I come here every time I come to Maui. I recommend getting the Cajun style Mahi Mahi. Everything is delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was ok. I had shrimp tacos and my daughter's fish taco. The shrimp taco was better. Cole slaw was blah. For the prices, I would try another place. There is limited seating and we had to share our table with another party. Overall it was ok!
Best fish in Kihei. You cant go wrong. We got the opakapaka grilled and fish and chips! Been here many times, it never disappoints. Come early!
This is a great place to get a few favorite fresh fish/seafood dishes.
Starting from Blackened Sashimi, Burgers, Seafood Pasta, Salads and more.
Dishes are super fresh and big. Very tasty and well made.
Considering sharing if you are not a huge eater since everything is big and extremely reasonable for the price.
Place has opened seating tables outside only but it does have covering. No inside tables.
Ambiance is like eating right at the beach super relax.
They do offer margaritas and have a nice wine selection to be a beach restaurant.
Service is fast. We did come at a quieter time when there are no lines, but be aware that it does have its rush hour with lines to order and pay.
You order at the counter, pay and then sit down at an available table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yum Yum Yum!!! Try everything!! It was delicious!
Absolutely delicious 😋 Ono, Mahi Mahi, delicious 👍
My favourite restaurant in Paia. The seafood is always excellent n's reasonably priced. It has become a little crowded and there is always a line for ordering food which stretches onto the pavement - and often around the corner.
Delicious & fresh fish, generous portions!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best fish restaurant I tried on the island in my opinion. The fish plate is great, with a choice of 4 fishes and 4 styles of preparation. Prices are good compared to other similar restaurants on the island. I highly recommend
Great staff, lines that are a bit longer but it goes quickly. Overall good food.
Recommended dishes: Seafood Pasta, Blackened Mahi Mahi with Cajun Rice and Coleslaw
Restaurantji Recommends
Expect to wait in line for excellent fish at reasonable prices. There's not a ton of seating but enough and there are lots of other places to explore within walking distance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Easily the best place my wife and I ate this week. We came multiple times and tried multiple renditions of different fish!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food and friendly staff. I eat here every time I come to Maui. It’s the first place I want to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you are looking for ultra-fresh, high-quality seafood 🐟 Kihei, Paia Fish Market is an absolute must-visit! 🏝🌊 The fish here is consistently excellent perfectly cooked, flaky, and packed with flavor. 🔥🐟
While their dinner plates are great, the real star of the show is the fish sandwich option (you can choose your catch, like Mahi Mahi or Ono). 🥇🥖 What takes the sandwich to an entirely different level is their house tartar sauce. It is honestly amazing, perfectly creamy, and pairs beautifully with the fresh fish! 🤤 Sauce lovers, rejoice! 🙌🥣
The kitchen staff runs a tight ship, so the service is incredibly quick ⚡💨 even when they are slammed. That speed is a massive plus because this place gets very crowded! 👥👥 The interior has a casual, counter-service setup with minimal seating, meaning finding an open table to dine in can be a real challenge during peak hours. 🪑❌
If the indoor seating area is packed out, just order your fish sandwich to go and take it down to the beach for a classic Maui picnic! 🏖🌅🧺
Incredibly fresh fish / food every time we’ve visited. The team is incredibly friendly and although busy plenty of seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...