We enjoyed the food and music here . We visited during our honeymoon. I hope they reopen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips Mahi Mahi Sandwich
frosty
Had the special of the night and it was excellent. We were seated right above the ocean and the view as the sun set was lovely. The server was excellent. Thank you Desi for your food and drink menu suggestions and excellent service.
FiveToe
Great sashimi and Ceasars to start, prime rib and Mahi Mahi for the meals, loved it all. Good service and the unmatched view of the sunset and there is nowhere better on Maui than the Old Lahaina Fish Company. This place is a must to visit when coming to Maui. It just leaves you happy.
AmandaF
We went here for my daughters birthday dinner. It was a wonderful experience! The location and decor were perfect. The hostess and our waiter were fantastic! And the food...Amazing!!! I had the Mahi Mahi and I am still thinking about it! Thank you Lahaina Fish Co. for making my daughters birthday dinner such a wonderful experience ❤️
John Thompson
Fantastic dinner at sunset. We were upstairs with a great view of the water and sunset. I had the Ahi tuna and split the Seasonal Farm Salad. Best tuna ever. Great drink selection, friendly wait staff, and excellent Chief.
What a fun little place right on the water with amazing views and delicious food. We had a table on the water for sunset. Brett, our waiter, and the ENTIRE staff from hostess to drink server knew about my allergies and I felt so comfortable eating there without an allergic reaction. The fresh fish was incredible and the wine menu was extensive and very reasonably priced.
Food was wonderful. The whole reservation felt rushed. Seemed as if they wanted us in and out like a quick service restaurant rather than a nice sit down restaurant. Texted that the table was ready before the reservation time and before we even checked in. Then followed up with a phone call. We were still in the parking lot, and not late to the reservation. Service was attentive, but seemed aggressive. They cleared the appetizer plates before we were finished with the appetizers we ordered. It just didn't seem to be a friendly environment and we felt rushed out. Our entire dinner with appetizers and drinks and dinner for 5 of us was under an hour.
Heard great things about this restaurant. Nothing spectacular. I broke the rule and ordered the rib eye from a fish place. It was undercooked, not hot when arriving to table and lacking flavor. Opah was good but we asked for blackened and it came out grilled. Arugula salad was good and the seafood chowder was okay. Mac nut pie was overrated.
RobinZ
My husband and I went here for our anniversary dinner. The staff is very friendly, the food was AMAZING and we even got to watch from our table as the sea turtles were swimming around in the ocean.
Rebecca Dellavilla
Like most Front St restaurants, you're paying for the view. We arrived around 4:30pm and had no wait without a reservation.The food was good, but our table spent almost $500 for 1 app, 4 entrees, and 2 alcoholic drinks. We were all hungry an hour later.Our server was (presumably) high, which normally wouldn't be an issue for us but it was likely the reason he was inattentive, flighty, and had a weird habit of talking as he walked away from the table lol
Lahaina Fish Company never disappoints. Food is awesome; local fish is super fresh and prepared perfectly. Location overlooking Lahaina Harbor is fantastic, and service is excellent. Our server, Archer, knew the menu completely and answered all our questions. Drink menu is very good as well. We had lunch, but the dinner menu (offered all day long) is as good as any fish/seafood restaurant in Lahaina or Kaanapali. Really enjoyed it
Kpearl
Not very busy but we only came for appetizers and drinks. The selection was just okay. Seems to be a slow day in Lahaina. Been here quite often and it's usually more lively. Will be back in six months to check it out again.
ScottF
Had a great meal with Archer as our entertaining server. We rarely dine out & chose Lahaina Fish Co for the view & fresh fish of course. Sashimi was bright red & fresh as could be. Mahimahi sandwiches were delish & fries done crisp & served hot. Also had the Li Hing Margarita which was so Ono. Highly recommend dining here, little pricey but you get what you pay for & everything is expensive these days.
Happyandfull
Worst place We have ever ate in Maui. Fish was so over cooked I almost couldn't cut it with a knife, spareribs had so much bbq sauce smothering them, Ahi nachos were so stale, nothing had any flavor BLAND BLAND BLAND. expensive and it was horrible! We try to find something good about our meals but not here, the view was nice but that's the best thing I can say!
Birthday
Great location and scenery for this restaurant. The service we great and our server was patient and helpful. I wish we would have gotten her name to recognize here on here. The food was pretty good 4/5 stars. The seafood chowder was very good for the price. It came out very hot which was great. The only negative about this meal was that it came out lukewarm instead of warm or hot. I was surprised the fries weren't hotter as there weren't many people on the restaurant. Overall we enjoyed this visit.
We enjoyed the food and music here . We visited during our honeymoon. I hope they reopen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips Mahi Mahi Sandwich
Had the special of the night and it was excellent. We were seated right above the ocean and the view as the sun set was lovely. The server was excellent. Thank you Desi for your food and drink menu suggestions and excellent service.
Great sashimi and Ceasars to start, prime rib and Mahi Mahi for the meals, loved it all. Good service and the unmatched view of the sunset and there is nowhere better on Maui than the Old Lahaina Fish Company. This place is a must to visit when coming to Maui. It just leaves you happy.
We went here for my daughters birthday dinner. It was a wonderful experience! The location and decor were perfect. The hostess and our waiter were fantastic! And the food...Amazing!!! I had the Mahi Mahi and I am still thinking about it! Thank you Lahaina Fish Co. for making my daughters birthday dinner such a wonderful experience ❤️
Fantastic dinner at sunset. We were upstairs with a great view of the water and sunset. I had the Ahi tuna and split the Seasonal Farm Salad. Best tuna ever. Great drink selection, friendly wait staff, and excellent Chief.
What a fun little place right on the water with amazing views and delicious food. We had a table on the water for sunset. Brett, our waiter, and the ENTIRE staff from hostess to drink server knew about my allergies and I felt so comfortable eating there without an allergic reaction. The fresh fish was incredible and the wine menu was extensive and very reasonably priced.
Food was wonderful. The whole reservation felt rushed. Seemed as if they wanted us in and out like a quick service restaurant rather than a nice sit down restaurant. Texted that the table was ready before the reservation time and before we even checked in. Then followed up with a phone call. We were still in the parking lot, and not late to the reservation. Service was attentive, but seemed aggressive. They cleared the appetizer plates before we were finished with the appetizers we ordered. It just didn't seem to be a friendly environment and we felt rushed out. Our entire dinner with appetizers and drinks and dinner for 5 of us was under an hour.
Heard great things about this restaurant. Nothing spectacular. I broke the rule and ordered the rib eye from a fish place. It was undercooked, not hot when arriving to table and lacking flavor. Opah was good but we asked for blackened and it came out grilled. Arugula salad was good and the seafood chowder was okay. Mac nut pie was overrated.
My husband and I went here for our anniversary dinner. The staff is very friendly, the food was AMAZING and we even got to watch from our table as the sea turtles were swimming around in the ocean.
Like most Front St restaurants, you're paying for the view. We arrived around 4:30pm and had no wait without a reservation.The food was good, but our table spent almost $500 for 1 app, 4 entrees, and 2 alcoholic drinks. We were all hungry an hour later.Our server was (presumably) high, which normally wouldn't be an issue for us but it was likely the reason he was inattentive, flighty, and had a weird habit of talking as he walked away from the table lol
Restaurantji Recommends
Lahaina Fish Company never disappoints. Food is awesome; local fish is super fresh and prepared perfectly. Location overlooking Lahaina Harbor is fantastic, and service is excellent. Our server, Archer, knew the menu completely and answered all our questions. Drink menu is very good as well. We had lunch, but the dinner menu (offered all day long) is as good as any fish/seafood restaurant in Lahaina or Kaanapali. Really enjoyed it
Not very busy but we only came for appetizers and drinks. The selection was just okay. Seems to be a slow day in Lahaina. Been here quite often and it's usually more lively. Will be back in six months to check it out again.
Had a great meal with Archer as our entertaining server. We rarely dine out & chose Lahaina Fish Co for the view & fresh fish of course. Sashimi was bright red & fresh as could be. Mahimahi sandwiches were delish & fries done crisp & served hot. Also had the Li Hing Margarita which was so Ono. Highly recommend dining here, little pricey but you get what you pay for & everything is expensive these days.
Worst place We have ever ate in Maui. Fish was so over cooked I almost couldn't cut it with a knife, spareribs had so much bbq sauce smothering them, Ahi nachos were so stale, nothing had any flavor BLAND BLAND BLAND. expensive and it was horrible! We try to find something good about our meals but not here, the view was nice but that's the best thing I can say!
Great location and scenery for this restaurant. The service we great and our server was patient and helpful. I wish we would have gotten her name to recognize here on here. The food was pretty good 4/5 stars. The seafood chowder was very good for the price. It came out very hot which was great. The only negative about this meal was that it came out lukewarm instead of warm or hot. I was surprised the fries weren't hotter as there weren't many people on the restaurant. Overall we enjoyed this visit.