We are picky about pizza but this was pretty good. Relatively thick crust pie. Kind of stuffy inside the place though and no alcohol allowed on patio so they’d benefit from AC. Per le very friendly there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
David Ditta
We ate here three separate times and happy each time. Definitely one of the cheaper options and a non greasy thin pizza is never a bad idea.I just wish the had garlic dipping sauce. I guess it’s not a “thing” in Maui but other than that, no complaints
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Denise W
Love how tasty the pizzas are and definitely worth the price. They also have a lot of varieties too.
Cindy
Ask for extra sauce paid for it but didn't get it! This usually never happens but it happened the last time.I love the food especially the chicken caesar salad but the prices are outrageous. Should at least offer Kamaina discount to us locals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Melissa M
Friendly and happy staff, amazing crust, affordable local beer and wine prices. I had been here in late June with a raging appetite as we had been doing many outdoor and water activities since the morning. My cheese-less calzone absolutely hit the spot and my friends and family's pizza looked extremely appetizing. They were loaded with toppings on their perfectly baked crust. While in Maui last week I knew I savored returning there for another cheese-less calzone. I was not disappointed. Their marinara sauce was expertly balanced. The only drawback was their room for dining in or on their lanai. However it was worth the drive for a late dinner from Kihei!
pbk040608
This was the best pizza we have had in a really long time. Crust was not soggy, sauce was simple but really flavorful and toppings were fresh. Cheesy garlic bread with marinara was also great. Love that the place was really low key and off the beaten path-the focus is on the food. This will be our first choice the next time we end up in Maui.
Scott Kielty
We went to Prison Street Pizza for an early dinner before the rush. We ordered a cheese calazone and a carnivore pizza. The calazone was out 5 minutes before the pizza and cold on the inside. The cheese wasn't melted so I sent it back to continue cooking. The large pizza came out and it was huge! It could easily serve 3-4 adults. We ended up waiting 5 minutes past the pizza to come out to get the calazone back.The waitress asked if we were ready for our tab and we replied yes. 10 minutes go by and nothing. I ended up going to the front to ask for our tab so we can pay and leave. Other people were wondering where their food was so we weren't the only ones hoping for better service.Overall, the pizza was good - large slices, good ingredients, and the isnald vibe was cool but the service was pretty miserable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Kyle Sela
We ate here last night on 4th of July which I have to assume was the busiest night of the year in Lahaina. This is where Maui has their firework celebration. The staff was cool, calm and polite despite a huge crowd and line out the door. We got a large ham and pineapple pizza for $24.50 and it was really good. Crisp crust, great sauce and plenty of toppings. My son had a California cheeseburger which he devoured. If we are in Lahaina again we would definitely go back for pizza again. The building is small and really cute but I gave 4 stars because it felt cramped...but that was likely because it was just so busy. Definitely recommend this place
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
WillZoeAsh
I rarely give bad reviews here but as a local in Lahaina town this place has been a big disappointment. Today is my husbands birthday and all he wanted to do is to relax and have a nice pizza for dinner. In the last few times we ordered here our order did not come as expected. Tonight was the last straw. We got there plenty of time for pickup. My husband still stood in line for 10mins which was understandable but when we got home our pizza was burnt and very dry. The Serpico pizza had some burnt spots on the bottom and extremely very dry. The Freight Train pizza supposed to have some BBQ sauce but instead all we can taste was the pork and the crust was burnt all over and very dry. We are all for supporting our local restaurants and understand that most of them struggles from shortage of staffs and with the inflation it can’t be that easy for small businesses to stay afloat. As locals we have already been dealing with the high cost of living, we understand this... All we ask for supporting our local businesses is to be treated with respect. We also understand the cost of food in restaurants had increased and don't mind paying this but good grief $70 for both pizza! we expect at least a decent meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Curt W
The price is fantastic..great option for cheaper eats in area which it's quite pricey.Pizza is tasty and fresh not out if the world amazing.. but for the price the Quality is perfectly fine. Crust is more on thin style. So for others leaving poor reviews in food ..perhaps they there are some expectation issues...we found the Ingredients were fresh and the pizza sauce was tangy..crust was not soft ot soggy. Mozzarella sticks were just ok.The staff are friendly and service was great. Would return for eats.
Can’t recommend this place at all. Food was below average, took a long time 45+ minutes and was very pricey. Poor customer service. The family next to us also waiting a long time.
Bapiraju Yarlagadda
Try garlic bread with cheese … and also try grandma’s alfredo pizza
Celeste Villarreal
Fantastic pizza!! I wish I had gotten a picture, but I didn’t! My family got a pepperoni (always a staple) and the Grandma’s for take out. Highly recommend the Grandma’s pizza (Alfredo sauce, chicken breast, spinach, garlic, mozzarella). Both pizzas are great fresh from the oven as well as cold leftovers! Also great to take in a cooler to the beach for a picnic!
Nargiza М
Love this place! Pizza was delicious! Mango tree is beautiful ?Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza is good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert A
Great pizza with a thin crust. Also tried a salad and the garlic bread. The salad was wonderful with many items like artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and nice Maui onions. The garlic bread is a most with great seasonings. Many pizza options to choose from.
We are picky about pizza but this was pretty good. Relatively thick crust pie. Kind of stuffy inside the place though and no alcohol allowed on patio so they’d benefit from AC. Per le very friendly there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
We ate here three separate times and happy each time. Definitely one of the cheaper options and a non greasy thin pizza is never a bad idea.I just wish the had garlic dipping sauce. I guess it’s not a “thing” in Maui but other than that, no complaints
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love how tasty the pizzas are and definitely worth the price. They also have a lot of varieties too.
Ask for extra sauce paid for it but didn't get it! This usually never happens but it happened the last time.I love the food especially the chicken caesar salad but the prices are outrageous. Should at least offer Kamaina discount to us locals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Friendly and happy staff, amazing crust, affordable local beer and wine prices. I had been here in late June with a raging appetite as we had been doing many outdoor and water activities since the morning. My cheese-less calzone absolutely hit the spot and my friends and family's pizza looked extremely appetizing. They were loaded with toppings on their perfectly baked crust. While in Maui last week I knew I savored returning there for another cheese-less calzone. I was not disappointed. Their marinara sauce was expertly balanced. The only drawback was their room for dining in or on their lanai. However it was worth the drive for a late dinner from Kihei!
This was the best pizza we have had in a really long time. Crust was not soggy, sauce was simple but really flavorful and toppings were fresh. Cheesy garlic bread with marinara was also great. Love that the place was really low key and off the beaten path-the focus is on the food. This will be our first choice the next time we end up in Maui.
We went to Prison Street Pizza for an early dinner before the rush. We ordered a cheese calazone and a carnivore pizza. The calazone was out 5 minutes before the pizza and cold on the inside. The cheese wasn't melted so I sent it back to continue cooking. The large pizza came out and it was huge! It could easily serve 3-4 adults. We ended up waiting 5 minutes past the pizza to come out to get the calazone back.The waitress asked if we were ready for our tab and we replied yes. 10 minutes go by and nothing. I ended up going to the front to ask for our tab so we can pay and leave. Other people were wondering where their food was so we weren't the only ones hoping for better service.Overall, the pizza was good - large slices, good ingredients, and the isnald vibe was cool but the service was pretty miserable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
We ate here last night on 4th of July which I have to assume was the busiest night of the year in Lahaina. This is where Maui has their firework celebration. The staff was cool, calm and polite despite a huge crowd and line out the door. We got a large ham and pineapple pizza for $24.50 and it was really good. Crisp crust, great sauce and plenty of toppings. My son had a California cheeseburger which he devoured. If we are in Lahaina again we would definitely go back for pizza again. The building is small and really cute but I gave 4 stars because it felt cramped...but that was likely because it was just so busy. Definitely recommend this place
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
I rarely give bad reviews here but as a local in Lahaina town this place has been a big disappointment. Today is my husbands birthday and all he wanted to do is to relax and have a nice pizza for dinner. In the last few times we ordered here our order did not come as expected. Tonight was the last straw. We got there plenty of time for pickup. My husband still stood in line for 10mins which was understandable but when we got home our pizza was burnt and very dry. The Serpico pizza had some burnt spots on the bottom and extremely very dry. The Freight Train pizza supposed to have some BBQ sauce but instead all we can taste was the pork and the crust was burnt all over and very dry. We are all for supporting our local restaurants and understand that most of them struggles from shortage of staffs and with the inflation it can’t be that easy for small businesses to stay afloat. As locals we have already been dealing with the high cost of living, we understand this... All we ask for supporting our local businesses is to be treated with respect. We also understand the cost of food in restaurants had increased and don't mind paying this but good grief $70 for both pizza! we expect at least a decent meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
The price is fantastic..great option for cheaper eats in area which it's quite pricey.Pizza is tasty and fresh not out if the world amazing.. but for the price the Quality is perfectly fine. Crust is more on thin style. So for others leaving poor reviews in food ..perhaps they there are some expectation issues...we found the Ingredients were fresh and the pizza sauce was tangy..crust was not soft ot soggy. Mozzarella sticks were just ok.The staff are friendly and service was great. Would return for eats.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Can’t recommend this place at all. Food was below average, took a long time 45+ minutes and was very pricey. Poor customer service. The family next to us also waiting a long time.
Try garlic bread with cheese … and also try grandma’s alfredo pizza
Fantastic pizza!! I wish I had gotten a picture, but I didn’t! My family got a pepperoni (always a staple) and the Grandma’s for take out. Highly recommend the Grandma’s pizza (Alfredo sauce, chicken breast, spinach, garlic, mozzarella). Both pizzas are great fresh from the oven as well as cold leftovers! Also great to take in a cooler to the beach for a picnic!
Love this place! Pizza was delicious! Mango tree is beautiful ?Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza is good ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza with a thin crust. Also tried a salad and the garlic bread. The salad was wonderful with many items like artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and nice Maui onions. The garlic bread is a most with great seasonings. Many pizza options to choose from.