The food was disappointing overall. We came with a large group and tried most of the menu. The sandwiches were especially bad—everything in them tasted like it had been flash frozen, with no real flavor. The pizza was somewhat better, but still not worth the price. Given the quality and cost, I wouldn’t recommend this place.
Peach Matthew
What a great local restaurant! Pretty sure we were the only tourist in there at the time. It's not a big place, but they pack a lot of flavor in big portions! Stumbled upon this place on the way down the mountain.
You can instantly see everyone comes for the pizza. It was neat to watch them hand toss the dough right there. The pizza was a bit New York style, with a crispy thin crust. The flavor was fantastic!
We also got two pasta dishes, Vodka Penne was pretty good and very popular. I really enjoyed the Mahi Pasta, a great sauce and lots of fresh veggies. Plus the fish was perfect.
The building is older and very simple, but that makes it so charming. It's a wonderful little place and the staff put a lot of love into their work. Be sure to check them out and support the locals. You won't be disappointed!
Brian Butcher
We stopped in and really enjoyed the atmosphere and the legitimate east coast style pizza. Looking forward to trying there Stromboli. We are definitely going back.
B Allen
This time I had the pesto shrimp scampi! Soo worth it. For the price and quality this place is my go-to upcountry. Open late as well.
C N
Interior reminds you of the 80s, small, service was lackluster, lasagna was good, overpriced, but only few noodles and mostly meat, sauce and cheese. However, the pizza is very good and would order the pizza again.
Nicole Banister
We were starving after a day of hiking and sunset at the summit, we called when we were 20 minutes away and they had a hot pizza ready when we arrived. Pizza was delicious! Plus, a good ceaser salad! Great staff and nice dining room. Highly recommend!!
Anthony
Lovey place nice people. Great food
David Mufty
Great food and service
Staff was particularly helpful and hospitable
Jason Laba
Love the staff and the small town feel
Jennifer Wilson
So good we went twice in the same day! Pizza- excellent, especially the crust! Chicken tenders- my kids loved them! Sandwiches and raviolis were also very good! The place itself is nothing fancy, but typical of a NJ pizza place as it is modeled after. Close proximity to start of road up Haleakala.
They have the BEST Chief Salad I have ever eaten. The atmosphere was awesome, great vibe music, awesome customer service, very friendly staff and kid friendly. I had the veggie lasagna and there was something sweet about the ricotta cheese that compliments the savory veggies mixed with it.
I would recommend anyone via to come eat at this gem.
Tyler Brown
Made a stop here on our way down from viewing the sunset and stars from Haleakala. Serpico's was open late (9:30pm I think), and pizza sounded good to all but 1 of my kids.
The pizza was tossed and made right by us in an open kitchen where we could see the pizza oven and everything. The pizza was piping hot and had a crispy crust. Very delicious.
Small place, but they also do takeout.
Staff was super accommodating and nice. The poor appetizer focaccia with marinara was a hit, especially since we were starving.
My son that didn't want pizza ordered a kids portion of spaghetti with a meatball and was worried that there wouldn't be enough food. I'm happy to report that he was impressed by the portion and completely satisfied!
Regina Heller
Unbelievable pizza! So good and the staff were so nice! They hustled!
John Fields
Where locals eat; the waitresses sing along with the radio. Hearty portions, good flavors, not expensive. Wines.. but Pepsi tho..🫤🫤
Lauren Taylor
Awesome food - very happy we found this place on our way back down from Haleakala. We ordered 2 pizzas and both were delicious - and huge! Service was a bit slow but they were very busy, understandable. All the other food we saw brought out to other tables looked amazing as well. Contrary to another review, there is a bathroom, you just need to ask for the key. We used it and it was very clean.
The food was disappointing overall. We came with a large group and tried most of the menu. The sandwiches were especially bad—everything in them tasted like it had been flash frozen, with no real flavor. The pizza was somewhat better, but still not worth the price. Given the quality and cost, I wouldn’t recommend this place.
What a great local restaurant! Pretty sure we were the only tourist in there at the time. It's not a big place, but they pack a lot of flavor in big portions! Stumbled upon this place on the way down the mountain.
You can instantly see everyone comes for the pizza. It was neat to watch them hand toss the dough right there. The pizza was a bit New York style, with a crispy thin crust. The flavor was fantastic!
We also got two pasta dishes, Vodka Penne was pretty good and very popular. I really enjoyed the Mahi Pasta, a great sauce and lots of fresh veggies. Plus the fish was perfect.
The building is older and very simple, but that makes it so charming. It's a wonderful little place and the staff put a lot of love into their work. Be sure to check them out and support the locals. You won't be disappointed!
We stopped in and really enjoyed the atmosphere and the legitimate east coast style pizza. Looking forward to trying there Stromboli. We are definitely going back.
This time I had the pesto shrimp scampi!
Soo worth it. For the price and quality this place is my go-to upcountry. Open late as well.
Interior reminds you of the 80s, small, service was lackluster, lasagna was good, overpriced, but only few noodles and mostly meat, sauce and cheese. However, the pizza is very good and would order the pizza again.
We were starving after a day of hiking and sunset at the summit, we called when we were 20 minutes away and they had a hot pizza ready when we arrived. Pizza was delicious! Plus, a good ceaser salad! Great staff and nice dining room. Highly recommend!!
Lovey place nice people. Great food
Great food and service
Staff was particularly helpful and hospitable
Love the staff and the small town feel
So good we went twice in the same day! Pizza- excellent, especially the crust! Chicken tenders- my kids loved them! Sandwiches and raviolis were also very good! The place itself is nothing fancy, but typical of a NJ pizza place as it is modeled after. Close proximity to start of road up Haleakala.
Restaurantji Recommends
They have the BEST Chief Salad I have ever eaten. The atmosphere was awesome, great vibe music, awesome customer service, very friendly staff and kid friendly. I had the veggie lasagna and there was something sweet about the ricotta cheese that compliments the savory veggies mixed with it.
I would recommend anyone via to come eat at this gem.
Made a stop here on our way down from viewing the sunset and stars from Haleakala. Serpico's was open late (9:30pm I think), and pizza sounded good to all but 1 of my kids.
The pizza was tossed and made right by us in an open kitchen where we could see the pizza oven and everything. The pizza was piping hot and had a crispy crust. Very delicious.
Small place, but they also do takeout.
Staff was super accommodating and nice. The poor appetizer focaccia with marinara was a hit, especially since we were starving.
My son that didn't want pizza ordered a kids portion of spaghetti with a meatball and was worried that there wouldn't be enough food. I'm happy to report that he was impressed by the portion and completely satisfied!
Unbelievable pizza! So good and the staff were so nice! They hustled!
Where locals eat; the waitresses sing along with the radio. Hearty portions, good flavors, not expensive. Wines.. but Pepsi tho..🫤🫤
Awesome food - very happy we found this place on our way back down from Haleakala. We ordered 2 pizzas and both were delicious - and huge! Service was a bit slow but they were very busy, understandable. All the other food we saw brought out to other tables looked amazing as well. Contrary to another review, there is a bathroom, you just need to ask for the key. We used it and it was very clean.
Loading...