New American Restaurants near Paia, HI

NyloS Restaurant Fine Dining
115 Baldwin Ave, Paia

“If you want fine (5 star) food in an intimate setting (5 tables) then this is for you! We loved it. Thank you for making our 15th Anniversary Dinner a memorable delight!“

4.6 Superb81 Reviews
Leis Family Class Act New American • $$$
Laulima, 310 W Kaahumanu Ave, Kahului - 7.03 miles

“Arguable the best restaurant on Maui ....perhaps Hawaii.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
Baked On Maui Bakery • $
375 W Kuiaha Rd # 37, Haiku - 4.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Classic French Toast
Piggy Wiggy Benedict
Chocolate Croissant
Turkey Croissant
Biscuits & Gravy
Paniolo Skillet
Huevos Rancheros
Eggs Benedict
Belgian Waffle
Cinnamon Roll

“Great local food. I highly recommend them if you’re a local or on vacation.“

4.5 Superb123 Reviews
SixtyTwo MarcKet American • $
62 N Market St # 100, Wailuku - 8.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wailuku Town Stuffed Brioche French Toast
Toast Scrambled Eggs and Crispy Bacon
Buttermilk Cheddar Biscuit Sandwich
Signature Short Rib Eggs Benedict
Braddah Dave's Taro Burger
Signature Eggs Benedict
Savory Crepe of the Day
Stuffed Bubble Waffle
Maui Cattle Loco Moco
Pesto Chicken Crepes

“Great food and service! Atmosphere is clean and fresh“

4.6 Superb123 Reviews
Seascape Maalaea Restaurant Seafood • $$
192 Maalaea Rd, Wailuku - 12.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

I'a Palai Fish & Chips
Fresh Fish and Chips
Banana Creme Brulee
Catch of the Day
Ahi Poke Bowl

“This has always been one of our most favorite restaurants. All dishes they offer are simply outstanding. This time we had Ahi Poke Nachos, Steak Poke and the Ramen dish. So incredibly tasty for a very good price. And what a view!
Update: We visited today again - Had the best Poke bowl ever. This is a must - highly recommended!🤙🤙
Update 2: We visited yet again yesterday. The food keeps on getting better. The crispy pork belly appetizer was beyond excellent. One of the best dish we ever had. Ahi & Steak Pokd were outstanding as always. I would give more than five stars if it would be possible.😀“

4.4 Superb103 Reviews
Kula Lodge Restaurant Family • $$
15200 Haleakala Hwy, Kula - 9.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

One Egg Bacon and Potatoes
Artisan Brick Oven Pizza
Macadamia Nut Pancakes
Banana Mac Nut Pancakes
Classic Eggs Benedict
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Hawaiian Omelette
Kula Veggie Omelet
Maui Onion Soup
Fish and Chips

“Overindulged! The joyful experience of our 36th anniversary dinner will be one that we’ll be chasing over and over again! We were overindulged from the moment we sat down at the table with the most beautiful view, surrounded by soothing live music. The care and concern from each and every staff member was evident, making sure that the best possible bottle of wine for our meal was chosen, that our water glass was never too empty, that each plate delivered was well executed and well presented and explained, when done each time dishes were taken away quickly, the pacing of the meal was well done, just everything and everything! Perfection! And a special note to Sasha- we already noted during our meal service- the finesse and skill you brought to the level of service was just outstanding! Kudos to you and to the team that supports you in making sure that each of your tables gets the attention that they deserve! To say that our anniversary dinner was memorable is truly an understatement! It will be that feeling of being so well taken care of and that every orchestrated element enhanced our celebration will be what brings us back over and over again. We already are making plans to come back and I know we will be coming back over and over again! With our deepest appreciation! …and then the food! Truly the best farm to table experience on Maui! From the amuse buche course(s!) that wet our appetite for more goodies to come. The locally sourced ingredients shined with their freshness and the finesse in which they were presented. Two highlights were the Maui onion soup presented with the perfect amount of cheese and puffed pastry topping- just perfectly seasoned. And then the Haleakala filet mignon, once again perfectly cooked and perfectly seasoned and topped with compound butter that was melted at table side with rosemary. (It feels like we are saying perfect too much! But we do mean it!) Then to end the evening celebration with our chocolate lava cake surrounded by white and milk chocolate fondue with banana bread and fresh fruits was simply scrumptious! Chef Junior Ulep, Mahalo for our special night, with our deepest grateful hearts, we appreciate your mana and the joyfulness in which you have chosen to feed us and our fellow patrons at Kula Lodge Restaurant!“

4.3 Superb341 Reviews
Kula Lodge New American • $$
15200 Haleakala Hwy, Kula - 8.5 miles

“Overindulged! The joyful experience of our 36th anniversary dinner will be one that we’ll be chasing over and over again! We were overindulged from the moment we sat down at the table with the most beautiful view, surrounded by soothing live music. The care and concern from each and every staff member was evident, making sure that the best possible bottle of wine for our meal was chosen, that our water glass was never too empty, that each plate delivered was well executed and well presented and explained, when done each time dishes were taken away quickly, the pacing of the meal was well done, just everything and everything! Perfection! And a special note to Sasha- we already noted during our meal service- the finesse and skill you brought to the level of service was just outstanding! Kudos to you and to the team that supports you in making sure that each of your tables gets the attention that they deserve! To say that our anniversary dinner was memorable is truly an understatement! It will be that feeling of being so well taken care of and that every orchestrated element enhanced our celebration will be what brings us back over and over again. We already are making plans to come back and I know we will be coming back over and over again! With our deepest appreciation! …and then the food! Truly the best farm to table experience on Maui! From the amuse buche course(s!) that wet our appetite for more goodies to come. The locally sourced ingredients shined with their freshness and the finesse in which they were presented. Two highlights were the Maui onion soup presented with the perfect amount of cheese and puffed pastry topping- just perfectly seasoned. And then the Haleakala filet mignon, once again perfectly cooked and perfectly seasoned and topped with compound butter that was melted at table side with rosemary. (It feels like we are saying perfect too much! But we do mean it!) Then to end the evening celebration with our chocolate lava cake surrounded by white and milk chocolate fondue with banana bread and fresh fruits was simply scrumptious! Chef Junior Ulep, Mahalo for our special night, with our deepest grateful hearts, we appreciate your mana and the joyfulness in which you have chosen to feed us and our fellow patrons at Kula Lodge Restaurant!“

4.3 Superb288 Reviews
Frankly Gourmet Sandwich Shop • $
1 Keolani Pl, Kahului - 4.46 miles

“It's a bummer that they don't have musubi anymore (bring it back?), but my favorite thing to get when I'm flying out of OGG is a hot dog from this place. I used to get a musubi AND a hot dog. Reliable and friendly, nothing fancy, it's exactly what a hot dog truck in an airport ahould be.“

4 Good4 Reviews
Tante's Island Cuisine Hawaiian • $
100 W Kaahumanu Ave, Kahului - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Sari Sari Tante’S Favorite
Hawaiian Pineapple Pancakes
Loco Moco Traditional
Short Ribs Loco Moco
Paniolo Steak & Eggs
Tante's Banana Split
Kona Coffee Mud Pie
Sweet Potato Salad
Island Mixed Plate
Eggs Benedict

“I cried good tears this morning. I've never in my life cried because of how divine the food was. I ordered the crab cakes benedict, usually when I order crab cakes it's a hash brown with little bits of crab meat but this one is purely crab and it was so fresh like it was caught in the early hours before restaurant opened. Eggs were cooked to perfection and the hollandaise sauce was heavenly. It was love on a plate, my compliments to the chef! Service was absolutely wonderful, lovely and welcoming ladies. They were very attentive and efficient. Mahalo nui loa! 🌺“

4.2 Good118 Reviews
The Wooden Crate At Lumeria Maui American • $$$
1813 Baldwin Ave, Makawao - 1.93 miles

“Delicious fresh farm to table food. The tomato soup was divine and the steak, the steak was cooked perfectly. I was in heaven. There was a loud party of ppl which was a little disturbing only bc I was in quiet mode. The hostess graciously moved me, which i really appreciated.“

3.6 Good22 Reviews