Paia Gelato : Best Gelato in Maui

The two beautiful people in the shop are so kind and all the gelatos were so delicious! Must visit!

Delicious. Such a treat on any day but especially when it’s hot like today. Staff were super friendly. We loved all the flavors.

Incredibly good stracciatella

Sandy Beach + Chocolate is amazing! I was skeptical, but go for it. I'm so glad we made a point of checking this place out.

Best gelato in Paia…I had the mac nut coffee & french vanilla 🤍🤍🤍

2nd visit in three days! The employees are the cherry on top. The two girls working just made you feel welcome & happy to be alive!!! Thank you for being great examples for Maui to us visitors!!!

Vanilla macadamia is a must!

Tasty and overall good. Italian gelato still better. A 4 star only mainly as the price is - like everything on Hawaii - ridiculous. Lilikoi and pistachio was our favorite.

AMAZING vegan gelato! Half of the flavors are dairy free and so creamy you could never tell. Chocolate raspberry and Thai ginger lime coconut were fantastic

They have amazing Gelato, and all of their flavors are great! Everyone who worked there was very nice. 10/10 experience, I will definitely be coming back for more!

I'm extremely disappointed with the portions ... I ordered the three scoops of pistachio, stracciatella and ube together and I gotta too much ube, perfect amount of stracciatella, but barely any pistachio.
The pistachio was my favorite and I got a tiny amount of it literally I took too bites with that tiny ice cream spoon they give you and it was done. I even told her she didn't give me enough of the pistachio and showed her what I go she said she did and offered to give me a tiny bit more but it still wasn't close to comparison with the amount of the other flavors.
The pistachio might have been their popular one because it was almost gone and don't get me wrong their ice cream flavors are great but I was really dissatisfied with the portions.
If you like pistachio as much as I do, just get it by itself. If you get it with others flavors, you'll get a smaller portion of it.
If I ever go back, I'm only ordering pistachio by itself. I only gave it three stars because the flavors were amazing but portions are terrible. I didn't get what I paid for.

Delicious! I lived in Italy for several years, and the chocolate hazelnut (Nutella) was legit! Che buono!! The passion fruit was also excellent! And the service—so kind and happy! Let us try all we wanted! Loved it!

When they say the best gelato they mean it! They have amazing gelato. Fresh tasty smooth. The best coconut gelato we've ever had - even compared to Italy and Spain. The staff is happy friendly and cheerful. Very happy we dropped in

My wife and I visited a little over a year ago during our honeymoon. Their team was incredibly friendly, kind, and welcoming. Their Lilikoi Gelato is unbelievable.

Delicious gelato and amazing options! Thanks Luca for being so kind and letting us try special flavours!!