Gilmore's Pub

5307 Caraway Ln, Cedar Falls
(319) 859-9342

Recent Reviews

Sort by
James C

Good food and service. Cheese curds were some of the best. Would have been a 5 star but my Ruthie beer was dated a year old…

Gabbi Johnstone

Food was ok, kinda expensive for what you get but the service is horrible. I should have known better when we showed up at 7 on a Sat night and there were only 5 tables of people. We had 5 people and a baby, so they automatically charged us a 20% gratuity (for parties of 6 or more). I guess since they knew they were getting that normal wait service went out the window. Nothing like waiting with empty glasses forever, or done with your meal for 20 minutes uses before being checked on again. Trust me, there are much much better places to spend your money than this excuse for a restaurant in an old folks home.

Jim Volgarino

Want an un-noisy, unpretentious, friendly to all space to enjoy conversation and perfectly prepared foods? This is it.

Amy Lesyshen

Great place to eat! The group I was with loved the food! The burgers were the bomb!

lynn Stock

Went for the first time Friday night 1-10-25 Food was out of this world Service was top notch We will be coming back and telling all our friends A Gem in our city for sure

Kurt Stock

I had the pork belly. Absolutely fantastic. I highly recommend it

Sue Hansen

Excellent food and drinks. Service is great as well.

Amy Woodson

We recently discovered this hidden gem. What a great place! Location is a bot out of the way but 100% worth it. Food is amazing, waitresses have been wonderful, and price is extremely reasonable. Absolutely recommend!

Amy Woodson

Nice atmosphere, food and service were great and pricing is excellent. Looking forward to going back. Hopefully when they have music!

Allison W

Gilmore’s Pub is a classy restaurant with wonderful food and perfect portions. The prime rib was cooked to perfection. The sides tasted absolutely amazing. We were about to get our check when we saw mouthwatering desserts coming to the table next to us that we just had to try! The sangria cheesecake was delicious! I am a huge cheesecake fan and the hint of orange was subtle and commentary with the fresh fruit.

The service was great! The prices are a weren’t too bad, and they were definitely well worth it.

Bob Shadle

We had a very tasty dinner there twice now. We'll be back.

Jared Blaylock

First off, it is open to the public at the listed hours like any normal restaurant. Just approach the hostess counter like any other place.
Went in on a Tuesday at 5:30 and every seat was filled so we sat at the bar.
Got the cheese curds as an appetizer. Light breading without seasoning and melty all the way through. Ranch and buffalo as standard were both good.
My wife for the pork tenderloin sandwich and enjoyed it. Sweet potato fries on the side were coated lightly and ended up nice and crispy unlike most others.
I got the patty melt with fries the melt had some unexpected additions, with a black bean spread on there. All added to the flavor and was a welcome surprise.

We will be back to try some more of their offerings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joan Dawson Huhn

Unique menu with variety and change. Creative chef. Best in Cedar Falls.

Scott Kipp

Great food every time. Service is slow at times.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Zachary Moye

This is a hidden gem of a spot. Nestled inside a retirement home, Gilmore's Pub is open to all people who would happen by their store. The following is a breakndown of our visit.
We had brunch here at 1130 amm. There was a 15-minute wait time as the regular customers were showing up in droves. The staff called our names, and we were seated in wonderfully comfy chairs. We were given a brunch menu to choose from. While not extensive, it was adequate. Wait time for meal was around 10-15minutes. I got the Monte-cristo sandwich, and it was absolutely fantastic. The portions they serve are more akin to European sizes, but it was enough to fill us up. Brunch was under 30usd for us. Great deal and excellent plated food! We will be back!

Wheelchair accessibility: It's in a retirement home. You are good to go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...