I ordered two pizzas and some sides from this business on 05-17-25. When they arrived the pizzas had been tipped. One of them was still alright, but on the other most of the toppings had slid off the pizza. I called to complain, got the manager, and he said he'd send me a replacement. When I got that pizza it was ALSO tipped, and the toppings had slid off that pizza. I called again, and the manager (never got his name) told me he'd give me a coupon for a free extra-large specialty pizza for any future order. He said it would be tied to my phone number, and would show up if I called in a new order. But when I called today to place an order, the guy I spoke to (different person) said he didn't see any notes about a free pizza, and refused to give me that offer. When I asked to speak to a manager he said he was one. He also refused to give me his name.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jessica Myers
Have had their pizza a handful of times now and every time it's delicious. We really like the Maui Wowwie. Service has been polite and prompt for pick up. Atmosphere got a 4, because it could use some love, but it's not really a dine in place. Love the old Gumby character and posters hung.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon \u0026 Andrea Nelson
Amazing food- even better than I remember from my time in college. Great service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elaine D
Standard college town late night pizza. Good when you need food late at night. One booth of I door seating. Definitely a take out or delivery place.
Chief Keef
Idk about anything else but the buffalo pizza is so fire
Steve Holloway
You'd be better off with a nice $12 frozen pizza than paying 30 dollars to get this delivered. Nowhere near the quality or amount of food as Domino's or Papa John's. Would not recommend
Gumby’s Pizza: The Post-Trip Comfort Food You Didn’t Know You Needed 🤪
Just got back from a long trip and needed something cozy to settle back in—Gumby’s delivered (literally and figuratively). We ordered through DoorDash, which was super easy, and the driver was great about keeping in touch. Smooth process from start to finish.
This time we opted not to get pepperoni since it can sometimes feel a bit too oily for us, and honestly? Solid move. If you’ve ever felt the same, I definitely recommend trying a different topping combo—it made the whole pie feel lighter but still just as satisfying.
As you can see from my photos… I only remembered to snap them after the pizza was already half gone. I think that says enough. Also ordered the 12 Pokey Dots—and let’s just say there were only 3 left by the time I took a picture. They’re just really tasty, cheesy clumps of doughy goodness. You’ve been warned.
The crust is that perfectly chewy, comforting kind that hits the spot after a long week (or a long flight). Gumby’s really is that reliable go-to when you want to feel full, happy, and a little nostalgic.
What to order: - 12 pokey dots - 14” build your own pizza (for a normal sized pizza) Pro tip: if you’re looking for a smaller pizza for 1 person, then they also have 10” or 12” as well. I really like how it’s so customizable.
Highly recommend. Especially if you forget to take pictures until you’re halfway through. That’s when you know it’s good.
Jose Rubio
Stopped by tonight and experienced cool and friendly staff. Pizza was great and made to perfection! This place is definitely worth the visit!
Desi Chay
Came to IC to visit my son and we ordered pizza. The service was quick, staff was friendly and the pizza was good! Great price as well!! Definitely be back! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Rain
I ordered a 0calzone tonight and had left a note about my dipping sauce. I have severe food restrictions because of a medicine I'm on for parkinson's. It prevents me from eating a great many things. They actually read the note, called me because what they had wouldn't work and then worked with me when they were out of the ingredient I ordered to figure out another one I could eat. It was fantastic service and definitely some of the best I've had in town.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krystal Duffy
Love Gumby’s! Great spot for late night pizza and always delicious!
They don’t answer the phone
Service: 1
Want diarrhea I am
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza Delivered Fresh!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered two pizzas and some sides from this business on 05-17-25. When they arrived the pizzas had been tipped. One of them was still alright, but on the other most of the toppings had slid off the pizza. I called to complain, got the manager, and he said he'd send me a replacement. When I got that pizza it was ALSO tipped, and the toppings had slid off that pizza. I called again, and the manager (never got his name) told me he'd give me a coupon for a free extra-large specialty pizza for any future order. He said it would be tied to my phone number, and would show up if I called in a new order. But when I called today to place an order, the guy I spoke to (different person) said he didn't see any notes about a free pizza, and refused to give me that offer. When I asked to speak to a manager he said he was one. He also refused to give me his name.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Have had their pizza a handful of times now and every time it's delicious. We really like the Maui Wowwie. Service has been polite and prompt for pick up. Atmosphere got a 4, because it could use some love, but it's not really a dine in place. Love the old Gumby character and posters hung.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food- even better than I remember from my time in college. Great service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Standard college town late night pizza. Good when you need food late at night. One booth of I door seating. Definitely a take out or delivery place.
Idk about anything else but the buffalo pizza is so fire
You'd be better off with a nice $12 frozen pizza than paying 30 dollars to get this delivered. Nowhere near the quality or amount of food as Domino's or Papa John's. Would not recommend
Great pizza and friendly service
Restaurantji Recommends
Gumby’s Pizza: The Post-Trip Comfort Food You Didn’t Know You Needed 🤪
Just got back from a long trip and needed something cozy to settle back in—Gumby’s delivered (literally and figuratively). We ordered through DoorDash, which was super easy, and the driver was great about keeping in touch. Smooth process from start to finish.
This time we opted not to get pepperoni since it can sometimes feel a bit too oily for us, and honestly? Solid move. If you’ve ever felt the same, I definitely recommend trying a different topping combo—it made the whole pie feel lighter but still just as satisfying.
As you can see from my photos… I only remembered to snap them after the pizza was already half gone. I think that says enough.
Also ordered the 12 Pokey Dots—and let’s just say there were only 3 left by the time I took a picture. They’re just really tasty, cheesy clumps of doughy goodness. You’ve been warned.
The crust is that perfectly chewy, comforting kind that hits the spot after a long week (or a long flight). Gumby’s really is that reliable go-to when you want to feel full, happy, and a little nostalgic.
What to order:
- 12 pokey dots
- 14” build your own pizza (for a normal sized pizza)
Pro tip: if you’re looking for a smaller pizza for 1 person, then they also have 10” or 12” as well. I really like how it’s so customizable.
Highly recommend. Especially if you forget to take pictures until you’re halfway through. That’s when you know it’s good.
Stopped by tonight and experienced cool and friendly staff. Pizza was great and made to perfection! This place is definitely worth the visit!
Came to IC to visit my son and we ordered pizza. The service was quick, staff was friendly and the pizza was good! Great price as well!! Definitely be back! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a 0calzone tonight and had left a note about my dipping sauce. I have severe food restrictions because of a medicine I'm on for parkinson's. It prevents me from eating a great many things. They actually read the note, called me because what they had wouldn't work and then worked with me when they were out of the ingredient I ordered to figure out another one I could eat. It was fantastic service and definitely some of the best I've had in town.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Gumby’s! Great spot for late night pizza and always delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...