Andy's Pastry Shop
40 Renee Ln, Tiffin
(319) 430-4472
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
I recently ordered some cupcakes for an event where some friends had several food allergies. Andy was able to provide delicious cupcakes everyone was able to enjoy. There was a small mixup with my order that he also resolved quickly. Great food and great service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got cookies for my bridal shower. They were amazing. The light in my relatives’ eyes as they had the cookies and compared them to Walmart store bought cookies from when they were little brought a warmth to my heart. They’ve already started asking me to order some and mail the cookie to them. I can’t wait to tryout the cupcakes next for my wedding day!
I just can't express enough how much we love Andy's vanilla buttercream vegan/soy-free cake. We haven't barely tried anything else because we love the cake. It is delightful & I'm grateful to be able to eat cake again! 100% worth every penny!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a small one tier wedding cake and it was the best! Very moist and tasty. Fabulous flavor,thank you Andy!
The Monster cookies are amazing. They were purchased for a special event and I was thrilled to try them. I look forward to trying all flavors and pastries.
I had one of Andy's cookies today at UIHC. Yum! My first encounter with his pastries. Grateful for a gluten-free dairy free option!
Where to begin? I have been making my own desserts for years because unfortunately it’s so hard to find things that are both vegan and gluten free. I first had one of Andy’s cookies and had to question whether it was really vegan and gf or not because it was that good! I’ve since had multiple different cookie flavors, puppy chow and even a whole cheesecake. They have all been so delicious! His cookies are full of flavor and so soft. The puppy chow tastes just like regular puppy chow. And the cheesecake is the closest thing I’ve found to regular cheesecake. My family who has no food allergies has even loved the treats from Andy’s! Highly recommend to anyone who is looking for delicious treats!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I met Andy at the Cedar Rapids Farmer's Market and he was such a kind person! His customer service is top notch. I told him I had been struggling to find yummy gluten free desserts and he had me try one of his sugar cookies on the spot. It was delicious! I ended up buying his puppy chow (also very yummy) and a chocolate chip muffin. Y'all, this was the best gluten free chocolate chip muffin I've ever had! You honestly could not tell the difference between this muffin and a "regular" muffin. The only critique I have for it is that it was a bit crumbly, so make sure to eat it over a plate or something. But it was the perfect texture and taste and exactly what I needed in a muffin. I will 100% be a repeat customer!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were driving through town and decided to give them a call. We learned they sell their products inside of Hy-Vee in the area. We stopped and grabbed a pack of gluten free sugar cookies, gluten free puppy chow, and a gluten free strawberry cupcake w/strawberry frosting. One word… AMAZING! They don’t taste gluten free at all!
I've been gluten free & vegan for over six years, and I travel a lot, so I've tried countless gf & vegan baked goods across the country. These are some of the best. My (non vegan, non-gf) partner and parents even prefer them to other options! They're truly a family favorite. I highly
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I received 6 vegan and gluten-free vanilla cupcakes for a birthday. Legit the best cupcake I’ve ever had AND it’s vegan/gluten-free!
It was such a pleasure to work with Andy! I ordered quite a few items to fill the gluten free dessert bar of my dreams for my wedding & everything turned out amazing. Our guests are still talking about how soft the cookies were. :) I had to change my order a few times before the big day & Andy was always happy to help. I can't wait to order from Andy's Pastry Shop again soon!
My fiancée is allergic to eggs and dairy. I needed a wedding cake that he could eat and enjoy! Andy offered free cupcakes to taste and I can't wait to see the final cake design!
My fiancée is allergic to eggs and dairy. I needed a wedding cake that he could eat and enjoy! Andy offered free cupcakes to taste and I can't wait to see the final cake design!
We had cookies from Andy’s at a women’s conference and WOW! So YUMMY! The gluten free cookies were very appreciated by all! Thank you for helping us make everyone feel welcome!
Loading...