Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Food was AMAZING!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Italian Nachos, Peperroni Rolls

My husband and I stopped in last night to grab a late bite. We googled online to see what restaurants were open late. Hell ya, Old Chicago was an option so of course we had to come. Online it said that they closed at 12. We called to confirm but it was automated messaging system year answeed our call. Over the phone it said ordering to go was an option so we took it as it's a go.

We arrived at 11. That gave us an hour to eat a couple appetizers and allow my husband enjoy a couple cold ones. Walking in we did notice people in the dining area. We headed to the bar area and noticed all the chairs were placed on the tabletops. We asked the server if we can get a table. That's when we found out that they close the kitchen at 11. It's drinks only after 11.

I guess the frustrating part of all this is showing up and being disappointed because all the signs said that food and drinks were an option. Maybe your company should update Google and let them know you that y'all stop serving food before closing hours. And also update your automated phone messaging system to let your customers know that they can't place orders to go after 11. It's all deceiving.

It's been a couple years since we have been to Old Chicago. Our last visit was great! Service and food were fantastic. Too bad I can't say much about last night's visit.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Surprised how funny the pizza is.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was pretty good. However, our service was lacking. When we first walked in our party of five was seated at dirty table for 4 that had not been wiped down. The waitress was too concerned with who appeared to be her boyfriend sitting at another table to realize this. I grabbed a chair from another table. After the waitress took our order she proceeded to continue the conversation with him. Once our food finally arrived our drinks were not refilled until we asked multiple times. The same waitress forgot both my daughter’s sides. The poor table behind us had it even worse as they were seated before us and did not receive their food until we were almost done with ours.
It is rare that I would not leave a tip however I could not bring myself to leave one with this experience. I write this in hopes that the management of this location can resolve these issues.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Worst dinning experience I’ve had in a while. We waited for almost 45 minutes for our food and finally gave up & paid for my beer & appetizer. We had to get 2 different employees to get our server for us. The fact that she was surprised that we still hadn’t received our food tells you the level of customer service. Honestly it’d been a better experience just going to the food court. Stay away from this dump!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Wheelchair accessibility: The tables are arranged so that a person can easily get his/her chair up to it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Nachos, Chicago 7 Stromboli, Chicago 7 Pizza, Chicago Fire Calzone, Tuscan Chicken with Spinach, Hawaiian Pizza, Wings, Chopped Chicken Salad, Deep Fried Pickles, Pretzel Sticks, Cheesecake with Fresh Berries, Meatballs, Calzone 7, Brew, Peperroni Rolls, Artichoke Dip, Thai Pie, Bavarian Pretzel Sticks, Flatbread, Chicago 7 Calzone

Amazing Italian Nachos, Deep Dish Chicago Pizza!

Cesar salad wasn't fresh and dressing wasn't good.

The rest of the food is definitely worth it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago 7 Pizza, Peperroni Rolls

Went in after a funeral. Hostess didn't acknowledge us til we'd already been waiting awhile. After ordering and getting our drinks, we waited for 40 minutes, only seeing our waitress once. She stated food was on its way out. Waited longer and everyone working was avoiding us it seemed. We ended up leaving, as we live 2 hours away and our daughter was late taking her medication that she has to take with food. I've worked food before and I get things are rough and they might have been short staffed, but really?

2 pizzas arrived and were nasty. Barely any cheese and tons of sauce. The crust wasn't very good either.
I don't know what they eat in Chicago but I bet they'd be horrified that you call this Chicago pizza. As pizza lovers were very disappointed.

Food: 1

Service: 4

The door is open and ready for you to treat yourself to a GREAT pizza and a few COLD BREWS taking a break from shopping. When I take my sweetie there to ship this is the place I go to for a pizza and a few COLD BREWS. She’s happy going to shop and I’m happy for PIZZA AND COLD BEER.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

The best tap house and pizza place we've had in a long while! We'll be back. This food was amazing. The service was friendly. The draft selection and pizza selections were off the hook! We started with their pepperroni pizza rolls. You have GOT to try these!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago 7 Pizza, Chicago Fire Calzone, Peperroni Rolls

We’ve eaten here several times and each time pizza was great UNTIL today. We ordered medium pepperoni OC pizza. We got a large double pp with parsley all over the top(I should’ve questioned the price when I picked it up) It was super salty, we couldn’t finish our 1st slice. Awful! Will not be back and will definitely NOT recommend this place. My fault for not checking our order before leaving.

Food: 1

Service: 2

After searching for the best pizza in the Treasure Valley for years, we finally found it. Gone are the disappointments with lousy crust, too little of too much pizza sauce, excessive cheese, and lack of toppings (including bare crust for up to 2 inches around the perimeter of the pie). This is the pizza parlor to enjoy a perfect exceptional quality pizza that is competitively priced and served with a smile.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It’s unfortunate that there is only one location of this place. One of the best service ,food, and good atmosphere. Thanks so much old chicago you never disappoint. I took a military veteran for his first time and he loved it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Bar area was so nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5