Keystone Pizza
207 S 9th Ave, Caldwell
(208) 454-1700
Customers' Favorites
Texas Toast Garlic Bread with Cheese
Hawaiian Pizza with Jalapenos
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Large Pepperoni Pizza
All You Can Eat Salad
Combination Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
All Meat Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks
Menu
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Just wanted to send a heartfelt thank you to the kind person who turned in our son’s wallet at Keystone Pizza. Everything was still inside—cash and cards included. A huge thank you as well to the Keystone employees who went above and beyond by contacting the Caldwell Library to track us down. We are so grateful for your kindness and honesty!
Used to go to Keystone all the time growing up, and loved the pizza the atmosphere!
Had the night out with the family and stopped in to grab some food!
Something about all that has changed, the employees were or seemed distracted. They were eager to help once they got to the counter. The dining area seemed dirty and dim.
Salad bar was out of salad and looked neglected. When the employee came to drop off the pizza I made...
Had the night out with the family and stopped in to grab some food!
Something about all that has changed, the employees were or seemed distracted. They were eager to help once they got to the counter. The dining area seemed dirty and dim.
Salad bar was out of salad and looked neglected. When the employee came to drop off the pizza I made...
This place has great pizza. The recipes and choices have remained pretty much the same for about 50 years! It's a nice, family-oriented place with an arcade room for kids - a nice feature for parents - and a great lunch menu. The decor may seem a bit outdated, but I like the the nostalgic feel of the place.
It's no wonder this place has been successful for so long... keep up the good work! 👍
It's no wonder this place has been successful for so long... keep up the good work! 👍
You May Also Like
Happy Teriyaki - Downtown Caldwell - 921 Arthur St Ste A
![]()
Japanese, Asian
Casa Añejo - 812 Main St
![]()
Mexican