Papa Kelsey's
162 E Main St, Rigby
(208) 745-0010
Customers' Favorites
Italian Meatball 12 Whole
Ham & Cheese 12 Whole
Italian Salad
Papa Kelsey
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This has been one of my favorite restaurants since I was a teenager. Even the most basic of sandwiches here tastes amazing because of their incredible bread. I usually just get their ham and cheese and tomato sandwich, but their garlic mozzarella bread is good too. Simple, rustic, nostalgic, delicious.
Food is always hot and ready to go! Great service. The pizza is delish. Favorite are the sandwiches. Would recommend as a better sandwich shop than Subway. Great location in Rigby, Idaho too.
Vegetarian options: Customizable subs!
Vegetarian options: Customizable subs!
I order the Italian sub and told the guy what I wanted on it and for some reason they put green peppers on it.... Who puts green peppers on an Italian sub? ??? it was ok other than that but next time just put what the customer orders in their
You May Also Like
The Caramel Tree - 146 E Main St
![]()
Dessert
Lil' Mike's Bar-B-Que - 116 S Clark St
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, Caterers
The Cookie Cottage - 143 S Clark St
![]()
Coffee & Tea, Bakery