Sully's GastroPub

504 Shoup Ave, Idaho Falls
(208) 346-8851

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sherri Davidson

Honestly the best burger I have ever eaten! I ordered the Slap Yo Granny Blue burger and added blue cheese crumbles. Oh. My. Goodness!!! Delicious! The service was great. Our food came out quick. The atmosphere is awesome! I loved their food truck and I love the restaurant even more!

Rosie Newman

Driving from Montana to Arizona and we found this gem!! When I say this food was amazing, It was amazing!! I will be back no matter how many miles we must travel. The service was fantastic, our cups were never empty, food came out quickly. Miley handles that dining room like a pro. If you haven’t eaten here, stop by soon!

bryan vohs

Decent food and prices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Smoked Ribeye French Dip Sammich

Kelly Averett

The food is so unique. The burgers are super messy and delicious. Everything I've eaten there has been better than just "good food" because of the combination of flavors.
We tried the chili and cornbread as an appetizer. The chili was so good. However, the cornbread was the best thing over ever had there. It was moist, and sweet but still tasted like cornbread.
The only negative thing has been the fries. They are undercooked and limp every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slap Yo Granny Blue Burger

Nick Higgins

Service was horrible, we actually got put in a spot that the waitress didn't even know we were there. Did not get asked on we like our burger cooked, way under cooked, never got ketchup, or other condiments, meals looked big but it was all just a bunch of lettuce, I mean a lot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

Heather Wolfley

This place is great! We've been a few times now and we've always had really great experience. The food is awesome! We've recommended that some of our friends and family go and they all loved it too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Danny Smith

Slap yo granny burger is insanely good!! Consistent food. Food is top notch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sandwich, Fresh Fries, Patty Melt Sandwich, Sully's Trashcan Sammich, Rachaels Ruben, Hens in a Blanket Wrap w Chipotle Lime Ranch Chile Tomato Wrap, Mozzarella Explosion, Rachel's Rueben, Chicken Wrap, Slap Yo Granny Blue Burger, The Sour Hen, Strawberry, Meatball Sub, Chicken Caesar Salad, Parmesean and Herb Cicken Wings, Sullivan Nitro Pour, Turkey Sandwich, Russian Pickle Burger Medium Well with Housemade Fries and Housemade Fry Sauce

Katie Voorhees

Awesome place!!! Great atmosphere and wonderful food!! We had the most lovely and sweet server. She made our day!! Best pastrami ever!! Awesome chicken wrap!! Amazing cheesecake with a citrus glaze. Everyone check this place out!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yves Desfougeres

The burgers were awesome but the fries were cold and not crispy. The service was friendly and welcoming

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sully's Trashcan Sammich

Jessica Kaiser

We went for lunch last week and decided right away that it’s a new favorite. Our food was so delicious. My husband got the macdaddy (I believe that’s the name) with sidewinder fries and I got the trashcan. The Parmesan fries were soo good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Kidd

The burger I had was big, juicy, a little bland, and expensive. $18 for a burger and fries is kinda up there. It was a 1/2 lb patty but the price was still pretty steep. I think the burger being a bit bland is because of the larger patty. The bacon pieces on it were thick and tasty and everything else about it was fine. The fries were pretty good as well and the fry sauce was amazing. I really liked that. So all in all, the food was probably a 7.5-8 out of 10. There were really good aspects of it and other things that could have been a bit better. The price was probably the most disappointing thing but there are definitely more expensive places out there that are worse (cough cough Red Robin).

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Logan Black

Loved for food. I had the number 19 turkey bacon on rye which was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Fries, Turkey Sandwich

Danielle Hallam Black

Fantastic. We had the Trash Can and the #19 Sammie. Both were delicious and reasonably priced. Fresh cut fries were also amazing. Plan to eat here again and bring friends.

Oil Mama

Love the tea tinctures and helpful kkowledgabke people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tara Chabis

I can't praise this place enough
The atmosphere was wonderful, with the right soundtrack playing, the decor was fun (references from Pulp Fiction and The Big Labowski), a pool table, 2 game arcade systems, and nice seating areas.
Ash was our server, and she was so helpful, knowledgeable, patient, and kind.
And then, of course, the food was delicious and HUGE portions, and quite original. My husband got the ½lb. JAMO Whisky Burger and fresh cut fries. I got the #19 Sammich, which is essentially a BLT with tons of deli turkey and added avocado - on a GLUTEN-FREE bun!! and the sidewinder fries. Their fry sauce is the bomb!
My husband said the light stout was "creamy, with an almost floral tint," and the dark PEANUT BUTTER stout (pictured). "You could drink it for breakfast. I wouldn't recommend it, but you could, and then you won't need to eat the rest of the day. I shouldn't like it as much as I do."

We went on a Thursday evening (after Art Walk downtown). The restaurant had a decent number of people sitting down to eat, and we were told they get a decent amount of business on Fridays and Saturdays. I'm really hoping this keeps up so we can keep this amazing business going!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...