The Mill Steak and Spirits
$$$ • Steakhouses, Sports Bars
Hours:
324 N 3rd St, McCall
(208) 634-7683
About The Mill Steak and Spirits
Customers' Favorites
The Mill Steak and Spirits Reviews
Share your opinion about The Mill Steak and Spirits
Everything about our experience at The Mill was disappointing. This was our Honeymoon weekend, and I remember going to The Mill 10+ years ago and it being "THE PLACE" to eat in McCall, reservations required, but worth every penny. No longer the case. There were only about 15 people total in the whole establishment, and roughly 6 people in the bar. The server was too busy taking smoke breaks with her boyfriend to accommodate us, and coming back in reeking of cigarettes didn't...read full review
We were deeply disappointed by our experience at The Mill.
Our family gathered there to celebrate a special occasion: our beloved patriarch’s 65th class reunion. He is a highly educated man with a PhD, visiting with his wife, a respected music professor from China; his son, a lawyer who is half Jewish; his daughter-in-law, who holds a master’s degree in computer data analytics and is from Vietnam; his niece, who is also a local and was celebrating her 56th class reunion,...read full review
awesome place. highly recommend
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 5 - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 5 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 5 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 5 - 10PM |
| Friday | 5 - 11PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 11PM |
| Sunday | 5 - 10PM |
People in McCall Also Viewed
The Mill Steak and Spirits offers a good atmosphere and great drinks. The decor is rustic and genuine, with a circular fireplace, paintings, traps, and a variety of beer taps around the lounge, creating an interesting and authentic setting. The ribeye is juicy, and the prime rib was also praised for being great. The service is friendly and personal, making guests feel welcomed and cared for. The food generally arrives in a timely manner, and the overall experience is positive, with some reviews calling it the best meal in McCall. However, some dishes like the Idaho Rainbow Trout may lack flavor and need extra seasoning, and salads and appetizers could use improvement. While long waits for food can occur in large groups, the atmosphere and quality make it a decent spot with room for enhancement, reflected in its 3.5-star rating. Overall, it is considered a real deal, offering a charming and inviting dining experience.