As close as it gets to east coast pizza Family gets pizza from here a lot, when ever I’m in town, I get one to eat on way home and one to have at home
If your from Philly or at least Jersey, you will appreciate it
Thin crust, big slice, greasy
Delicious
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ellie Phelan
I'm from Connecticut and recently moved to Idaho. I've been struggling to find pizza that compares to the pizza we get in NY and New Haven. This is probably the closest I've found, very happy I gave this place a go, it'll likely be my go to pizza spot around here!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hector Logan
Well, we usually have great food. But this last visit not so good. The whole bottom of the pizza was burnt. We will check better before we leave next time. 9-12-25. We won't give up on you. 😂
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Rena Wrigley
Where else can you have a dinner date for $11?! My hubby and I eat here way too often. But the people are friendly, the food is great (those breadsticks 😋) and it's inexpensive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carson Park
Vanessa and Jess had great customer service. Even though it was 8 minutes before closing, they showed the best service and provided hot on the spot ready pizza! Johnny Bronx is a great New York style slice. Good music plays at this location as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doosan Lipskin
One of my favorite pizza stops. Especially like seeing what their special pizza is each time I stop in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tony Seckington
Best pizza!!!
Chris Trowbridge
This is one of our favorite places to get pizza in the valley so far! We love New York style pizza and this place is really close to the real deal. If they added buffalo wings and blue cheese to their menu they'd be perfect!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eric McBride
Great pizza, beer on tap, cool environment with huge garage style door opening to the outdoor seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Alex Gir
I ordered a pizza from door dash to pick up. It took them 40 minutes to make it, when I asked I was told it's my fault I got there early. I got there at the time the app told me to pick up. I ordered it at 8:20 and they close at 9 I saw them busy with cleaning and closing maybe that's why it took so long. Either they didn't notice my order or they didn't care and just wanted to go home. The restaurant was empty.
If you want an authentic NY slice.. this is the place. Thin, crispy, and no flop! Dave Portnoy would approve!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcus Berber
I do DoorDash on the side and came to pick up an order, I had arrived a little before I was suppose to pick up the order I was assigned to and one of the ladies who works here came out with an order and asked if I was here with doordash, I told her I was and before I could even give her the name she shoved the food through my window and said there you go and next time can you come inside and let us know thanks appreciate you. Then walked back inside. I checked the order and it wasn’t even the order I was assigned to. I had to walk back in and tell them it was wrong and the order I was there for wasn’t even ready for me to pick up. She’s pretty freaking rude and unprofessional. She didn’t even apologize for being rude or giving me the wrong order. I definitely would not eat here if that’s how she treats the drivers, I’d hate to see how she treats guests.
Doc Bohemian
As a first time customer, I was pleased to receive the excellent customer service provided by Andrea. Her knowledge of the menu is exceptional and got me acquainted with their Scarface pizza- a Detroit style deep dish pizza that is out of this world. I will gladly return- great service, positive atmosphere, and excellent food. I can hardly wait to try their other menu items- and their reasonable prices make that a certainty.
Clarence Covington
I've been in Idaho for 44 years now originally from the East Coast and I have to say this is the closest I have tasted to authentic New York or Philly pizza. Will definitely be my go to spot for pizza.
As close as it gets to east coast pizza
Family gets pizza from here a lot, when ever I’m in town, I get one to eat on way home and one to have at home
If your from Philly or at least Jersey, you will appreciate it
Thin crust, big slice, greasy
Delicious
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I'm from Connecticut and recently moved to Idaho. I've been struggling to find pizza that compares to the pizza we get in NY and New Haven. This is probably the closest I've found, very happy I gave this place a go, it'll likely be my go to pizza spot around here!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well, we usually have great food. But this last visit not so good. The whole bottom of the pizza was burnt. We will check better before we leave next time.
9-12-25. We won't give up on you. 😂
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Where else can you have a dinner date for $11?! My hubby and I eat here way too often. But the people are friendly, the food is great (those breadsticks 😋) and it's inexpensive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vanessa and Jess had great customer service. Even though it was 8 minutes before closing, they showed the best service and provided hot on the spot ready pizza! Johnny Bronx is a great New York style slice. Good music plays at this location as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my favorite pizza stops. Especially like seeing what their special pizza is each time I stop in.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizza!!!
This is one of our favorite places to get pizza in the valley so far! We love New York style pizza and this place is really close to the real deal. If they added buffalo wings and blue cheese to their menu they'd be perfect!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great pizza, beer on tap, cool environment with huge garage style door opening to the outdoor seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I ordered a pizza from door dash to pick up. It took them 40 minutes to make it, when I asked I was told it's my fault I got there early. I got there at the time the app told me to pick up. I ordered it at 8:20 and they close at 9 I saw them busy with cleaning and closing maybe that's why it took so long. Either they didn't notice my order or they didn't care and just wanted to go home. The restaurant was empty.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome pizza and good customer service.
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you want an authentic NY slice.. this is the place. Thin, crispy, and no flop! Dave Portnoy would approve!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I do DoorDash on the side and came to pick up an order, I had arrived a little before I was suppose to pick up the order I was assigned to and one of the ladies who works here came out with an order and asked if I was here with doordash, I told her I was and before I could even give her the name she shoved the food through my window and said there you go and next time can you come inside and let us know thanks appreciate you. Then walked back inside. I checked the order and it wasn’t even the order I was assigned to. I had to walk back in and tell them it was wrong and the order I was there for wasn’t even ready for me to pick up. She’s pretty freaking rude and unprofessional. She didn’t even apologize for being rude or giving me the wrong order. I definitely would not eat here if that’s how she treats the drivers, I’d hate to see how she treats guests.
As a first time customer, I was pleased to receive the excellent customer service provided by Andrea. Her knowledge of the menu is exceptional and got me acquainted with their Scarface pizza- a Detroit style deep dish pizza that is out of this world.
I will gladly return- great service, positive atmosphere, and excellent food. I can hardly wait to try their other menu items- and their reasonable prices make that a certainty.
I've been in Idaho for 44 years now originally from the East Coast and I have to say this is the closest I have tasted to authentic New York or Philly pizza. Will definitely be my go to spot for pizza.
Loading...