Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

840 E Alameda Rd Ste. D, Pocatello
(208) 232-6931

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Oh man! I used to go to the Papa Kelsey's in Twin Falls all of the time. Then my sisters became gluten-free. I haven't been back since. My life hasn't been the same.

I went to this location. At my first bite, my childhood came back. It was joyous. The fresh dough brought my innocence back in my life again. It was well worth the food. Zack signing off.
The staff and restaurant were great. I was greeted as I walked through the door, the restaurant smelled amazing, and the staff were friendly and hustling their butts off. It took them roughly 10 minutes from order to out the door. The owner even sat and talked to me for a moment about making pizza and about how he makes his dough fresh daily(which shows the dough could use a bit more time developing flavor from the yeast) the pizza all together was a solid pizza. At first I...
Great pizza. Really sweet & tasty sauce. I had the Philly steak sub (excellent) and my wife enjoyed her huge chef’s salad. We also got some cheesy garlic bread. Really quick service, too.

More Reviews