11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rexburg

“great food. the pizza was on point“

“Came to town to visit family and an ad for this place was with my hotel key. We decided to try it out not only was it deliver super fast but it was piping hot when we got it. Amazing pizza I will definitely be ordering again on this trip!“

“Curry pizza is the best! I went to the Rexburg location and the service was absolutely amazing! The employees are so kind and the food is absolutely incredible! The butter chicken is full of flavor and tastes so good! The honey curry pizza is also absolutely amazing!! I could eat curry pizza everyday and never get bored! They have food options for everyone!“

“This location is awesome! I don't go often, but their service is really great and fast. There was one time we ordered through Uber Eats and Uber Eats didn't communicate that there wasn't a driver and Papa Murphy's was about to close. We called Papa Murphy's, they told us what was going on, and were willing to let us pick up our pizza through the drive through even though they were technically closed by the time we got there. Each time the pizza has tasted great and the workers were fast, friendly and helpful.“

“My favorite place to eat!“

“food was great, service was lacking. server did not come check in our table one time after food was delivered to the table. ended up getting another server to get us a to go box and our server to get our check. won't be back to dine in as service was inadequate. pick up or delivery is best way here!!!!“

“Oh, how I, with the enthusiasm of a thousand gleeful squirrels, passionately adore the culinary marvel known as Papa John's! The ambrosial liquid gold that they affectionately refer to as 'sauce' is nothing short of a miraculous elixir, while their toppings ascend to the pantheon of gastronomic splendor, rivaling only the most illustrious of toppings found in the annals of pizza history. Now, I must admit, there are fleeting moments when the sausage may occasionally betray its delicious destiny and taste akin to a rather disheartened rubber band, yet I assure you, every other component of this pizza masterpiece is nothing short of pure, unadulterated perfection! I cannot extol enough the virtues of their cheese sticks, particularly the illustrious Tuscan six-cheese creation; my goodness, the flavor is a rhapsody of delight, and the crust's formidable structural integrity – nay, a veritable fortress! – oversees the fantastical assembly of cheesy wonder, which, in my humble yet profoundly wise estimation, stands tall among the upper echelon of pizza magnificence. Furthermore, the euphoric flavors dance in my mouth in an extravagant wave, with sweet notes that elude mere mortals' descriptions, leaving gastronomes flabbergasted and speechless! One simply must embark on this delectable adventure for oneself. Now, let us not overlook their Oreo bites, which burst forth with such a cacophony of robust sweetness that one could very well imagine they were conjured from Willy Wonka's most outlandish dreams. With a cornucopia of choices that cater splendidly to the varied whims of pizza enthusiasts, not to mention their signature garlic sauce—though I must confess I fall outside the camp that appreciates its unique charm, my boyfriend, the garlic aficionado, positively revels in its garlicky embrace. Indeed, I wholeheartedly endorse this culinary establishment over the likes of Doorzza, Papa Murphy’s, Little Caesars, and rest assured, they unquestionably out-pizza the Hut! A prestigious 9 out of 10 on my utterly subjective and delightfully whimsical rating scale!“

“They were wonderful. Someone instantly jumped to help, everyone was smiling, patient, helpful,“

“We stopped in Rexburg for the evening and tried this little hidden gem. Great food, staff, and atmosphere. Everything was made to perfection and I can’t wait to stop in again when I am in town.“

“I am absolutely sold on this place. The customer service is #1. They really care about their customers and stand behind the product they sell. They want their customers happy and I'm that guy. Thank you ! I'm gonna spread the word about this place. Great things happen here.“

“Dietary restrictions: As in all pizzerias, you order what’s on it.
I think all pizza places here have gluten free choices, too.

Parking: At least 2 parking spaces per business, there is ample parking.

Kid-friendliness: All good!! Just don’t let them play in the street…

Wheelchair accessibility: Well, it’s ONLY handicapped accessible AFTER you get up onto the sidewalk in front of the businesses… 6-8” step up!“