29$ for one large pizza is insane ! overpriced for its location, also made my stomach hurt the last 2 times I ate it something wrong with the ingredients must be old or something . 0/10 trash
Olga Makri Japczyk
Great pizza, fantastic staff
Reid Roberts
Great place! Great Food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Ex Sausage Pizza
Rose A.
great pizza - friendly staff - pizza ready quickly ordered many times and always great
Britton
My go to spot for Pizza. Don't be afraid to be creative with their ingredients. I have them make a Mediterranean w/beef dipped in Au jus Gravy ?.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Merrill D.
What is wrong with me, I've haven't talked about Sal's? There are many things wrong with me, and that 4000 page book is for another time. The little pizza places are what I always look for. Sal's is a staple. Don't be fooled by it's location and exterior appearance, this workhorse is around the corner of a 7-eleven building. The appearance is small but internally, thanks to the hard workers doing their thing, they produce some great pizza. Their tavern style is classic, thin (but not cracker thin) crust has generous, tangy sauce, and hearty, fresh toppings. I like that the sausage isn't too salty like other places. Don't sleep on their wings, they are meaty and done right. Sal's is 100% pickup or delivery. They have other options for pizza, appetizers, hot sandwiches, pasta, ribs, salad, etc. Dave Portnoy recently put them on an extended map..beyond word of mouth from locals. I never expected him to show up near my neck of the woods, but if he was in search of a "real deal" or "go-to" tavern-style pizza, he made the right decision. Even without One Bite, Sal's was already award-winning. Be sure to use their coupons as they gladly accept them.
Marcella Mecher
Our catering orders are always phenomenal. I love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynne Cook
The best pizza in Algonquin!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Garcia
Sals always passes the vibe check. The pizza is great! The staff is always friendly and the delivery service is exceptional. We've never had an issue and we've been ordering for years. The taste is always consistent. You truly couldn't ask for better quality. Thanks always guys!!
Both the thin crust and pan pizza are excellent. I can't pick only one so I get both when I order. Try it, you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Kozi-Lester
Thank's Sal and Guest Great Family TimesThank's SAL HOPE U STAY OPEN LATE ? AND GET THE FREE PIZZA ? GOING LIKE DOMINO'S ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff W.
Fantastic pizza. Reminds me of how pizza should be made. On time and hot. This is a place I drive an hour to go to
Tim D.
Pretty sure I tried it in 2022, and thought it was ok. Fast forward to late fall 2023, saw Bar stool sports review it, and thought oh I know where that place is. Curious to see what David Portnoy would say. A week later we went to a relatives house and they suggested ordering it. We got a different pizza and my thought was this is very good. We will go back again. Glad to help out the smaller business places.
29$ for one large pizza is insane ! overpriced for its location, also made my stomach hurt the last 2 times I ate it something wrong with the ingredients must be old or something . 0/10 trash
Great pizza, fantastic staff
Great place! Great Food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Ex Sausage Pizza
great pizza - friendly staff - pizza ready quickly ordered many times and always great
My go to spot for Pizza. Don't be afraid to be creative with their ingredients. I have them make a Mediterranean w/beef dipped in Au jus Gravy ?.
Food: 5
Service: 5
What is wrong with me, I've haven't talked about Sal's? There are many things wrong with me, and that 4000 page book is for another time. The little pizza places are what I always look for. Sal's is a staple. Don't be fooled by it's location and exterior appearance, this workhorse is around the corner of a 7-eleven building. The appearance is small but internally, thanks to the hard workers doing their thing, they produce some great pizza. Their tavern style is classic, thin (but not cracker thin) crust has generous, tangy sauce, and hearty, fresh toppings. I like that the sausage isn't too salty like other places. Don't sleep on their wings, they are meaty and done right. Sal's is 100% pickup or delivery. They have other options for pizza, appetizers, hot sandwiches, pasta, ribs, salad, etc. Dave Portnoy recently put them on an extended map..beyond word of mouth from locals. I never expected him to show up near my neck of the woods, but if he was in search of a "real deal" or "go-to" tavern-style pizza, he made the right decision. Even without One Bite, Sal's was already award-winning. Be sure to use their coupons as they gladly accept them.
Our catering orders are always phenomenal. I love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza in Algonquin!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sals always passes the vibe check. The pizza is great! The staff is always friendly and the delivery service is exceptional. We've never had an issue and we've been ordering for years. The taste is always consistent. You truly couldn't ask for better quality. Thanks always guys!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza at a reasonable price...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Always coming back home to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Both the thin crust and pan pizza are excellent. I can't pick only one so I get both when I order. Try it, you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thank's Sal and Guest Great Family TimesThank's SAL HOPE U STAY OPEN LATE ? AND GET THE FREE PIZZA ? GOING LIKE DOMINO'S ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic pizza. Reminds me of how pizza should be made. On time and hot. This is a place I drive an hour to go to
Pretty sure I tried it in 2022, and thought it was ok. Fast forward to late fall 2023, saw Bar stool sports review it, and thought oh I know where that place is. Curious to see what David Portnoy would say. A week later we went to a relatives house and they suggested ordering it. We got a different pizza and my thought was this is very good. We will go back again. Glad to help out the smaller business places.