Batavia Creamery

4 N Island Ave, Batavia
(630) 482-3729

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Khrissy Gads

I ordered a custom ice cream cake for my husband's birthday. The owner kindly walked me through all the options and came up with some fun ideas. Upon pickup, the detail and design were amazing and the cake was SO good. Can't wait to order more!

Angelette Pooh-Moore

THANK YOU FOR DOING A WONDERFUL JOB ON MY DAUGHTER'S 21ST BIRTHDAY CAKE IT LOOKED JUST AS GREAT AS IT TASTED ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Dee Dee Dabzz

This place has the best ice cream in the area in my opinion. every pay day I'm coming here.

Michelle Casaccio

I never write reviews but this Oreo ice cream pie deserves one. The pie was a hit at our Christmas Eve party! Everyone said it was the best they ever had. Also, the kids loved the Santa ice cream scoops! Thank you so much for your amazing customer service and delicious treats. Will be back. :)

james northey

Many different out of the ordinary flavors. Inexpensive, patient and friendly staff. The dark chocolate raspberry truffle was great would definitely go back

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Brownie Sundae

Lora Vodicka

Some of the best ice cream in the area! Unique flavors with great textures and perfect taste. Staff is so helpful and very friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

expired oats

the staff is so incredibly kind, your experience feels very personal. the area is clean and always feels inviting. my last day in town for a while and i visited just for their brownie sundae, extremely worth it :]

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Ice Cream Cone

Erica L

LOVED it. Let us taste several kinds before deciding. Cute little location, friendly staff. And different types of flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Schlagel

Small ice cream shop with plenty of options. Everyone is extremely friendly & really great with kids. Never had a bad ice cream. They will give you a sample before buying which is extremely helpful with indecisive kiddos. Highly recommend. Inside & outside seating

Parking: When it gets busy the parking lot can fill up but there's plenty of parking between the parking lot & street parking down town and on the streets

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone

Alyssa Potthast

Best spot for icecream. I've enjoyed every flavor I've tried. The staff and owners are equally awesome!

This is and always will be our go to place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diana Cummins

Really disappointed.. Went in yesterday for my husband to choose for a cake or pie he decided on pie.. we had it last night for his birthday party and unfortunately one of our guest found a hair in it.. clearly wasn’t any of our hairs.. was really upset… Not sure if I would go back and purchase a cake or pie again…

Parking: Very crowded place to find parking.

Recommended dishes: Shaved Ice

Tara J

Hands down the best ice cream shop….to have ever existed. I love that there’s new flavors every time we go. The homemade waffle cones are SOO delicious. The employees are always super friendly. It’s hard not to go in for a treat every week. Different scoop and cone sizes is a game changer. Thank you for being around!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Turner

Your standard ice cream and options. Friendly staff and good location. Close to the river to walk off the treats.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

BadCobra2

They didn’t give us the ice cream we wanted (vanilla) and there was visibly enough. Always crowded and literally anyone could walk out without paying. Otherwise, Key Lime Pie ice cream was incredible. Best I’ve had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Gelato

Ashley Strubel

We have always loved coming to get ice cream here as there is so many awesome selections and options for those who can't have dairy. I was extremely upset on my latest visit as multiple employees were extremely rude. There was a line out the door and 3 employees leaning against the counter. They were frustrated that people were not all fitting and asked me to move forward to let others in. Unfortunately with the capacity of the line we could not move forward so I replied "I'm not sure where you want us to move forward to." She turned to her coworker who both rolled their eyes at me and proceeded to talk about me. I looked at her and smiled to let her know I'm watching and can see her facial reactions. She proceeded to then complain to multiple coworkers about me. After about 5 mins of her sitting against the counter she asked who was next which happened to be my party which she was not thrilled to be helping. I understand that the staff is young but they need to learn how to not be so rude to customers and while busy step up to the plate and help. Out of the 5 or so employees I only saw 3 really busy consistently to get the line down. Really disappointed in our visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Loading...