Pagliai's Pizza
509 S Illinois Ave, Carbondale
(618) 549-4241
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Hamburger and Ham Pizza
Pagliai's Special Pizza
Joe's Special Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
Favorite Pizza
Italian Beef
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza
Pagliai's
Sausage
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I was debating on how many stars to give. First the waitress was new, and horrible. Second we ordered a large Joes special, pan crust. It was $27 and some change. Then you charge $6 for crust. That makes the pizza $33. It was good but not $33 good, then charge $5.50 for the crust on a medium pizza. I don't think so. Then we leave and walk past the counter where 6 employees were standing and no one says thanks, have a good night etc. As we are exiting 1 waitress on the floor...
Fantastic dinner tonight! Met the new owners, fantastic people. We had a thin crust pizza and it was amazing. We opted for the chewy thin and it was perfect, toppings were great and the cheese was perfect. I had a fountain Coca Cola and my husband enjoyed Blue Moon on draft. Our server was very nice and the place was clean. 10 out of 10!! We cant wait to go back and try some sandwiches!
Paglai’s is still THE BEST pizza ever! The new owners have not changed a thing and are doing a fantastic job! The sausage tastes just as fresh and delicious as it always has! I highly recommend Pagliai’s Carbondale and i will definitely be back!
You May Also Like
Wazo's Big Chill - 508 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Jimmy John's - 515 1/2 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Bombay Olive - Authentic Indian Cuisine - 518 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Fine Dining, Indian