Pagliai's Pizza
509 S Illinois Ave, Carbondale
(618) 549-4241
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Hamburger and Ham Pizza
Pagliai's Special Pizza
Joe's Special Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
Everything Pizza
Favorite Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza
Italian Beef
Pagliai's
Menu
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We have been going to pags for about 35 years. Always loved their pizza. But they have new owners and they have switched the salad dressing to a cheaper item. They did have the best thousand island and French salad dressing. But dressing is not very good now. The pizza was still good although it was a little cold when they brought it to our table.
I was debating on how many stars to give. First the waitress was new, and horrible. Second we ordered a large Joes special, pan crust. It was $27 and some change. Then you charge $6 for crust. That makes the pizza $33. It was good but not $33 good, then charge $5.50 for the crust on a medium pizza. I don't think so. Then we leave and walk past the counter where 6 employees were standing and no one says thanks, have a good night etc. As we are exiting 1 waitress on the floor...
You May Also Like
Wazo's Big Chill - 508 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Jimmy John's - 515 1/2 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Chango’s Bar & Grill - 519 S Illinois Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, Mexican
You could tell the staff was training and they were using paper tickets so it took awhile.
HOWEVER, the Coke was crispy and pizza...