Pizzas was good, nothing crazy special as anticipating, but apparently don’t get take out. Pretty disappointing to see this when we opened the box. Wet and messy soup. And no, we didn’t tilt it at any point. Oh well, no shortage of other pizza places around.
Food: 2
K H
Best Pizza in the area
Rebecca Clarke
This place was amazing! Did a carry out pizza. The angry goat. Pepperoni, spinach, goat cheese, and hot honey. Crust was so tasty and crispy, but doesn’t cut your mouth. When we picked it up, the restaurant had done good vibes. Very great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Sanaxay
I finally made my way over to Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company and here's my review. I've heard of Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company when they first opened and it's always been on my "to try" list but I just never got around to trying them. I don't know why, but was it because we've already picked out our favorite deep dish style pizza with Georgio's and Lou's? However, it's always been on the back of my mind. Then when Barstool's review came out it prompted me again to give this place a try. LOL, boy that was a mistake. After that, the wait times were up to 2 hours and 30 mins just to get your pie! Ugh, should've tried it when I had the chance.So I called yesterday at 4:00pm right when they opened and placed an order for two pies. One 14" with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, and a 9" Sweet Sting. I placed the order and they said 30 to 40 mins. SWEET! So I made my way over to the restaurant for pick up.ProTip: I tried searching everywhere to see approximately how much a 9" would feed and as well as the 14". After ordering it I can confirm that for the 9" this will comfortably feed two grown adults and for the 14" this will comfortably feed four grown adults.I get the restaurant and I was taken back by the meat market but then I remembered the Barstool video and they split the place with a meat market. I walk up and tell them I'm here to pick up and they asked if I wanted it cut. I know why, because if you leave it uncut and cut it yourself at home the edges are more crispier. I told them to go ahead and cut it and I went over to the slot machines to try to win some money for some free pizza but that was not the case today. Slots 1, Jim 0. I digress. Hopefully the pizza taste better than my slot play. I get the pizza and head home.I advise my mother-in-law that this pizza joint received rave reviews and she's the BIGGEST food critic. So our review of the pizza are exactly the same, so what did we think?It's a great pie. The ingredient match well with each other and are fresh. The pizza sauce it self was very neutral and this is NOT a bad thing. It was not too sweet, not too salty, not too tangy with spices, just neutral and you just taste the fresh tomatoes which is excellent. The cheese it melty and gooey and down right addictively delicious. The crust is on a different level to that of Georgio's and Lou's. It's crunchy, exquisite, and quite frankly, it hooks you in. You CANNOT stop eating it and just go back for more and more. My wife had reservations about getting the Sweet Sting Pie as she was leary of the homemade habanero honey as she didn't want it to be too spicy but this was not the case whatsoever. It's the right amount of heat that keeps you going back for more. Our quasi-supreme pizza was delectable as well and dare I say 'Mother-in-Law approved' :)Georgio's and Lou's have always been a staple in our house hold for good ole Chicago Deep Dish style pizza but now I have to really rethink our pizza options. I hold those restaurants in the highest regard but now Uncle Jerry has a seat at our table and he knows how to make a damn good pie.With that said, I'm thankful Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company is in the neighborhood and they are so good that it's worth telling your friends and family to try out and travel for some damn good pizza. Congratulations you've earned my 5 star Google review. Keep up the great job!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
Ryne Obenauf
Sausage is great. I normally don't like sausage pizza. Also the stinger.... OMG it was so friggin good. Friendly staff.Recently went back and somehow the pizza got better. Keep it up!
tony pasko
The pizza was excellent and Nancy and Jerry do a great job of running the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daren D
Don't believe the kooks giving one star reviews. The pizza is amazing. If you want to dine in, plan accordingly - it's a small place. But you won't find more delicious deep dish anywhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
Bro C H Bogda Ministries Intl
New waiter, wondering what the experience would be with someone more seasoned. I know that the industry is struggling with getting good help. We still tipped well and hope that they can stay and improve, we will continue to
Pizza was awesome. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Classic Pepperoni
Pizzas was good, nothing crazy special as anticipating, but apparently don’t get take out. Pretty disappointing to see this when we opened the box. Wet and messy soup. And no, we didn’t tilt it at any point. Oh well, no shortage of other pizza places around.
Food: 2
Best Pizza in the area
This place was amazing! Did a carry out pizza. The angry goat. Pepperoni, spinach, goat cheese, and hot honey. Crust was so tasty and crispy, but doesn’t cut your mouth. When we picked it up, the restaurant had done good vibes. Very great place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I finally made my way over to Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company and here's my review. I've heard of Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company when they first opened and it's always been on my "to try" list but I just never got around to trying them. I don't know why, but was it because we've already picked out our favorite deep dish style pizza with Georgio's and Lou's? However, it's always been on the back of my mind. Then when Barstool's review came out it prompted me again to give this place a try. LOL, boy that was a mistake. After that, the wait times were up to 2 hours and 30 mins just to get your pie! Ugh, should've tried it when I had the chance.So I called yesterday at 4:00pm right when they opened and placed an order for two pies. One 14" with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers, and a 9" Sweet Sting. I placed the order and they said 30 to 40 mins. SWEET! So I made my way over to the restaurant for pick up.ProTip: I tried searching everywhere to see approximately how much a 9" would feed and as well as the 14". After ordering it I can confirm that for the 9" this will comfortably feed two grown adults and for the 14" this will comfortably feed four grown adults.I get the restaurant and I was taken back by the meat market but then I remembered the Barstool video and they split the place with a meat market. I walk up and tell them I'm here to pick up and they asked if I wanted it cut. I know why, because if you leave it uncut and cut it yourself at home the edges are more crispier. I told them to go ahead and cut it and I went over to the slot machines to try to win some money for some free pizza but that was not the case today. Slots 1, Jim 0. I digress. Hopefully the pizza taste better than my slot play. I get the pizza and head home.I advise my mother-in-law that this pizza joint received rave reviews and she's the BIGGEST food critic. So our review of the pizza are exactly the same, so what did we think?It's a great pie. The ingredient match well with each other and are fresh. The pizza sauce it self was very neutral and this is NOT a bad thing. It was not too sweet, not too salty, not too tangy with spices, just neutral and you just taste the fresh tomatoes which is excellent. The cheese it melty and gooey and down right addictively delicious. The crust is on a different level to that of Georgio's and Lou's. It's crunchy, exquisite, and quite frankly, it hooks you in. You CANNOT stop eating it and just go back for more and more. My wife had reservations about getting the Sweet Sting Pie as she was leary of the homemade habanero honey as she didn't want it to be too spicy but this was not the case whatsoever. It's the right amount of heat that keeps you going back for more. Our quasi-supreme pizza was delectable as well and dare I say 'Mother-in-Law approved' :)Georgio's and Lou's have always been a staple in our house hold for good ole Chicago Deep Dish style pizza but now I have to really rethink our pizza options. I hold those restaurants in the highest regard but now Uncle Jerry has a seat at our table and he knows how to make a damn good pie.With that said, I'm thankful Uncle Jerry's Pizza Company is in the neighborhood and they are so good that it's worth telling your friends and family to try out and travel for some damn good pizza. Congratulations you've earned my 5 star Google review. Keep up the great job!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
Sausage is great. I normally don't like sausage pizza. Also the stinger.... OMG it was so friggin good. Friendly staff.Recently went back and somehow the pizza got better. Keep it up!
The pizza was excellent and Nancy and Jerry do a great job of running the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don't believe the kooks giving one star reviews. The pizza is amazing. If you want to dine in, plan accordingly - it's a small place. But you won't find more delicious deep dish anywhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
New waiter, wondering what the experience would be with someone more seasoned. I know that the industry is struggling with getting good help. We still tipped well and hope that they can stay and improve, we will continue to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Such good pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza and beer and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Classic Sausage Pizza
A bit crowded. But the Honey pepperoni pizza is worth the wait.A must try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
Excellent and very tasty pizza. But there could be some more seating space in the restaurant. Very busy because of the good food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
So good. Such nice people. How can you go wrong ?? love sweet sting! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Uncle Jerry's Sweet Sting Pepperoni Cup & Hot Honey Pizza
As good as el presidente recommended! I'd recommend getting there between 2-3pm. Pizza takes awhile and that's an easy time to find a table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5