It was $40 for a standard two-topping, 18in. thin crust pizza (not including delivery or tip). What happened? I recommend finding another pizza joint after these drastic price increases.
Nitya Joshi
It’s really really hard to find any type of new york style pizza in Chicago, but this place really hit the spot. It’ll be my new go to place when I crave it!
Prateek N.
Just a rock solid place to get a slice of newyork style pizza in Chicago, including a couple of veg. options.Apparently they have been in business for the past 29 years. That means it gotta be good..... and it is!
Shelley Harmon
Absolutely love this thin sliced New York style pizza served by the slice. Chewy crust, perfect amount of sauce and heated up to crispy perfection. Yum!!
Laura E
This is the only pizza place I order from in my neighborhood! I grew up in NY so am probably biased but I love it and cures my homesickness. Slices, rather than square, are a must for NY style pizza. I go here so much, they recognize me ???.
anna Trey
We loved the pizza. Half pepperoni half spinach ricotta tomato. We are in the suburbs and this pizzeria by far surpasses the local pizza places. Highly recommend.
DPSplumber
We had Luigi pizza today for lunch in the office. It was delicious and very filling. A large pie was gone in less than a minute.
Greg Wagner
Best NY style in the whole city. Took the first two years of living in Chicago to find a pizza with classic thin crust that was actually good! No longer live there but it's reason enough to move back.
Louis Lello
This is the best nyc style pizza I've had in town. I make a point to stop by here anytime I'm in the area.
Joanna Kim
Our go-to whenever we get the craving for pizza! We’re from NYC and are so grateful to have found Cafe Luigi’s! We order from here at least once a month. Our go-to is a plain cheese pizza and garlic knots!
Pizza taste was horrible. Became very sick after eating. How do you mess up pizza??? Toppings are expensive. Not recommended at all.
Sybil Kibble
Extremely delicious slices, was delighted to find NY style pizza in Chicago. :)
Aditya Venkitarama
I had an unpleasant experience at Cafe Luigi Pizza - I recommend staying away from ordering on their website. They work with Slice Rewards, which is an extremely unreliable third party coordinator for delivery/pick-up orders.I paid for a pizza and received a confirmation from Slice Rewards that my pickup order had been placed. When I showed up to the restaurant, the staff said I never placed an order and tried to get me to pay again in person to remake the order, even after I showed them proof that I had already paid online. On top of that, the staff could not provide a contact number for me to dispute the issue and refused to take any responsibility for the situation. This business is extremely unprofessional and blatantly disregards the needs of their customers. I was not able to get a refund or pizza in person, so Slice Rewards said they would post a refund to my bank account in 3-5 business days. I will never order from this establishment or Slice Rewards again.
Yousif ElWasila
This place has one of the best New York style pizza in Chicago. Delicious and Cheesy!!!Great staff and great service.
Anthony D.
Excellent pizza shop that sells by the slice. These slices are gigantic! They also had calzones, but I was way too full to try one. They warm it up when you order and the Supreme slice I had was made with fresh ingredients and absolutely delicious.
It was $40 for a standard two-topping, 18in. thin crust pizza (not including delivery or tip). What happened? I recommend finding another pizza joint after these drastic price increases.
It’s really really hard to find any type of new york style pizza in Chicago, but this place really hit the spot. It’ll be my new go to place when I crave it!
Just a rock solid place to get a slice of newyork style pizza in Chicago, including a couple of veg. options.Apparently they have been in business for the past 29 years. That means it gotta be good..... and it is!
Absolutely love this thin sliced New York style pizza served by the slice. Chewy crust, perfect amount of sauce and heated up to crispy perfection. Yum!!
This is the only pizza place I order from in my neighborhood! I grew up in NY so am probably biased but I love it and cures my homesickness. Slices, rather than square, are a must for NY style pizza. I go here so much, they recognize me ???.
We loved the pizza. Half pepperoni half spinach ricotta tomato. We are in the suburbs and this pizzeria by far surpasses the local pizza places. Highly recommend.
We had Luigi pizza today for lunch in the office. It was delicious and very filling. A large pie was gone in less than a minute.
Best NY style in the whole city. Took the first two years of living in Chicago to find a pizza with classic thin crust that was actually good! No longer live there but it's reason enough to move back.
This is the best nyc style pizza I've had in town. I make a point to stop by here anytime I'm in the area.
Our go-to whenever we get the craving for pizza! We’re from NYC and are so grateful to have found Cafe Luigi’s! We order from here at least once a month. Our go-to is a plain cheese pizza and garlic knots!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza taste was horrible. Became very sick after eating. How do you mess up pizza??? Toppings are expensive. Not recommended at all.
Extremely delicious slices, was delighted to find NY style pizza in Chicago. :)
I had an unpleasant experience at Cafe Luigi Pizza - I recommend staying away from ordering on their website. They work with Slice Rewards, which is an extremely unreliable third party coordinator for delivery/pick-up orders.I paid for a pizza and received a confirmation from Slice Rewards that my pickup order had been placed. When I showed up to the restaurant, the staff said I never placed an order and tried to get me to pay again in person to remake the order, even after I showed them proof that I had already paid online. On top of that, the staff could not provide a contact number for me to dispute the issue and refused to take any responsibility for the situation. This business is extremely unprofessional and blatantly disregards the needs of their customers. I was not able to get a refund or pizza in person, so Slice Rewards said they would post a refund to my bank account in 3-5 business days. I will never order from this establishment or Slice Rewards again.
This place has one of the best New York style pizza in Chicago. Delicious and Cheesy!!!Great staff and great service.
Excellent pizza shop that sells by the slice. These slices are gigantic! They also had calzones, but I was way too full to try one. They warm it up when you order and the Supreme slice I had was made with fresh ingredients and absolutely delicious.
Loading...