We got the flight of 4 ice cream flavors for $9. The Golden Cone was smack you in the face sweet, the pistachio was super green and clearly artificially colored/flavored, the oreo cheesecake was balanced with it not being overly oreo or overly cream cheese, and the caramel macchiato had a lovely strong coffee flavor. I would have liked it better if it was just coffee...no caramel. But, I'm sure I'm in the minority here. Lol
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Aarzoo Kothari
Icecream was really okay! The place seems njce and server was sweet person. But the quality of ice cream was really average.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sundae
Cristian Hernández
Amazed by this ice-ice Cream!
You must get the Guinness, Baileys, and Jameson.
Now, my person favorite is the Lemon (Fruit ice) Sorbet. It used to be the ice cream flight with above flavors and Netflix & chill, Cinnamon (no longer available).
It should be nice to select better music.
Vegetarian options: There are some
Dietary restrictions: This is not asked
Parking: Main street, so no easy to find a spot
Kid-friendliness: Yes, they have high chairs
Wheelchair accessibility: No really.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Single Scoop, Gelato, Ice Cream Selection
goldendragon35
This place has fallen off. Dipped cone not available and neither was the soft serve. For what they charge, not worth it
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Blasted Rat LLC
Amazing ice cream and a very friendly server!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S Ahmed
Been a few times. One of the only spots in the area to get a soft serve ice cream but something js off, ice cream and toppings always taste stale.
Nicole Rice
I’ve never been to an Irish ice cream shop but this one is great! Fun flavors and vegan/dairy free options in a separate case.
Elliot Smith
Mary Rapsky & Sean Mcguire's Cone Gourmet Ice Cream shop is a nice enough establishment, unfortunately the political orientation of the owners leaves something to be desired. As the United States veers ever deeper into a fascistic right-wing nightmare, Mary & Sean do not avail themselves of either their personal or their business platforms to advocate for democracy and justice, to the contrary, these two support fascism and white supremacy with their loud deafening silence, and they help to normalize fascists and right-wing racists, and jingoistic militarism and colonialism through their open association therewith. Other complaints I have is that their business does not respond to e-mail and DM messages, and, their ConeChicago web site is infected with a stealth virus that sporadically redirects their customers to a malicious malware website. Welcome to America Mary & Sean, your strong right-wing orientation and your alignment with the forces of bigotry and racism unfortunately fits right in with the preponderance of Irish Americans.
Machaela DeSano
I’ve given this place a few tries and after tonight’s visit, I’m especially disappointed. :( the ice cream is ok, not great (soft serve tasted good just more icey than creamy) but the staff is what does it!!! They are not very friendly or welcoming at all. While asking for sprinkles today they laughed at me and I swear that happened to me last time too. Is asking for extra sprinkles that ridiculous? Won’t be back. Ugh
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Luis Cartagenova
Great quality ice cream with classic as well as innovative flavors. Friendly service and generous scoops! Big fan of their ice cream flight!
Always good. Interesting flavors like the Cookie Monster but also soft serve (my dad had the vanilla/strawberry swirl). Cashier even said he discounted my order (Mother's Day discounts) on our order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Paladino
Went in 3 times to get soft serve that's listed on their menu. First time the machine was broken. 2nd time the employee said the machine was "cleaned for the night" even though it was 3 hours before close. 3rd time was "we don't do soft serve here" even though it's listed 4 different times on their menu in the restaurant. Do not recommend.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Anastacia Hanus
Tasty ice cream and friendly service! We got the cake batter and golden coyne flavors, but the caramel macchiato was a strong contender! The single scoop size was generous.
J Stone *
Cute place. Seating in back and outdoors too. You can get ice cream flights! 4 flavours for 8$. They give generous scoops for the normal cones/dish servings. They have vegan options too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Monster, Irish Mint Chip
We got the flight of 4 ice cream flavors for $9. The Golden Cone was smack you in the face sweet, the pistachio was super green and clearly artificially colored/flavored, the oreo cheesecake was balanced with it not being overly oreo or overly cream cheese, and the caramel macchiato had a lovely strong coffee flavor. I would have liked it better if it was just coffee...no caramel. But, I'm sure I'm in the minority here. Lol
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Icecream was really okay! The place seems njce and server was sweet person. But the quality of ice cream was really average.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sundae
Amazed by this ice-ice Cream!
You must get the Guinness, Baileys, and Jameson.
Now, my person favorite is the Lemon (Fruit ice) Sorbet. It used to be the ice cream flight with above flavors and Netflix & chill, Cinnamon (no longer available).
It should be nice to select better music.
Vegetarian options: There are some
Dietary restrictions: This is not asked
Parking: Main street, so no easy to find a spot
Kid-friendliness: Yes, they have high chairs
Wheelchair accessibility: No really.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Single Scoop, Gelato, Ice Cream Selection
This place has fallen off. Dipped cone not available and neither was the soft serve. For what they charge, not worth it
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Amazing ice cream and a very friendly server!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been a few times. One of the only spots in the area to get a soft serve ice cream but something js off, ice cream and toppings always taste stale.
I’ve never been to an Irish ice cream shop but this one is great! Fun flavors and vegan/dairy free options in a separate case.
Mary Rapsky & Sean Mcguire's Cone Gourmet Ice Cream shop is a nice enough establishment, unfortunately the political orientation of the owners leaves something to be desired. As the United States veers ever deeper into a fascistic right-wing nightmare, Mary & Sean do not avail themselves of either their personal or their business platforms to advocate for democracy and justice, to the contrary, these two support fascism and white supremacy with their loud deafening silence, and they help to normalize fascists and right-wing racists, and jingoistic militarism and colonialism through their open association therewith. Other complaints I have is that their business does not respond to e-mail and DM messages, and, their ConeChicago web site is infected with a stealth virus that sporadically redirects their customers to a malicious malware website. Welcome to America Mary & Sean, your strong right-wing orientation and your alignment with the forces of bigotry and racism unfortunately fits right in with the preponderance of Irish Americans.
I’ve given this place a few tries and after tonight’s visit, I’m especially disappointed. :( the ice cream is ok, not great (soft serve tasted good just more icey than creamy) but the staff is what does it!!! They are not very friendly or welcoming at all. While asking for sprinkles today they laughed at me and I swear that happened to me last time too. Is asking for extra sprinkles that ridiculous? Won’t be back. Ugh
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great quality ice cream with classic as well as innovative flavors. Friendly service and generous scoops!
Big fan of their ice cream flight!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great variety of ice creams and excellent service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good. Interesting flavors like the Cookie Monster but also soft serve (my dad had the vanilla/strawberry swirl). Cashier even said he discounted my order (Mother's Day discounts) on our order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in 3 times to get soft serve that's listed on their menu. First time the machine was broken. 2nd time the employee said the machine was "cleaned for the night" even though it was 3 hours before close. 3rd time was "we don't do soft serve here" even though it's listed 4 different times on their menu in the restaurant. Do not recommend.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Tasty ice cream and friendly service! We got the cake batter and golden coyne flavors, but the caramel macchiato was a strong contender! The single scoop size was generous.
Cute place. Seating in back and outdoors too. You can get ice cream flights! 4 flavours for 8$. They give generous scoops for the normal cones/dish servings. They have vegan options too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Monster, Irish Mint Chip
Loading...