New Paradise Bakery

5742 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago
(773) 993-0262

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pizzette with Pistachio and Ham
Arancini Aka Rice Ball - Ragu
Macchiato and Almond Cookies
Gelato \u0026Pistachio Cookie
Pizzette with Tomatoe Salsa
Pistachio Paradise Cannoli
Gelato &Pistachio Cookie
Almond Paste Cookies
Birthday Cake
Mini Cannoli

Gelato
Stracciatella - Sweet Cream Chocolate Drizzle (1 pt)
All-time creamy goodness. A delicious milk base mixed with a chocolate sauce that results in smooth creamy milk and light chocolate flavor.
Pistachio (1 pt)
Made with Sicily's finest pistachios blended to a smooth creamy texture and mixed with our creamy milk base to create a perfect pistachio delight. May contain pieces of pistachios.
Bacio - Milk Chocolate and Hazelnuts (1 pt)
Inspired by the famous bacio perugina chocolate. Flavors consisting of gianduja, more milk chocolate, and hazelnuts mixed to a creamy smooth texture. May contain chunks of chocolate and hazelnuts.
Frutti Di Bosco - Mixed Berries (Dairy Free) (1 pt)
Blackberries, raspberries, strawberries, blueberries, mashed together to create this perfect blend of very berry gelato.
Nocciola - Hazelnut (1 pt)
Hazelnuts blended into a creamy nut paste mixed with our creamy milk base cream to create a perfection of hazelnut gelato.
Dark Chocolate (Dairy-free) (1 pt)
A texture of a creamy refreshing and smooth real dark chocolate flavor. Best part is dairy-free.
Coffee (1 pt)
Our creamy gelato base is mixed with a smash of fresh coffee espresso to make the richest, creamiest, coffee gelato.

Sweet Bakery Items
Pistachio Mousse Ricotta Filled Cannoli
A deep-fried pastry shell filled with our rich sweetened sheep milk ricotta mixed with our pistachio cream nut base delight to create the perfect pistachio mousse filling. Topped with our green delicious pistachio nut pieces.
Sfogliatella Alla Whip Cream & Fresh Fruit
Sheets of puff pastry dough layered and baked to make a crispy, crunchy outer layer, filled and topped with real whipped cream and topped with fresh seasonal fruit.
Bombolone AKA Italian Filled Doughnut- Nutella
Big bombs of our soft fluffy dough filled with Nutella and rolled in sugar mixture.
Sfogliatella (AKA Custard Lobster Tails AKA Neapolitan)
Sheets of puff pastry dough layered and baked to make a crispy crunchy outer layer, filled with a custard mixture of light scents and pieces of candied orange. Topped with powdered sugar and a hint of cinnamon.
Traditional Sicilian Ricotta Filled Cannoli
A deep-fried pastry shell filled with our rich, sweetened sheep milk ricotta, mixed with chocolate chips, and topped with powdered sugar.
Bombolone AKA Italian Filled Doughnut- Pistachio
Big bombs of a soft fluffy dough filled with our signature pistachio nut butter cream and rolled in sugar mixture.
Tiramisu
An Italian favorite "pick me up". A Coffee flavor dessert made of lady fingers dipped in our signature espresso and layered with a whipped sweetened mascarpone cream and topped with cacao.
Pistachio Paradise Cannoli
Our 6 inches pastry shell is dipped in pistachio chocolate smothered in our green sicilian pistachios filled with our rich pastry pistachio nut cream to create a delightful pistachio explosion. An extreme richness of pistachio and more pistachio.
Bombolone AKA Italian Filled Doughnut- Apricot
Big bombs of soft fluffy dough filled with our sweet apricot jam and rolled in sugar mixture.
Pistachio Nut Butter Round Doughnuts.
A soft and fluffy round doughnut topped with our signature pistachio nut butter and crumbled with Sicilian Green Pistachios.
Cornetto AKA Little Horn AKA Italian Croissant - Nutella
An Italian version of the croissant. Cornetto dough is soft, sweet, and fluffy baked to perfection and filled with Nutella.
Cornetto AKA Little Horn AKA Italian Croissant - Pistachio
An Italian version of the croissant. Cornetto dough is soft, sweet, and fluffy baked to perfection and filled with our signature pistachio nut cream and topped more crumbled pistachios.
Cornetto AKA Little Horn AKA Italian Croissant - Sheep's Milk Ricotta
An Italian version of the croissant. Cornetto dough is soft, sweet, and fluffy baked to perfection and filled with cannoli ricotta cream mixed with chocolate chips.
Cornetto AKA Little Horn AKA Italian Croissant - Vanilla Custard
An Italian version of the croissant. Cornetto dough is soft, sweet, and fluffy baked to perfection and filled crema patisserie. (Vanilla pastry cream)

Cookies
Nutella Thumbprint Cookie Pack
A nutella cookie dough baked to chewy perfection and filled with Nutella, a chocolate hazelnut cream each cookie is approximately 2 and1/4" in round.
Almond Paste Cookies
A moist and chewy almond cookie dough on the inside with a crispy crunchy outside to create a natural sweet almond delight. Cookies will come in a variety of different art deco.
Italian butter cookie (1 pound)
A rich buttery cookie that is baked to create a crisp texture and then decorated with different sprinkles. (Cookies come in a variation of art deco)
Italian Chocolate Dipped Butter Cookies (1 pound)
A rich buttery cookie that is baked to create a crisp texture and then dipped in chocolate and Nutella. (Cookies come in a variation of art deco).

Savory Bakery Items
Arancini AKA Rice Ball - Ragu
Delicious, crispy, Sicilian balls of rice infused with saffron,coated with bread crumbs and fried to a crispy delight. Filled with a ragu meat sauce that does contain peas.
Arancini AKA Rice Ball - Burro Ham & Mozzarella
Delicious, crispy, Sicilian balls of rice infused with saffron,coated with bread crumbs and fried to a crispy delight. Filled ham and mozzarella.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+29 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+28 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

It was our first time here and we absolutely loved it. We tried the bomboleros and they were the incredible.

The owner, John, was super welcoming and treated us so kindly. He went out of his way to answer any questions we may have and we custom ordered a cake, which not to mention will be ready tomorrow morning!!
August 2025
Went there one Thursday night, 7:50pm, they are closing at 8pm. Girl was MAD we entered the place, she even said, we are closed but okay, I thought I locked the door. She had an attitude, complained that she has started cleaning in the back. More people came in, she got pretty rude. We certainly didn't feel welcome there.
July 2025
I am hoping it is just a fluke because I have been bragging about this place since they opened but my last two visits were disappointing. What ever changes they have implemented are not for the better. Perhaps managing multiple locations has put all eyes on the new place. The vibe is off, the pistachio gelato has taken on a neon tone and is gritty, the vanilla is also gritty and not the same quality, the other flavors are definitely not the same quality, the bombolone filling...
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Gladstone Lounge & Liquors - 5734 N Milwaukee Ave
Bar
Papa Joe's Pizza - 5750 N Milwaukee Ave
Pizza
Mom's Old Recipe - 5760 N Milwaukee Ave
Mexican, Vegetarian

New Paradise Bakery

5742 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60646
(773) 993-0262