I have to admit I walked past this place a million times... I am so happy I gave it a try.I love my thin crust Chicago style pizza to death but this NY style that PaulieGee has is fire . Vodka/Roni and The Big Bad Wolf " fuhgedaboutit"
Reginice
Ugh! I was so excited to try Pauline Gee’s when my cousin mentioned that they had vegan options. I ordered two vegan slices which had quite a few toppings, but was so bland. The most flavor came from the drizzle on top.I noticed they have two locations and the other has a more extensive vegan menu. I’m willing to give it another try at the other location, and maybe, if I order an entire pizza, it’ll be a better experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vegan, Pizza by the Slice
Reginice C.
Ugh! I was so excited to try Pauline Gee's when my cousin mentioned that they had vegan options. I ordered two vegan slices which had quite a few toppings, but was so bland. The most flavor came from the drizzle on top. I noticed they have two locations and the other has a more extensive vegan menu. I'm willing to give it another try at the other location, and maybe, if I order an entire pizza, it'll be a better experience.
Erik B.
Slice shop open until 2am that actually has several great tasting options. Thankfully a friend reminded me of this place after so much time outside of the city so that we could make a quick stop before we continued our late night up Milwaukee Ave. My go-to Sausage and Giardineira tasted great and the Vodka Roni was also a pleasant surprise that might be my new favorite topping combo. Quick and friendly service and although there was a good amount of people initially a table opened up pretty quickly so that our group of 4 could enjoy our slices along with the emo songs of our youth to nod along to in between bites. You can order full pizzas too at this location but I don't know how late that goes.
C D
It's a good NY style pizza. It tastes pretty much exactly like your average pizzeria in NYC. That's a compliment. But Chicago's best pizza is better than your average pizzeria in NYC, so i wouldn't rank this as one of Chicago's best pizza. But it's a good place to get a slice if you're in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf
Minh P.
Really delicious and well priced slice shop! Stopped by the Wicker Park location and was very pleasantly surprised. The slices put you back $4.25 for just cheese or $4.75 with toppings. They have lots of fun topping combos ready to go. Slices come out super quick and hot, with a crispy bottom and crust. I had the white fish pizza and really liked it! Would totally come back and try some more. Fair warning: no free water available; just bottled water available for purchase. The bathrooms in the back have codes on them, so ask the cashier if you need.
Josh D
Music is deafening.*edit* very immature response by the owner, buddy you should be upset that you lost a customer
Blake Levit
It’s unbelievable pizza if you like NY thin!! The sauce is really good and the Za just comes together like no other. Jimmys, Robert’s and our OG Bob’s are all stellar but Paulie gees tops the list for me. Add their pepperoni (the good stuff) and hot honey sit back and take down 2, 4, or 8 slices. Paulie Gee’s is famous in NY and Derrick (GREAT guy) opened two options here in Chicago. The NY expertise brought another level and so happy they are here.
Food: 5
Gary Ramos
Pizza was greasy and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Adrian C.
Pretty good pizza in wicker park it's different in a good way it's very thin pepperonie it's different small it's like cup char pepperonie it's not Chicago style but it's pretty good pizza want some good Chicago style pizza try JB ALBERTOS RICOBENNES this pizza will disappoint but try and stop by Pauline's gees pizza to try
I don't know why the bad reviews I don't work far from there and I honestly feel that there was nothing wrong with customer service, they we're very good respectful and understanding, the food was beyond what I expected I had to get more to go. Service was fast and they have a good view so check it out im definitely coming back. Thanks for everything @Pauliegee'swickerpark
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf
Amee Mi
23% service charges after tax for 2 people’s !! Check your receipts before you paid
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Justin Brown
Good pizza by the slice. I’ll be
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Marco Carballo
Every time I am surprised by how delicious the pizza is ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf, Logan Zaddy, Wicker Baby
Brian Keith Young
Incredible is the word I'm coming up with right now to describe this pizza but honestly that word doesn't fairly describe how good and pleasantly blown away by this pizza me and my friends were. Seeing any bad reviews about this place I can laugh off and know those people prolly needed a hug more than a ? piece of pizza. To whoever made our pizza tonight, thank you! Was our highlight of our weekend getaway. ?Logan Zaddy for president!!
I have to admit I walked past this place a million times... I am so happy I gave it a try.I love my thin crust Chicago style pizza to death but this NY style that PaulieGee has is fire . Vodka/Roni and The Big Bad Wolf " fuhgedaboutit"
Ugh! I was so excited to try Pauline Gee’s when my cousin mentioned that they had vegan options. I ordered two vegan slices which had quite a few toppings, but was so bland. The most flavor came from the drizzle on top.I noticed they have two locations and the other has a more extensive vegan menu. I’m willing to give it another try at the other location, and maybe, if I order an entire pizza, it’ll be a better experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vegan, Pizza by the Slice
Ugh! I was so excited to try Pauline Gee's when my cousin mentioned that they had vegan options. I ordered two vegan slices which had quite a few toppings, but was so bland. The most flavor came from the drizzle on top. I noticed they have two locations and the other has a more extensive vegan menu. I'm willing to give it another try at the other location, and maybe, if I order an entire pizza, it'll be a better experience.
Slice shop open until 2am that actually has several great tasting options. Thankfully a friend reminded me of this place after so much time outside of the city so that we could make a quick stop before we continued our late night up Milwaukee Ave. My go-to Sausage and Giardineira tasted great and the Vodka Roni was also a pleasant surprise that might be my new favorite topping combo. Quick and friendly service and although there was a good amount of people initially a table opened up pretty quickly so that our group of 4 could enjoy our slices along with the emo songs of our youth to nod along to in between bites. You can order full pizzas too at this location but I don't know how late that goes.
It's a good NY style pizza. It tastes pretty much exactly like your average pizzeria in NYC. That's a compliment. But Chicago's best pizza is better than your average pizzeria in NYC, so i wouldn't rank this as one of Chicago's best pizza. But it's a good place to get a slice if you're in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf
Really delicious and well priced slice shop! Stopped by the Wicker Park location and was very pleasantly surprised. The slices put you back $4.25 for just cheese or $4.75 with toppings. They have lots of fun topping combos ready to go. Slices come out super quick and hot, with a crispy bottom and crust. I had the white fish pizza and really liked it! Would totally come back and try some more. Fair warning: no free water available; just bottled water available for purchase. The bathrooms in the back have codes on them, so ask the cashier if you need.
Music is deafening.*edit* very immature response by the owner, buddy you should be upset that you lost a customer
It’s unbelievable pizza if you like NY thin!! The sauce is really good and the Za just comes together like no other. Jimmys, Robert’s and our OG Bob’s are all stellar but Paulie gees tops the list for me. Add their pepperoni (the good stuff) and hot honey sit back and take down 2, 4, or 8 slices. Paulie Gee’s is famous in NY and Derrick (GREAT guy) opened two options here in Chicago. The NY expertise brought another level and so happy they are here.
Food: 5
Pizza was greasy and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Pretty good pizza in wicker park it's different in a good way it's very thin pepperonie it's different small it's like cup char pepperonie it's not Chicago style but it's pretty good pizza want some good Chicago style pizza try JB ALBERTOS RICOBENNES this pizza will disappoint but try and stop by Pauline's gees pizza to try
Restaurantji Recommends
I don't know why the bad reviews I don't work far from there and I honestly feel that there was nothing wrong with customer service, they we're very good respectful and understanding, the food was beyond what I expected I had to get more to go. Service was fast and they have a good view so check it out im definitely coming back. Thanks for everything @Pauliegee'swickerpark
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf
23% service charges after tax for 2 people’s !! Check your receipts before you paid
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Good pizza by the slice. I’ll be
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Every time I am surprised by how delicious the pizza is ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Big Bad Wolf, Logan Zaddy, Wicker Baby
Incredible is the word I'm coming up with right now to describe this pizza but honestly that word doesn't fairly describe how good and pleasantly blown away by this pizza me and my friends were. Seeing any bad reviews about this place I can laugh off and know those people prolly needed a hug more than a ? piece of pizza. To whoever made our pizza tonight, thank you! Was our highlight of our weekend getaway. ?Logan Zaddy for president!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Logan Zaddy