Best tuna sandwich I've had in a long time from the deli!
Cara
Coffee, food, and market are great. Don’t order food if you’re in a rush though. I had to wait over 30 min for what’s essentially half a grill cheese.
Michael Karouzos
I ordered a simple iced coffee with light ice. I brought it to the attention of a worker that I felt like there was too much ice in it. She, then, gave me a hard time and made a comment to her coworker about my request.
As I'm leaving, and within earshot, she continued to talk about how she felt like she put enough ice in and that I was wrong...
I have worked as a barista and professional bean roaster for over a total of over 6 years. Not once have I treated someone that way. The iced coffee was already very watery, no doubt since they did the ratio wrong while brewing it (which i politely did not mention while in the shop) and then I get two bouts of hard time for it.
What a lack of basic customer service.
I thought this would be a cool place in the neighborhood, but I was wrong.
Mr. Rucker
Yes, definitely a must go and get there. They have plenty of vegan options and nice decor.
Nicole Stull
The best tomato soup I’ve ever had! Great corner shop.
F Mt
Hot take for 2026: PROVIDE MORE THAN FOUR CINNAMON BUNS EVERY MORNING 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄!
yvette r
$2 cold brews m-f are no longer a thing :)
Julia R
Cute shop - Nice Selection - Friendly Staff Good place to go before having ppl over (for finger food) or if wanting a quick meal to make/snack for yourself. Very nice drink (alcoholic and non-alcoholic) selection, fancy cheeses, canned fish, vegan dips/spreads, crackers w/ gluten free options + more. The staff is always super sweet and don't mind having conversation. I visit frequently to get Faroe island lax (salmon), Northman Cider, gluten free crackers & love the tomato/basil vegan dip! It's open till 9pm some days, which is also a perk for people who work later shifts. They have a cafe w/ very good coffee -sadly I can't drink too much coffee but tried a sip and it's fantastic(smells amazing)!
Side note: you can also order an Irish version of the same coffee, 2 doors down Rockwell Street, at The Green Post restaurant, if wanting to relax 😉
Barbara Nelsen
Loved this place since they opened (great coffee, thoughtfully curated snacks + booze), but was compelled to leave a review after trying one of their new breakfast sandwiches. Highly recommend — the English muffin was elite and I was genuinely sad when I ate the last bite. Considering my other favorite breakfast sandwich in the neighborhood is from Green Post, I shouldn’t be surprised.
Lisa Chandler
Piccadilly Market has been open about 6 months now and has a lot of going for it. Enjoyable coffee menu and breakfast items. The lunch/ dinner sandwich menu is really creative and has a really great vegan sandwich included.
Over the past 6 months, I've seen them continue to revise the space (changed register set up, food case, etc) and been hopeful they might improve the accessibility issues at some point but continue to fail in that regard. When Green Post ended their daytime passport program, PM was intended to takeover but they have only installed high tops with stools. To have no other seating is really a big middle finger to customers with limited mobility and tells me disability accomodation was not ever a consideration for ownership for this space. The doorway entry is also difficult to manage (heavy/sticking doors and limited space to maneuver). I hope they make adjustments to this space to be more welcoming to all people as the cafe business grows.
I visited and had a mixed experience. As another recent reviewer mentioned, one of the two baristas was extremely rude working. The straight-haired woman running the cashier was very nice and friendly. However, the other barista (with curly hair) who was making drinks and heating food was extremely rude and even became condescending after confusion with a drink order.
Keaton Krueger
These folks just pulled up out of nowhere and made the best sandwiches on this side of town. The bread is amazing and the ingredients are very high quality. Go order the Hero Italian sandwich, buy yourself a nice bottle of wine or sparkling water if you’re feeling fancy, and enjoy. Easy 5/5.
Mariam Ethezaz
The food here is super high quality. Definitely recommend this place!
Joe K
Excellent market great selection and cool spot
Lauren Baltas
Cute place with a nice selection of specialty/luxury grocery goods. Our household is a big fan of the Green Post, so were disappointed to hear that they are limiting the Green Post day-time cafe hours for the Market opening. The Market is very limited in seating and limited with outlets, so it's not a great work space. They also do not offer much in the way of gluten-free or vegan items, which is usually a nice bonus at specialty stores. But is it good for grab & go coffee and for fresh flowers!
Best tuna sandwich I've had in a long time from the deli!
Coffee, food, and market are great. Don’t order food if you’re in a rush though. I had to wait over 30 min for what’s essentially half a grill cheese.
I ordered a simple iced coffee with light ice. I brought it to the attention of a worker that I felt like there was too much ice in it. She, then, gave me a hard time and made a comment to her coworker about my request.
As I'm leaving, and within earshot, she continued to talk about how she felt like she put enough ice in and that I was wrong...
I have worked as a barista and professional bean roaster for over a total of over 6 years. Not once have I treated someone that way. The iced coffee was already very watery, no doubt since they did the ratio wrong while brewing it (which i politely did not mention while in the shop) and then I get two bouts of hard time for it.
What a lack of basic customer service.
I thought this would be a cool place in the neighborhood, but I was wrong.
Yes, definitely a must go and get there. They have plenty of vegan options and nice decor.
The best tomato soup I’ve ever had! Great corner shop.
Hot take for 2026:
PROVIDE MORE THAN FOUR CINNAMON BUNS EVERY MORNING 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄!
$2 cold brews m-f are no longer a thing :)
Cute shop - Nice Selection - Friendly Staff
Good place to go before having ppl over (for finger food) or if wanting a quick meal to make/snack for yourself. Very nice drink (alcoholic and non-alcoholic) selection, fancy cheeses, canned fish, vegan dips/spreads, crackers w/ gluten free options + more.
The staff is always super sweet and don't mind having conversation.
I visit frequently to get Faroe island lax (salmon), Northman Cider, gluten free crackers & love the tomato/basil vegan dip!
It's open till 9pm some days, which is also a perk for people who work later shifts.
They have a cafe w/ very good coffee -sadly I can't drink too much coffee but tried a sip and it's fantastic(smells amazing)!
Side note: you can also order an Irish version of the same coffee, 2 doors down Rockwell Street, at The Green Post restaurant, if wanting to relax 😉
Loved this place since they opened (great coffee, thoughtfully curated snacks + booze), but was compelled to leave a review after trying one of their new breakfast sandwiches. Highly recommend — the English muffin was elite and I was genuinely sad when I ate the last bite. Considering my other favorite breakfast sandwich in the neighborhood is from Green Post, I shouldn’t be surprised.
Piccadilly Market has been open about 6 months now and has a lot of going for it. Enjoyable coffee menu and breakfast items. The lunch/ dinner sandwich menu is really creative and has a really great vegan sandwich included.
Over the past 6 months, I've seen them continue to revise the space (changed register set up, food case, etc) and been hopeful they might improve the accessibility issues at some point but continue to fail in that regard. When Green Post ended their daytime passport program, PM was intended to takeover but they have only installed high tops with stools. To have no other seating is really a big middle finger to customers with limited mobility and tells me disability accomodation was not ever a consideration for ownership for this space. The doorway entry is also difficult to manage (heavy/sticking doors and limited space to maneuver). I hope they make adjustments to this space to be more welcoming to all people as the cafe business grows.
A+ for food, D- for accessibility
Restaurantji Recommends
I visited and had a mixed experience. As another recent reviewer mentioned, one of the two baristas was extremely rude working. The straight-haired woman running the cashier was very nice and friendly. However, the other barista (with curly hair) who was making drinks and heating food was extremely rude and even became condescending after confusion with a drink order.
These folks just pulled up out of nowhere and made the best sandwiches on this side of town. The bread is amazing and the ingredients are very high quality. Go order the Hero Italian sandwich, buy yourself a nice bottle of wine or sparkling water if you’re feeling fancy, and enjoy. Easy 5/5.
The food here is super high quality. Definitely recommend this place!
Excellent market great selection and cool spot
Cute place with a nice selection of specialty/luxury grocery goods. Our household is a big fan of the Green Post, so were disappointed to hear that they are limiting the Green Post day-time cafe hours for the Market opening. The Market is very limited in seating and limited with outlets, so it's not a great work space. They also do not offer much in the way of gluten-free or vegan items, which is usually a nice bonus at specialty stores. But is it good for grab & go coffee and for fresh flowers!
Loading...