Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
1111 W Chicago Ave, Chicago
(312) 243-3735
Customers' Favorites
Classic Thin Crust Pizza
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Fries
Pepperoni Slice Combo
Louisiana Hot Sauce
Italian Beef Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Fries
August Pizza of the Month - Appetite For Destruction
14" (Small) August Pizza of the Month - Appetite For Destruction
Whipped Ricotta, Peppadew Peppers, Italian Sausage, Garlic
16" (Medium) August Pizza of the Month - Appetite For Destruction
Whipped Ricotta, Peppadew Peppers, Italian Sausage, Garlic
18" (Large) August Pizza of the Month - Appetite For Destruction
Whipped Ricotta, Peppadew Peppers, Italian Sausage, Garlic
10" Thin Crust Gluten Free - August Pizza of the Month - Appetite For Destruction
Cauliflower Crust, Whipped Ricotta, Peppadew Peppers, Italian Sausage, Garlic
Thin Crust Pizza
18" Thin Crust (Large)
14" Thin Crust (Small)
16" Thin Crust (Medium)
Gourmet Pizzas
Monster Pie*
Hot Sopressata, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Red Bell Peppers, Extra sauce
Summertime Chi Pie*
Sausage, Pepperoni, Tomato, Basil, Ricotta
Caprese Pizza*
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Tomatoes, Fresh Cracked Pepper, Sea Salt, Extra-Virgin Olive Oil
The Italian Beef Pizza*
The best parts of our Italian beef sandwich combined to create a spicy, delicious pizza.
BBQ Chicken Pizza*
Oven roasted BBQ chicken, white onion, fresh cilantro, BBQ sauce
Garden Pie*
Broccoli, Garlic, Mushrooms, Spinach, Tomatoes
Buffalo Chicken Pizza*
Oven roasted Buffalo chicken, white onion, Buffalo sauce, blue cheese drizzle
The Juice*
Fresh Mozzarella, Hot Sopressata, Meatballs, Garlic
Deep Dish Pizza (requires 45 min pickup time)
14" Deep Dish (Large) requires 45 min pickup time
10" Deep Dish (Small) requires 45 min pickup time
12" Deep Dish (Medium) requires 45 min pickup time
Stuffed Pizza (requires 45 min pickup time)
14" Stuffed (Large) requires 45 min pickup time
12" Stuffed (Medium) requires 45 min pickup time
10" Stuffed (Small) requires 45 min pickup time
Vegan Pizza
10" Vegan Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
10" GF Pizza
Calzones
Calzone
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Oven roasted chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella, Gorgonzola, scallions
BBQ Chicken Calzone
Oven roasted chicken, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onion, fresh cilantro,
Heart-Shaped Pizza
Heart Pizza
Vegan Heart-Shaped Pizza
Vegan Heart-Shaped Pizza
Slices
Pepperoni Slice
Sausage Slice
Cheese Slice
Today's Veggie Slice
Appetizers
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Seasoned Fries
Pizza Bread
Cheese Fries
Seasoned Cheese Fries
Garlic Bread
White Cheddar Cheese Curds
Spinach & Ricotta Arancini (2pcs)
Ricotta Bites
Salads
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken breast with Romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, Parmesan, Caesar dressing
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, Parmesan, Caesar dressing
Garden Salad
Field greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, carrot shreds
Sandwiches
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Parmesan
Italian Beef
Meatball Sandwich
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Beef Meatball Combo
BBQ Beef
Italian Beef in Marinara
Chicken Breast Sandwich
BBQ Chicken
Butterfly Fried Shrimp
Plain Shrimp (10)
Buffalo Shrimp (10)
Plain Shrimp (5)
Buffalo Shrimp (20)
Sweet & Spicy Shrimp (20)
Buffalo Shrimp (5)
Plain Shrimp (20)
Sweet & Spicy Shrimp (10)
Sweet & Spicy Shrimp (5)
Wings
Boneless Wings (8)
Jumbo Whole Wings (6)
Fresh whole wings consisting of a wingette and a drumette. Baked & flash fried
Jumbo Whole Wings (3)
Fresh whole wings consisting of a wingette and a drumette. Baked & flash fried
Boneless Wings (16)
Chicken Strips
Classic Chicken Strips
Tossed Chicken Strips
Desserts
Eli's Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Eli's creamy cheesecake bursting with bittersweet chocolate chips, baked on an all-butter chocolate cookie crust.
Eli's Original Cheesecake
Combination of slow-cultured cream cheese, sour cream, sugar, Madagascar vanilla beans and whole eggs. All baked on a crisp all-butter shortbread cookie crust.
Carrot Cake
Chocolate Fudge Cake
Rice Crispy Treat
Sides & Extra Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Parmesan
Buffalo Sauce
Red Pepper Flakes
Cocktail
Bleu Cheese
Hot Giardiniera
Sweet Peppers
Cheddar Cheese Sauce
Ketchup
Mango Habanero
Louisiana Hot Sauce
Caesar
Pizza Sauce
BBQ Sauce
Jalapeños
Honey Mustard
Balsamic Vinaigrette
Mayo
Soda
Coke Can
Diet Coke Can
Jones Cream Soda
Jones Strawberry Lime
Jones Root Beer
Sprite Can
Jones Berry Lemonade
Jones Green Apple
Dr. Brown's Black Cherry Soda
Just Ice Tea
Half Tea Half Lemonade
Powerade
Fruit Punch Powerade
Water
Water Bottle
Klarbrunn Sparkling Raspberry Water
Juices
Calypso Southern Peach Lemonade
Red Bull
Regular Red Bull
Sugar Free Red Bull
Red Bull Watermelon (Red Edition)
Red Bull Tropical (Yellow Edition)
Red Bull Strawberry Apricot (Amber Edition)
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Absolutely fantastic! The pizza here is top-notch, hands down some of the best I’ve ever had. The prices are fair, especially considering the quality of the ingredients. The service is also exceptional – the staff is friendly and always goes above and beyond to ensure you have a great experience. MONSTER PIE is the king of the menu. Highly recommend!
September 2024
The pizza is thin but it’s delicious the restaurant is cool it gives off a gothic like chill vibe to me at night. The guy who wears the hat and has glasses picks and chooses who he wants to be nice to but whatever overall I’d come back can’t beat $6 pizza
September 2024
Perfect casual pizza joint. As close to an authentic New York slice shop as you’ll get in Chicago - and right off the Blue Line.
Even if you don’t like pizza, you should stop by at least once and check this place out.
Even if you don’t like pizza, you should stop by at least once and check this place out.
September 2024
You May Also Like
Big Shoulders Coffee - 1105 W Chicago Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee Roasteries, Coffee
D'Agostino's Pizza and Pub Ogden - 752 N Ogden Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Pubs, Gluten-Free
Dunkin' - 801 N Milwaukee Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee