The Graystone Tavern

3441 N Sheffield Ave, Chicago
(773) 666-5450

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anthony DiStefano

We happened to park almost right in front of this establishment to catch Cubbie game. My son and I had the Mac and Cheese with chicken wings. Both were really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dustin Marciniak

This place was super chill, not far from Wrigley. Went to get some beers and apps before the game. The service was fast and friendly, the Old Style was cold and cheap. Will most likely go here again before a game to get drinks and snacks. We also got the buffalo chicken tacos, they were really good too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keb Estrella

Stopped by Graystone Tavern on a Saturday afternoon. The vibe is chill, and the staff is friendly. Ordered the fried chicken tacos and a double smash burger. The tacos were crispy and flavorful, but the burger was a bit overcooked for my liking. Fries were decent. Nice beer selection, but the juke box could use more variety. Overall, a good place to hang out, just hope for a more consistent meal next time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Katie Hartman

Looking for the best bar in the world? Look no further—Graystone is it. The owners are kind, genuine people who run a business worth supporting. The service is quick and the bartenders are friendly. On top of that, they are a Vikings, Chelsea, a UW huskies, and a Hanukkah bar. Whether it’s before or after your next Cubs game, stop by and support local at Graystone. You won’t regret it. Go dawgs 🐶 💜

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Altman

Lovely neighborhood bar with nice beer selection and soccer!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

kevin rego

Great little bar near ballpark... they were friendly to us out-of-towners heading to a Cubs game!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M A

Stopped in for a drink before a show at the Newport Theater, great service and a very nice tavern filled with friendly people

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Chapman

Morgan, Claire, Will, John, Ryan, Reagan, Jake and Bella, I love the bartending staff here. Incredibly friendly and great at their job. I moved to Chicago last year and this has become a mainstay for me.

Manny the cook always puts out killer food, I really recommend the Graystone Double Smash and the Pizza Puffs.

No matter when it’s busy or slow they put in the work here with constant events.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teresa Myers

The Graystone Tavern offers a great atmosphere, tasty food, and friendly staff, making it a solid choice for a fun night out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rulookinatme2

Visited Greystone with friends on Fat Tuesday. Chill space, Im sure it packs out quickly, especially during Cubs season. Will was great, and Shy(Chi) cooked everything to perfection. For food at a bar, the wings and Baja 🌮 tacos were freaking 😋 delicious 🔥 - they toasted the flour tortilla🔥.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Taco 2, Fries, Curly

Jason Singer

Friendly service and good vibes. Excellent music choices by the DJ and a nice drink selection.
Fried chicken tacos hit the spot. Spicy chicken with mac n cheese 🤗 yes please.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stefan

Came here with a group of people to watch the superbowl. We had reservations and was sat in the back bar area . Arrived a hour or so before the game and there was no bartender, servers or tv's on in our area. It gets worse, the heat wasn't on and I was told it was broken. It was 58° Everyone had jackets on like we were tailgating. Wristbands were pre purchased. Some of our party left due to the cold . Nobody was offered a refund . Those of us who stayed tried to enjoy eating and drinking in the cold conditions. When our waitress arrived she was awesome & the bartenders up front were too.

Food: 2

Service: 2

Abbie L

Went for The Bachelor showing and it was horrible. Have tried to give this place a chance multiple weeks but it’s gotten bad the past few times. Last time there was a group of the bartenders friends who jeered and screamed the second half of the show as they got more drunk. It made viewing the show extremely uncomfortable. In the end they were harassing one of the women there with her friends to date one of them.

To top it off, the food is horrible. I keep trying different options and the food continues to disappoint. Would not recommend the chicken tenders (one time was fine but last time was crazy dry - like cardboard - and when I told the server he offered me more and I obviously said no), the nachos, the burger, and the egg/spring rolls.

On the other hand, I’ve had some fun nights there despite the bad food. The female bartender in the back room is great. They have run a trivia night that looked fun but I’ve never attended. The only good food I’ve had is the pretzel bites, curly fries, and Mac n cheese.

All in all I will not be returning to this bar and will recommend my friends to avoid it as well.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Steven Rausch

Friendliness from patrons & staff alike: a great place South of Wrigley to have a few beers. Pool table I cannot give a worthwhile review for -- it's been too long since I've played on it.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Bea Kale

Bachelor night was full of the bartenders old male friends jeering at the contestants, screaming at the tv, and making uncomfortable comments to the females there trying to enjoy the show. Food is incredibly bad. I’ve had chicken tenders so dry they were like cardboard. The burger, nachos, and egg/spring rolls are really bad as well.

Loading...