The Graystone Tavern

3441 N Sheffield Ave, Chicago
(773) 666-5450

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Angel Gonzalez

Great atmosphere, great drinks , good servers. Check it out

Ashley Chmielewski

I stopped in on Christmas Eve while the bar was converted to an 8 Crazy Nights/Hannukah bar. The decor was really fun - blue and white lights, sweaters, tiny hats on bottles, tablecloths, themed cocktails. Some screens still played sports but various holiday movies were on. Metered street parking but it was easy to find a spot on the holiday. Fritz and Buckets were attentive and kept the vibe fun. Great draft beer selection. This tavern is normally a Viking bar, which is when I normally visit. There's a main seating area and bar, and a second seating area down the hallway where the restrooms are. I'll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Dustin Herlich

Absolutely love the Hanukkah pop-up bar! The service here is very friendly, the drinks are great, and the food is pretty good too. Really love that they do this. It's a nice little place, with a really great back room. Clearly a lot of locals, but very welcoming to anyone. The boozy hot chocolate I had was top notch. The boozy Hanukkah jelly donuts (sufganiyot) were delicious and thankfully dairy free!!! Great place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G S

Cool atmosphere and nice bartenders. Visited from out of town but felt like a dive to call home. Decent drinks and space

Robert Orenstein

Hanukkah decorations will blow your mind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Googler Mapser

Very popular. A fun experience for those checking out the holiday pop-ups. Prices are comparable to others in the area, but I have never had a smaller shot in my life. Good conversations with everyone that was there, though.

Food: 3

Tristram Bisgrove

Went to experience Hanukkah bar. Happened to be during Minnesota Vikings game (they’re a borussia Dortmund/Chelsea/vikings bar). That was an interesting experience. Not bad, just unexpected. People had fun. Seasonal drinks were great too! Had Mensch Mule. Perfect. Food, however, was trash. Never ordered a brisket sandwich and experienced being served a pot roast sandwich before. Bun was crispy and perfectly done. But I ordered brisket, not potatoes and carrots with a few strands of beef in it. Fries were overdone and latkes were disappointing. If you’re going for drinks and an experience, go. You’ll enjoy. If you’re expecting to eat there too, hard pass. So much promise on the food menu to be let down in person. Should’ve known.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Chuck Mallory

Oy! Incredible find while visiting. Get this: an enclosed, heated patio with TVs where we could bring our dog. Very friendly waiters. Good drinks, good food. It’s aka “8 Crazy Nights” Hanukkah spot and the decor was fab (though it’s not Hanukkah yet). I had the loaded latkes and they were perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shannan Berkbuegler

My favorite time of year! Updated 8 Crazy Nights menu & decor. Great bar year ‘round. Servers are ON it, always— fun, excellent service, and they remember everything. It’s still one of my Go-To places here in Chicago’s Wrigleyville.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

matthew kincaid

Stopped im to watch college football.
From the minute we walked the whole staff was welcoming.

They mentioned Chicago Chelsea club party and offered to turn sound on and TV on for our game in the back room.
More than kind.

Staff awesome!
Chelsea club awesome!
Space out back awesome!

Thanks for being so kind Will! Perfect vibe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Arielle Steward

Loved this bar!!! They were open at 6am for the 6:30 Chelsea game. Staff were so friendly and ready to serve everyone so early in the morning. Screens all over, you didn’t have a bad view anywhere you sat! We also tried the Fish and Chips and those were so good. Can’t wait to go back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Edgar Z

Came in on a game day but after the game. The all female staff of servers blatantly walked past me numerous times, and ignored when I attempted to flag their attention. I saw them going around to other tables, but it was clear they all were intentionally refusing to stop at mine. Very negative experience and one I have not encountered here before.

Service: 1

Jason Roussos

Great service good and beer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roxanne Maiden

Would an absolute great place to enjoy the Cubs game! The food made by Chi was so! The mac & cheese was soulful 🤤 atmosphere, drinks and location are great! Parking thats another story that's not their fault

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Glade

Great pre / post Cubs game spot. The food is always on point and the bartenders are fun.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...