You're a Cookie!

910 Sherwood Dr Ste 21, Lake Bluff
(773) 961-7091

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Josue ortiz

Confusing website and service. Team members didn’t help us and only told us they weren’t open to the public. We walked away after that.

viren patel

Was great!!

Nicole W

This is my family's favorite place to get a sweet treat. I've stopped by to grab one cookie and cocoa, dozens of cookies (either baked or frozen), cookie cakes, and also had cookies shipped to friends in a different state... And I've had nothing but positive experiences each time. I love how many flavors are available and that there are options for my family members with allergies. Angela clearly is passionate about making delicious cookies, and I can't wait to see what other flavors come up next!

Christina Wags

Amazing cookies! Great service! The cookies are wonderful- with options and personal service. Highly recommend!

Andi LP

Today i had…..a rough time. I live in the area and pass by this cookie shop every day. After work, i was compelled to finally stop in for the first time. Upon learning everything is vegan, i literally burst into tears. Listen, vegan items are cool. I’m not even vegan; clearly this burst of emotion had nothing to do with the events that took place at You’re a Cookie. But it was this one tidbit of good news that reminded me I’ve got a lot more to look forward to in life. Gotta say, the angel working today REALLY handled my over sharing and outburst well. Thank you, kind stranger. I’m eating the cookies on my bed right now. Agree with everyone else. That chocolate chip cookie is to live for.

Elizabeth Berkeley

Delicious cookies! Tons of vegan options and amazing ice cream sandwich!

charlie p

This is a great place to pickup dessert after procuring food from Wok! You Want, La Zacatenaca, Jaiyen, or any other area restaurants. We enjoyed their cookies and personalized attention. They offer many seasonal options, too. We will be back soon!

Eric Lee

Nice and tasty and a great gluten free option

Beth K

I was only in town for a few weeks, and I'm kicking myself for not visiting sooner! The GF cookies were absolutely delicious. I brought them to a get-together, and both my husband and friend were shocked when I pointed out they were eating GF cookies. If you're GF, or entertaining both gluten-eating and GF company, this is your best bet for a treat that will please everyone. The storefront is unassuming, but do not hesitate to pop in! The woman who assisted me was very friendly. I'm hoping to make it back in at least once more before I leave town to try a cookie sandwich.

Nika Lofton

the gluten free chocolate chip is unreal, i think about this cookie frequently. wish there was a sit down store!

Yessica Alzati

Las galletas son deliciosas!! The cookies are delicious! I had the smore cookie and it is so good!! You can taste the cinnamon, marshmallow and the chocolate in one bite! First time visiting and I had an amazing experience. Definitely will be back.

Rachel Yant Cato

Excellent cookies and even better customer service. Thank you!!

Christina Wagener

Amazing cookies! Great service! The cookies are wonderful- with options and personal service. Highly recommend!

Jennifer Marnul

I’m obsessed with these cookies. 10/10 would recommend trying them!

Edward Antanitus

Great cookies. It’s nice to have this shop in our area.

Loading...