Soul & Smoke Evanston

1601 Payne St, Evanston
(847) 859-2732

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amber Binderup

Awesome hidden gem ! We were visiting Evanston and were very hungry for some bbq, this place didn’t disappoint . I had the brisket sandwich and Mac n cheese. Brisket was tender and Smokey , absolutely loved it. Mac n cheese was creamy and cheesy in all the right ways! My husband had their jalapeno sausage dog and he loved it as well. Service was great , no problems at all.

winston Feng

The best bbq in the north shore

Eric Collins

You know the bbq good when you don’t need sauce.

Hayley Beck

Delicious every time and I love that they are active in the community.

Rion Lawson

This place is horrible a warehouse made into a restaurant. Pricey food very small amounts you will leave pissed and still hungry after spending $100 Never go here

Ed Brill

Brisket combo was delicious. Gold sauce. Really happy with the taste and smoke.

Terry Sanders

Phenomenal food, that’s arguably the best in the north shore.

Arturo

Great food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wayne Bennett

The soup and 1 salad is very good. The brisket sandwich so so. A little too heavy on the smoke in smoked. Corn bread muffin is the best I've had.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cornbread Muffin, Apple Slaw

Pavlo Chechel

Rarely leaving reviews. However, once a month I want to get some good food, for the dinner, and chose this place this week. And well this is very bad, I got the sandwich and ribs. Sandwich was dry, the vegetables are not fresh, and in general it was not good. The ribs are just dry, they are not flavory enough to ignore the dryness of the meat. I are half of my order and just threw away leftovers. There are around 5 other places in the same area that have 10 times better food. I got delivery so rating only food quality, not aware of service or atmosphere. Summing up, if you are a meat lover avoid this place, I am not giving it second chance.

Joel Chaitman

Great carry out. Ribs, pulled pork and Mac and cheese were great

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Mac and Cheese

Linda Goad

Gosh I’m so disappointed. I really want to support this place but the prices are darn near prohibitive. 17 dollars for a bowl of gumbo. 8 dollars for a baked sweet potato half the size of any sweet potato I’ve ever seen. I’ve been ordering from them for about a year but on several occasions I’ve felt that the food although very good did not justify the bill. Thanksgiving dinner was organized and very good but the cranberry sauce was some sort of soup and I had to throw it out. I couldn’t afford the way overpriced desserts. Tonight I got a bowl of gumbo, a sweet potato and corn muffin. $30. Sorry guys I so appreciate your community support and that you’re in my neighborhood but that’s a lot of money

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Lauren Penson

I was very disappointed by my recent visit. $26 for a small sandwich, small mashed potatoes, and San Pellegrino soda. First, the mashed potatoes tasted old, and did not have a fresh taste. It was explained to me that this is how they are made in the South. I don't think so. The sandwich was surprisingly small, and I had hoped to have slices of brisket rather than a mishmash of tiny brisket leftover pieces with sauce. The meat itself tasted good, but there was too much sauce in the mix. If they aim to open a full-scale restaurant, they will need to improve. I will not be back. Although the personnel was very nice, they couldn't make up for the average food quality.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

L B

It’s pricey. I ordered chicken gumbo with added shrimp. See pic for size For this small bowl I was charged $22 dollars. Not sure if that is a fair price point for the quantity of food. I also ordered the black eyed peas. I was charged $6.00 for this small cup of beans. I’m sorry. This robbery to be charged these prices and the portions are extremely small. Don’t support this place. You’ll leave not full and will pay expensive prices for small portions. The problem with this place is portion sizes and prices. It’s better to just drive into the city to get more bang for your buck.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

WILL SMITH

We decided to stop by and try out Soul & Smoke based on a referral, but I’ve got to say the best part of this experience was the service. The price was outrageous for the portion you receive,Not to the food was lacking in the flavor department. I guess I’ll stick to ole faithful the BBQ spot in Evanston, But unfortunately they’re not open on Monday.

Parking: Very congested area and difficult to find parking.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brisket Sandwich, Potato Salad, Sweet Potatoes, Mac and Cheese, Rid Tips

Loading...