The Caterist

944 Pitner Ave, Evanston
(847) 676-2433

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sydney Strick

I loved working with The Caterist! Erin not only coordinated our wedding dinner, but helped us with other wedding coordinating in general since we did not hire an official wedding planner. She made everything flow so easily! The day of crew was amazing, so sweet, and attentive. The food was delicious and we received tons of compliments on how yummy everything was!

Brandan Satisfield

If you have any doubts about booking The Caterist, let me put your worries to rest. Erin & her team were the most professional and attentive service I’ve ever hired for an event. We hired them for our wedding. So many people were blown away by their staff and the timeliness of the service. They stuck to our evening timeline without rushing guests. We had not a single incident the entire evening. Plus the food was excellent the beef was tender as butter. The chicken was highly complimented. We’d highly recommend using the caterist and to top it off they are so affordable!

Kristen Nelson

The Caterist provided exceptional service for our fundraising event at the Evanston History Center. We received positive reviews on the food tasting wonderful. As an event organizer, I also appreciated how easy it was to work with their team during planning and on the event day. Their staff was friendly and all smiles which makes such a difference for guests.

Christopher Goc

People raved about the food and the service was excellent! They took care of everything day-of so we could enjoy our day. They were able to take special requests and accommodate a diverse menu, including kids meals and late night bites. I know I was the guest of honor at my own wedding, but they really did their best to make sure I felt pampered. They even gave us some great options for rentals for the ceremony furniture. If your venue lists The Caterist as a preferred caterer, make sure you book a tasting and try it for yourself! You won’t be disappointed.

Albert Chen

We worked with the Caterist for our summer 2023 wedding and were extremely satisfied with their service and food. They were very responsive and transparent with pricing from the beginning. We paid our deposit before the tasting so we didn't expect much from it, but we were blown away by how well put together the whole event was. Our venue presented a few challenges (no fridges provided, minimal kitchen appliances, chairs and tables stored on another floor) and the Caterist team overcame them all like it was nothing. Many of our guests told us it was the best wedding meal they've had. Our wedding would not have gone so smoothly if we had not worked with the Caterist and highly recommend them for any weddings.

Natalia Gardocki

My husband and I chose The Caterist as the caterer for our wedding reception and we couldn't be more pleased. From the very beginning with our tasting, Erin from their team was incredibly responsive to our questions and concerns and so easy to work with. On the day of the wedding, the servers and bartenders were all friendly and helpful. Now the important part: the food was amazing. So many guests at our wedding came up to us raving about the food. Entrees were well seasoned and the portions were generous, and the desserts on our dessert table were also very tasty, with a lot of variety. Overall, would definitely recommend working with the Caterist for your wedding!

Christine Chen

We worked with the Caterist for our reception and they did an incredible job! We truly have no complaints about their service - the food was incredible (biggest compliment we received from all of our guests) and their staff was so professional. Ana, who we worked with most closely, was so pleasant, patient, and so kind to work with from the very start of our working relationship. The tasting was done so well & made us feel so welcome. Would highly recommend the Caterist from here on out!!

Tammy Barb

Itemp work with these people there's a father and son the father is Brian excellent people to work with I really enjoyed myself very clean environment sanitize they really take care of their guests when they come and have events at different locations it's just really a great place to work an if they are having a event they'll take care of you to their best abilities.

Melodie Foley

I have been a wedding industry professional for over six years working in venue management and planning/coordination - I had the absolute pleasure of working with Ana and The Caterist for the first time at a wedding out in Richmond, IL. Those of us in the industry know that wedding days and the weeks/months leading up are truly a team sport. Getting to collaborate with someone as professional, organized and thoughtful as Ana was a true highlight in my season.My couple had a family style dinner that guests were RAVING about throughout the night(especially the truffle mashed potatoes). Our vendor meal was similar to what the guests ate and I can confirm that the food was AMAZING, my vegetarian associate also agreed that it was one of the best veggie meals she was served this season. Servers were polite, professional, punctual, and swift.Ana was super communicative leading up to the event and I always felt like my notes and my clients needs were carefully documented and executed upon. We were able to problem-solve together and work as a well-oiled team. If you want exceptional service, leadership and food I would not hesitate to book Ana and The Caterist for your big day :)

Alicia Wright

They were great! Fantastic from start to finish for our 2023 wedding. They were relatively in budget, the food and service was great, the staff and Erin (the event producer) was so on top of everything we needed. 10/10, no notes!

Josephine Phillips

The caterist were super professional!

Olivia Kohler

We are blown away by the service and level of dedication that the team at The Caterist gave to our wedding. The guests wouldn't stop talking about the food. It was beyond! They even accommodated our gluten sensitive guests by making the majority of the menu GF! I felt truly special when they had a server bringing us the passed apps and cocktails during our cocktail hour! Then that service continued throughout the night. We were not expecting that.Working with the Ana to make adjustments to our rental orders and floor plan was a breeze and made the process stress-free!Thank you again for making our day so special!

Elsie Fernandez

Used The Caterist for my daughter's Quinceanera and I was blown away at the level of service I received. I can't say enough about how great it was working with them, the coordination, the follow-up and most importantly the food. I received rave reviews on the "vegetarian lasagna" by almost everyone at the event. The servers were attentive and made sure every detail was taken care off. I didn't have to worry about anything...I was able to focus my attention to the guests and enjoy the event. I am so happy I used them and will definitely use them for my other daughter's quinceanera next year.

Jacklyn Cummings

The caterist were super professional! They handled every detail of our wedding with ease. We could tell from the moment we went to our first tasting that they were detail oriented and they didn’t disappoint. Our guests raved about the food and the service! We would book them again in a heartbeat!

Jacklyn Humphrey

The caterist were super professional! The handled every detail of our wedding with ease. We could tell from the moment we went to our first tasting that they were detail oriented and they didn’t disappoint. Our guests raved about the food and the service! We would book them again in a heartbeat!

Loading...