Whiskey Thief Tavern

616 Davis St, Evanston
(847) 859-2342

Recent Reviews

Kevin s

Very cool place to get dinner and drinks or just drinks! Places like this are what give Evanston such a good reputation.

Daniel Stoyanov

Excellent ice cream! Banana and coconuts my favorite combination. But they have some crazy flavors like avocado and wine ?! I stopped by frio gelato on the way to the beach and on the way back. ?

Mario Brown

first time and highly recommended

Uri Percy

Extraordinary environment and super personal service. The meals were crisp and enchanting. Will easily recommend this place to my friends. Convenient prices and big meals. Great job.

Julie Burkett-Greenfield

my family and I just discovered their food tonight and the spicy fried chicken sandwich was a 10 out of 10!!

Tatty M.

This place and the staff are soooo amazing that I felt like I was being treated like a princess for a second . The chef made a very very minor mistake but after me telling the waitress about it she literally apologized 100 times and brought the manager to apologize as well and made our experience so great . Can't wait for this pandemic to be over so I can go back .

Aaron Rodriguez

Althought the menu is a bit limited , this place has a cool atmosphere and some very delicious burgers. Good spot for a casual date or for getting drinks with friends.

Felix G.

This is a nice place for having a drink, and if you want, to follow sports events. They have multiple huge TVs in the establishment. Unfortunately they are heavily impacted by the Covid situation. Nice Whiskey menu with some interesting recipes for Old Fashioned drinks. Staff is friendly and accommodating and they know the drinks.

Melissa Hamilton

Amazing atmosphere and friendly staff. Eli always has excellent recommendations!

Adeola Gideon H19

Wonderful attendants. They wanna make sure you are satisfied before you leave.

Christine Hightower

Tried Bob's Pizza today. The Bob's sausage pizza was really great. I really like their sauce and crust.

Salman Ahmad

Not bad. They had a solid whiskey selection. Prices are ok. I didn't have the food.

Jeremy Aufderheide

I've been here a couple of times for drinks and a couple of times for brunch. Tonight, I decided that since they had booths and a kitchen, maybe dinner would be good. I was wrong. Before the review though, the staff has always been great...all of the times and they were all great including the waiter tonight. My complaint tonight though is the food. We both ordered burgers. The french fries were jelly bean-sized nubs served in a metal container that coincidentally looks like a trash can. And the burgers were served on giant greasy buns, burgers dripping grease so much that they saturated the board they were served on. Not planning to go back for dinner again.

Chris Davis

The variety of whiskeys make this play stand out. If any time you're in Evanston you must see this place.

Nick Fruendt

They give you a huge portion of fries

Load More