Heard about this place for literally 2 decades and I'm 31. Old fashion sweet was honestly not great. BBQ shrimp appetizer was epic. I had the duck my lady had the fillet. Either one is amazing. Just a place everyone should experience.
Kris Stanton
I walked in and was told it's mostly reservations but they made room for me. Alice was my waitress and she was terrific. My food was fantastic and I appreciated them make it an acception for me in my first visit. Everyone should try because this is Geneseo's secret. I will return...And make a reservation next time. Haha
Gary Andrews
Ive been there many times. Very good. But last time I was there my Sirloin steak, was the worst I have EVER HAD. I cant even describe the taste. Steak was either partially rotton or the charcoal used gave it a terable taste. Mabey a combination If I experience bad food like that I just never return.
J B
Excellent food, great atmosphere and friendly service!
TheUltimateTestofSanity
Using the elevator was neat
J Winsk
The cooks are hot, literally it's like 400 degrees in the kitchen
Misty Souders
I take my family there every New Years Eve. The Serve is Spectacular. The Food is Perfect. My mother always gets Chicken livers my dad Beef Strips I get Lobster tails and son gets BBQ shrimp. We had an incredible time!!
Katie Franks
Use to be our favorite restaurant. Recently, we went to celebrate a family event and unfortunately the quality of food was horrible. Steaks were raw and sent back twice, baked potatoes overcooked, salad was not as crisp as usual, fried chicken was over cooked and dried, and the salmon raw and flavorless. The service was good and even the waitress new the steaks were raw and sent them back once on her own. Very expensive non ediable meal and super disappointing.
Jeffrey Schriver
Absolutely the best steak anywhere. Great service and fantastic food. Love their cold crisp salads and cheese and crackers. Any food you order off the menu is fantastic
William O'Brien
One of only a few restaurants in the area that is high-class dining, exceptional food..
Good not great. Our first time. Would go back. Drinks are strong. You get a lot for the money.
Michael Mato
Absolutely love this place. Great supper house vibe. Good is on point
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Strip Steak and Baked Potato, Chicken Livers, French Onion Soup, Cheese and Crackers Are All You Can Eat with Dinner, Dinner Salad
super boy69
Definitely a community staple
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Adrienne Johnson
Excellent foods. One of our go tos for a family celebration.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
brent retherford
Had my moms 80'th Birthday Party here tonight. 24 people there. Our waitress did a great job. We definitely kept her busy. My wife and I ordered French onion soup, Filet Mignon cooked to medium perfection. Fried chicken that was also perfectly cooked golden brown, with a delicious salad and baked potato. This was our 5th or 6th time here. Always great food and service. The steak was phenomenal. We will definitely be back.
Heard about this place for literally 2 decades and I'm 31. Old fashion sweet was honestly not great. BBQ shrimp appetizer was epic. I had the duck my lady had the fillet. Either one is amazing. Just a place everyone should experience.
I walked in and was told it's mostly reservations but they made room for me.
Alice was my waitress and she was terrific. My food was fantastic and I appreciated them make it an acception for me in my first visit.
Everyone should try because this is Geneseo's secret.
I will return...And make a reservation next time. Haha
Ive been there many times. Very good. But last time I was there my Sirloin steak, was the worst I have EVER HAD. I cant even describe the taste. Steak was either partially rotton or the charcoal used gave it a terable taste. Mabey a combination If I experience bad food like that I just never return.
Excellent food, great atmosphere and friendly service!
Using the elevator was neat
The cooks are hot, literally it's like 400 degrees in the kitchen
I take my family there every New Years Eve. The Serve is Spectacular. The Food is Perfect. My mother always gets Chicken livers my dad Beef Strips I get Lobster tails and son gets BBQ shrimp. We had an incredible time!!
Use to be our favorite restaurant. Recently, we went to celebrate a family event and unfortunately the quality of food was horrible. Steaks were raw and sent back twice, baked potatoes overcooked, salad was not as crisp as usual, fried chicken was over cooked and dried, and the salmon raw and flavorless. The service was good and even the waitress new the steaks were raw and sent them back once on her own. Very expensive non ediable meal and super disappointing.
Absolutely the best steak anywhere. Great service and fantastic food. Love their cold crisp salads and cheese and crackers. Any food you order off the menu is fantastic
One of only a few restaurants in the area that is high-class dining, exceptional food..
Restaurantji Recommends
Good not great. Our first time. Would go back. Drinks are strong. You get a lot for the money.
Absolutely love this place. Great supper house vibe. Good is on point
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Strip Steak and Baked Potato, Chicken Livers, French Onion Soup, Cheese and Crackers Are All You Can Eat with Dinner, Dinner Salad
Definitely a community staple
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Excellent foods. One of our go tos for a family celebration.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had my moms 80'th Birthday Party here tonight. 24 people there. Our waitress did a great job. We definitely kept her busy. My wife and I ordered French onion soup, Filet Mignon cooked to medium perfection. Fried chicken that was also perfectly cooked golden brown, with a delicious salad and baked potato. This was our 5th or 6th time here. Always great food and service. The steak was phenomenal. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup
Loading...