This is my boyfriend and I’s favorite pizza spot. It is always absolutely delicious and Hailey is always an attentive and kind server!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Messer
No garlic knots @6pm on a Sunday what the heck !!!! :(((
Dj Reese
Picked up a take out order today and male staff member made a racist joke right in my face as if that would insult me. NEVER spending a dime there again.
Lauren Anthony
Hands down the BEST pizza I have ever had. Instant happiness with each bite. The best part is the garlic crust!! If you’re having a bad day go here it’ll make everything better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle H
Great pizza, delicious! Perfect crust, artisanal ingredients, good portion size and cost. Salad was perfect too. Good, attentive service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Lippincott
Our favorite NYC style pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J_
This was our first time here! We were hoping to get a pizza but slices are only available earlier in the day. We ordered a full pie for the two of us and have no regret!! We highly recommend this place! It’s fun, fast, the food is very delicious and well presented. The restaurant is small and lively- but it could accommodate a large group in a long table, which will watch where the pizzas are made! We ordered the funky Cesar, which has a new twist on the dressing. It is a miso. I was hesitant, but it was delicious. It was not too creamy. It was not too fishy. It w was not too salty.- all the things I hate about Caesar salads was avoided with this amazing funky, Cesar! Try for yourself! Haley was our server ! She enthusiastic about the pizzas! We were a little concerned about the hot honey, so she gave us that on the side. We loved our pizza! Their pies offer a good twist on classic recipes.! You can’t get this anywhere else- you need to try it!! Since we were in for a full pizza, we accompanied with a bottle of Chiante, which we could cork and carry Haley was our server. She was super sweet accommodating great recommendations she made us feel comfortable! She was also highly recommended by the table next to us- it was also their first time and they raved about the pizzas. So, if you are rained out of a Cougars game like we were- or just out and about in Geneva- or want to travel for a unique delicious pizza pie- stop in and have a great time!! .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George Fed
Nemec Brothers Pizza in Geneva is outstanding and worth a visit. The garlic knots are perfectly baked and full of flavor, and the pizza is next level. I had one with pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey and it was easily one of the best combos I’ve ever tried. Great spot for amazing pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey Pepperoni Pie, Garlic Twists
Tommy
Called Geneva location several times around 7pm on Sunday 8/17 and no answer. Showed up to see a handwritten note about the Geneva location closing at 6pm, yet they’re posted hours are open until 9pm on Sunday’s… No posts or any other information on their FB or instagram either. Unbelievable. I don’t care how popular you are or how busy, this is a pizza restaurant. How are you able to make up the hours as you go… Not the first person that has experienced this based on some other reviews. You’re in the heart of downtown Geneva and you’ve been open for over a year now. Get it together. This is basic stuff.
After reading so many good reviews, I decided to order Grandma's Pie. I ordered it for takeout, the total with tip was $39), and I was deeply disappointed. I won't say that the pizza was terrible, but it's definitely not the kind of pizza worth paying about $40 for, since there was practically no toppings, the price is significantly overpriced, I don't think it's appropriate to pay that much for the dough.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Andrea Lopez
Came in today for the first time 8/14/2025, and I will continue to come & try all pizzas. I'm in love with their pizza now.
Had the delicious Garlic twist, with the Pepperoni pie!! And the mike's honey ( the honey made a huge difference since I've never had honey on the combination!!!) The pizza was just good fantastically made. By far one of the best pizza I've ever had. Thank you
Everyone reading this go try this pizza. You will be satisfied as me. If I can give 10 stars I will.
Thanks-Andrea
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TK
Great pizza! Might be my new favorite in the Fox Valley. New York style, nice crisp on the bottom, great crust. This place is really good. Hard to find this style around here, but you should try it out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Sanner
Excellent pizza, some of the best in the area. Definitely try the cookie too.
Best traditional style pizza ive ever had
Food: 5
This is my boyfriend and I’s favorite pizza spot. It is always absolutely delicious and Hailey is always an attentive and kind server!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
No garlic knots @6pm on a Sunday what the heck !!!! :(((
Picked up a take out order today and male staff member made a racist joke right in my face as if that would insult me. NEVER spending a dime there again.
Hands down the BEST pizza I have ever had. Instant happiness with each bite. The best part is the garlic crust!! If you’re having a bad day go here it’ll make everything better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, delicious! Perfect crust, artisanal ingredients, good portion size and cost. Salad was perfect too. Good, attentive service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our favorite NYC style pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first time here! We were hoping to get a pizza but slices are only available earlier in the day. We ordered a full pie for the two of us and have no regret!!
We highly recommend this place! It’s fun, fast, the food is very delicious and well presented. The restaurant is small and lively- but it could accommodate a large group in a long table, which will watch where the pizzas are made!
We ordered the funky Cesar, which has a new twist on the dressing. It is a miso. I was hesitant, but it was delicious. It was not too creamy. It was not too fishy. It w was not too salty.- all the things I hate about Caesar salads was avoided with this amazing funky, Cesar! Try for yourself!
Haley was our server ! She enthusiastic about the pizzas! We were a little concerned about the hot honey, so she gave us that on the side. We loved our pizza! Their pies offer a good twist on classic recipes.! You can’t get this anywhere else- you need to try it!!
Since we were in for a full pizza, we accompanied with a bottle of Chiante, which we could cork and carry
Haley was our server. She was super sweet accommodating great recommendations she made us feel comfortable! She was also highly recommended by the table next to us- it was also their first time and they raved about the pizzas.
So, if you are rained out of a Cougars game like we were- or just out and about in Geneva- or want to travel for a unique delicious pizza pie- stop in and have a great time!! .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nemec Brothers Pizza in Geneva is outstanding and worth a visit. The garlic knots are perfectly baked and full of flavor, and the pizza is next level. I had one with pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey and it was easily one of the best combos I’ve ever tried. Great spot for amazing pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Honey Pepperoni Pie, Garlic Twists
Called Geneva location several times around 7pm on Sunday 8/17 and no answer. Showed up to see a handwritten note about the Geneva location closing at 6pm, yet they’re posted hours are open until 9pm on Sunday’s… No posts or any other information on their FB or instagram either. Unbelievable. I don’t care how popular you are or how busy, this is a pizza restaurant. How are you able to make up the hours as you go… Not the first person that has experienced this based on some other reviews. You’re in the heart of downtown Geneva and you’ve been open for over a year now. Get it together. This is basic stuff.
Restaurantji Recommends
After reading so many good reviews, I decided to order Grandma's Pie. I ordered it for takeout, the total with tip was $39), and I was deeply disappointed. I won't say that the pizza was terrible, but it's definitely not the kind of pizza worth paying about $40 for, since there was practically no toppings, the price is significantly overpriced, I don't think it's appropriate to pay that much for the dough.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Came in today for the first time 8/14/2025, and I will continue to come & try all pizzas. I'm in love with their pizza now.
Had the delicious Garlic twist, with the Pepperoni pie!! And the mike's honey ( the honey made a huge difference since I've never had honey on the combination!!!) The pizza was just good fantastically made. By far one of the best pizza I've ever had. Thank you
Everyone reading this go try this pizza. You will be satisfied as me. If I can give 10 stars I will.
Thanks-Andrea
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza! Might be my new favorite in the Fox Valley. New York style, nice crisp on the bottom, great crust. This place is really good. Hard to find this style around here, but you should try it out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza, some of the best in the area. Definitely try the cookie too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every bite - so good so good 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...