Had a really nice lunch with friends. Everyone was happy with their food! Reuben chicken strips and pot roast sandwich and of course the fries! Lucus was a great waiter!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders
Craig Flanick
Visited some family in the area and stopped in. Mediocre food, mediocre service and mediocre experience in general.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ed Tobias
My wife and I were hungry and thirsty. We just finished watching a Boys basketball game at Geneva HS. They won that night. We asked one of the teachers there if she could recommend a restaurant nearby. She just started going on and on about OTP, the food, the atmosphere, the beer on tap and the MUST try onion rings. This place rocks but I'm getting ahead of myself. She gave us excellent directions. We walk in, it's a slow night. We ordered a beer and mixed drink; my Stella was tasty and fresh. My wife enjoyed her mixed drink. It had an excellent ratio Tito's to Cranberry. It wasn't a heavy headed pour, it’s just right. When she finished it, she ordered another, it was outstanding, according to her. We ordered our dinner; the wings were for me and OTP burger for my wife with a side order of onion rings. My wife loved the burger. It was cooked as asked, juicy, -as my wife told me while she was eating the burger its "flavorful with a smorgasbord of tastes and crunchiness WoW". My chicken wings were to DIE for: they were fresh, tasty, moist, and not dry or over fried. They were able to mix and match the seasonings; the spicy BBQ, the Hot and plain BBQ were excellent. The onion rings were to DIE for; they were better than our teacher recommended to us……They were fresh, tasty with just the right amount delicious beer battered crumbs. They were YUMMY! The restaurant/bar feels like a "Cheers Bar". This is our go-to place the next time we are in the area. This place is EXCELLENT!
Parking: Easy parking on Main street
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly meals
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Griffin May
Nice restaurant with a great variety of American food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaeleen Kaufmann
Met cousin in Geneva for a girls weekend. Great location. We had chicken salad sandwiches 1 one croissant and 1 on pretzel roll. So yummy!!!! And we shared the donut ice-cream dessert. Heaven!Server was so sweet, funny and nice!!!As a person who is allergic to scents and for a person working in a restaurant maybe less perfume. But so sweet!!!!!Great town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sunny days
I met up with some friends yesterday to eat here! The vibe is nice and everything seemed great! After watching quite a few people who sat after us get their food before us we checked and were told it would be a couple minute. No problem! I’m not in a rush so no biggie. Then the waitress said that the ticket didn’t get sent in so it would be a bit longer. Still no biggie, life happens!When the food finally comes out, I had asked for no cheese on the burger. I point it out and ask quickly still trying to be as polite as possible cause I know of the mix up earlier. The waitress decided instead to gaslight me and tell me that I asked for no cheddar cheese and that the southwest burger has 2 cheeses on it. Well the cheese was definitely cheddar to start off with but then to still try and gaslight me when I have the menu showing that she’s oddly lying to me about cheese. I bite my tongue and she takes my food back. Not even minutes later I get it back. I go to take a bite of my burger and sure enough I see the yellow cheese around the edges of the burger. At this point the cheese has clearly been scraped off by staff. At this point the nice bone in my body ran very cold and I made a call to try and figure out if I was being irrational. I decided that we would just not leave a tip but also not cause a scene at the restaurant as I’m not allergic to milk. As this is being decided by my table group the staff is clearly anxious and talking to eachother repeatedly looking at my table. The waitress comes up and asks about our food. I decided it wouldn’t hurt to mention it lightly. I explained the hazard of people who may be allergic to milk and how I was disappointed. She then continued to gaslight me and tell me the yellow cheese I was seeing was grease. ?(which if that is really their grease then people dining here should be concerned about the cleanliness cause grease from burgers is not yellow and doesn’t solidify like that?) but as she said that with no asking or arguments she said she’d take a discount off of my meal. So in her gaslighting she admitted guilt. She also offered to make me a new one but I honestly didn’t want my food spit in if I sent it back a third time so I refused.ALL AND ALL IF YOURE ALLERGIC TO ANYTHING THIS ESTABLISHMENT DOESNT TAKE ALLERGIES SERIOUSLY AND WILL TOTALLY GASLIGHT YOU ABOUT IT. (If the establishment would also like to gaslight me again on here I have pictures.)
Herman Beneke
We had a private party. Everything was great. Food, service, drinks, atmosphere, etc. We will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
June DeMario
Great burgers, onion strings, sweet and sweet potato fries. Fabulous service and definitely will go again.
Nice little hang out. Great mozzarella sticks. Great ambiance. Great drink selection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Riley DeMoss
DO NOT GO HERE. I made a reservation for a wedding rehearsal dinner and they were extremely understaffed. We paid for a personal bar tender and there was no one at the bar half the time. On top of this the food was extremely late to be served (almost 1.5 hours). I understand things happen but the worst part is the disrespect the staff showed us. When we asked, politely, when the food would be served for the second time, keep in mind this is over an hour after when it was supposed to be served, one of their employees got in my face and started threatening me. The employee that did this was bald and wearing a chicago hat. He was disposable to say the least. He lied to us and treated us horribly for simply asking when the food we paid over a thousand dollars would be ready. This employee not only threatened us but was also starting at my nine year old cousin and trying to talk to her the whole time. Please do not go there and to the ownership - please hold higher standards for who you hire. This man was a disgust and as long as he works there I will make it my mission to spread the word to all of Geneva to never eat or drink there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tristan Diekman
Old Towne Pub is a great place for burgers, sandwiches, and other pub fare. Set in a rustic, homey vibe, with a lot of TVs to catch up on sports, service I'd good and brings out food in a timely manner. All the dishes my party had left good impressions. If you're wanting to eat some good food and watch some sports, this is the perfect spot to go to!
laura bertolini
We had a one year old celebration birthday party and had the entire space upstairs which included a game room and two bathrooms and full service bar. The appetizers and chicken/beef fajitas were all very good. We were advised on how much to order for our group and it was just enough. We were allowed to come in an hour before the party to decorate. We all had a good time. The only negative was the full service bar did not have a bartender so the tender from the main dinning room took orders and came back up with drinks. But that wasn’t so bad as very attentive. Great hidden find.
Twisted Flame Glassworks Inc.
You know how You just get a hankering for something. Well this afternoon I had a hankering for a BLT And Old Town pub did not disappoint. 1st time at this establishment and it won't be the last. The bread tomato and lettuce were super fresh. The bacon was fantastic but really the highlights of the sandwich Is the garlic aoli And that perfectly drippy egg they put on top. Service was stellar And we will be back soon. Thank you for a fantastic lunch
Permanently closed February 28, 2024 ?
Decent bar
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Had a really nice lunch with friends. Everyone was happy with their food! Reuben chicken strips and pot roast sandwich and of course the fries! Lucus was a great waiter!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders
Visited some family in the area and stopped in. Mediocre food, mediocre service and mediocre experience in general.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My wife and I were hungry and thirsty. We just finished watching a Boys basketball game at Geneva HS. They won that night. We asked one of the teachers there if she could recommend a restaurant nearby. She just started going on and on about OTP, the food, the atmosphere, the beer on tap and the MUST try onion rings. This place rocks but I'm getting ahead of myself. She gave us excellent directions. We walk in, it's a slow night. We ordered a beer and mixed drink; my Stella was tasty and fresh. My wife enjoyed her mixed drink. It had an excellent ratio Tito's to Cranberry. It wasn't a heavy headed pour, it’s just right. When she finished it, she ordered another, it was outstanding, according to her. We ordered our dinner; the wings were for me and OTP burger for my wife with a side order of onion rings. My wife loved the burger. It was cooked as asked, juicy, -as my wife told me while she was eating the burger its "flavorful with a smorgasbord of tastes and crunchiness WoW". My chicken wings were to DIE for: they were fresh, tasty, moist, and not dry or over fried. They were able to mix and match the seasonings; the spicy BBQ, the Hot and plain BBQ were excellent. The onion rings were to DIE for; they were better than our teacher recommended to us……They were fresh, tasty with just the right amount delicious beer battered crumbs. They were YUMMY! The restaurant/bar feels like a "Cheers Bar". This is our go-to place the next time we are in the area. This place is EXCELLENT!
Parking: Easy parking on Main street
Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly meals
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Nice restaurant with a great variety of American food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Met cousin in Geneva for a girls weekend. Great location. We had chicken salad sandwiches 1 one croissant and 1 on pretzel roll. So yummy!!!! And we shared the donut ice-cream dessert. Heaven!Server was so sweet, funny and nice!!!As a person who is allergic to scents and for a person working in a restaurant maybe less perfume. But so sweet!!!!!Great town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I met up with some friends yesterday to eat here! The vibe is nice and everything seemed great! After watching quite a few people who sat after us get their food before us we checked and were told it would be a couple minute. No problem! I’m not in a rush so no biggie. Then the waitress said that the ticket didn’t get sent in so it would be a bit longer. Still no biggie, life happens!When the food finally comes out, I had asked for no cheese on the burger. I point it out and ask quickly still trying to be as polite as possible cause I know of the mix up earlier. The waitress decided instead to gaslight me and tell me that I asked for no cheddar cheese and that the southwest burger has 2 cheeses on it. Well the cheese was definitely cheddar to start off with but then to still try and gaslight me when I have the menu showing that she’s oddly lying to me about cheese. I bite my tongue and she takes my food back. Not even minutes later I get it back. I go to take a bite of my burger and sure enough I see the yellow cheese around the edges of the burger. At this point the cheese has clearly been scraped off by staff. At this point the nice bone in my body ran very cold and I made a call to try and figure out if I was being irrational. I decided that we would just not leave a tip but also not cause a scene at the restaurant as I’m not allergic to milk. As this is being decided by my table group the staff is clearly anxious and talking to eachother repeatedly looking at my table. The waitress comes up and asks about our food. I decided it wouldn’t hurt to mention it lightly. I explained the hazard of people who may be allergic to milk and how I was disappointed. She then continued to gaslight me and tell me the yellow cheese I was seeing was grease. ?(which if that is really their grease then people dining here should be concerned about the cleanliness cause grease from burgers is not yellow and doesn’t solidify like that?) but as she said that with no asking or arguments she said she’d take a discount off of my meal. So in her gaslighting she admitted guilt. She also offered to make me a new one but I honestly didn’t want my food spit in if I sent it back a third time so I refused.ALL AND ALL IF YOURE ALLERGIC TO ANYTHING THIS ESTABLISHMENT DOESNT TAKE ALLERGIES SERIOUSLY AND WILL TOTALLY GASLIGHT YOU ABOUT IT. (If the establishment would also like to gaslight me again on here I have pictures.)
We had a private party. Everything was great. Food, service, drinks, atmosphere, etc. We will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great burgers, onion strings, sweet and sweet potato fries. Fabulous service and definitely will go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tater Tots, Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice little hang out. Great mozzarella sticks. Great ambiance. Great drink selection.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DO NOT GO HERE. I made a reservation for a wedding rehearsal dinner and they were extremely understaffed. We paid for a personal bar tender and there was no one at the bar half the time. On top of this the food was extremely late to be served (almost 1.5 hours). I understand things happen but the worst part is the disrespect the staff showed us. When we asked, politely, when the food would be served for the second time, keep in mind this is over an hour after when it was supposed to be served, one of their employees got in my face and started threatening me. The employee that did this was bald and wearing a chicago hat. He was disposable to say the least. He lied to us and treated us horribly for simply asking when the food we paid over a thousand dollars would be ready. This employee not only threatened us but was also starting at my nine year old cousin and trying to talk to her the whole time. Please do not go there and to the ownership - please hold higher standards for who you hire. This man was a disgust and as long as he works there I will make it my mission to spread the word to all of Geneva to never eat or drink there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Old Towne Pub is a great place for burgers, sandwiches, and other pub fare. Set in a rustic, homey vibe, with a lot of TVs to catch up on sports, service I'd good and brings out food in a timely manner. All the dishes my party had left good impressions. If you're wanting to eat some good food and watch some sports, this is the perfect spot to go to!
We had a one year old celebration birthday party and had the entire space upstairs which included a game room and two bathrooms and full service bar. The appetizers and chicken/beef fajitas were all very good. We were advised on how much to order for our group and it was just enough. We were allowed to come in an hour before the party to decorate. We all had a good time. The only negative was the full service bar did not have a bartender so the tender from the main dinning room took orders and came back up with drinks. But that wasn’t so bad as very attentive. Great hidden find.
You know how You just get a hankering for something. Well this afternoon I had a hankering for a BLT And Old Town pub did not disappoint. 1st time at this establishment and it won't be the last. The bread tomato and lettuce were super fresh. The bacon was fantastic but really the highlights of the sandwich Is the garlic aoli And that perfectly drippy egg they put on top. Service was stellar And we will be back soon. Thank you for a fantastic lunch
Loading...