Bake Share
827 Center St, Grayslake
(847) 356-1854
Customers' Favorites
Key Lime Pie
Apple Pie
Scone
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I would (and do) recommend Bake Share to anyone! Best pies in the area!!! Every dessert my family has tried so far, we’ve loved, and I can’t wait to give more a try. My personal favorite is their cookies and cream pie- worth it 100%!!
My son Ben introduced me to Mike the “Pie Guy” at farmers market in Grayslake. I purchased the peach and branched out with chicken pot pie. You can literally taste the freshness. I have never found anyone that could compete with my mamas crust. But you did and I felt a little nostalgia taking over. She baked with love. As you do. Thank you so much. I’ll be back😊
Looking for the world’s greatest key lime pie? Well, you found it!!!! Truly, Mike has managed to create the perfect key lime pie. It is so insanely good…The only downside is that you will never enjoy a key lime pie from somewhere else ever again 😆 We have also tried & loved the French silk, pumpkin, lemon ice box, apple pie, beef & ale….you really can’t go wrong. Gluten free options are a cherry on top. Very friendly staff and the owner Mike is a seriously...
You May Also Like
El Azteca II - 821 Center St
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Umai Sushi & Hibachi - 100 S Atkinson Rd
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Mongolian