Cakes By Ally

109 W Monroe St, Herrin
(618) 694-9939

Recent Reviews

Hannah Gund

I didn't even know about this place until a friend brought some of the brownies, cupcakes, and macarons. They were all incredible!!! Some of the BEST cupcakes and macarons I've ever had. Incredible flavor and texture. Can't wait to check it out myself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randa Burgess

I ordered a six inch, 2 layer cake. Was told it would feed 10-12, which I didn't believe. I was wrong. It was perfect and so adorably decorated. My son loved it. I would definitely recommend Cakes By

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kayla O'Bright

The perfect bit of sweet everyone needs! There’s something for everyone :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Iced Latte, Frosted Sugar Cookies - Half Dozen

Lisa D. Vinson

The cakes are good, but customer service sucks. I’m in the store a lady comes in after me. The counter person is working with me the manager has her to stop and take care of another customer “real quick”. Second time this has happened will NEVER go back

Sebastian Housden

They have so many flavors, cupcakes and macaroons were phenomenal!

Patrick Padilla

Phenomenal cake shop. My wife and I ordered a cake along with cupcakes and cookies and they provided a phenomenal cake exactly how my wife wanted. Along with that the taste of the cakes and cupcakes were amazing as well, perfectly sweet and a nice soft texture as well. Definitely order here if you plan on ordering any sweets for your future events!

christina ewell

That Italian Creme Cake was amazing. Eric and I split it. Yummmmmm

Randi Claunch

I stopped in and got a cake for my grandma’s birthday and the Italian cream cake is absolutely delicious. I also appreciate the macarons’s being gluten free for my allergy child. I didn’t order ahead and I was very impressed with the selection available. Thank you!

Ann D.

We love the moist cake and the buttercream icing is a favorite! You can't go wrong with the Bridal white cupcakes! My son loves the Boston Cream cupcakes and my boyfriend's favorite is the Fudge Sundae one! We also enjoy the Snicker cupcake!

Meresa Monteith

I was not impressed. My cake was very pretty, but was not tasty. It tasted like a Kroger or Walmart cake. And it cost $50 bucks.

Katie Eck

This place is amazing. We just moved to the area and ordered a cake for my 9 year old's birthday. My husband has never liked cake, but immediately upon tasting the icing, he ate two huge pieces. We all think this is the best cake we've ever had.The prices are super reasonable, the quality is insane, and the owner was super sweet. We will definitely be back!!

Joshua Roman

You better learn how to respect your customers. I’m only reviewing because my genuine hearted mother refuses to. DON’T advertise a cake ON YOUR SITE if you can’t even come close to remaking it and DON’T use “it’s all we had in the back” as an excuse. Most of all, DON’T accuse someone of not wanting to pay AFTER they call you to tell you that they aren’t going to make a big deal, leave a bad review, or give negative feedback but just wanted you to know that it was a bit of a disappointment considering it was for a very special event.You can at the very least admit your failure or show at least a half hearted attempt to make things straight.

Cazy Garrett

Been going here for a few years. She even did my wedding cake. The owner is absolutely wonderful and super helpful and so is the rest of the staff. I recommend this place to everyone I know!

Natassia H.

We love this cute little shop! Their macrons are amazing and by far my favorite! we also tried cake pops (kids favorite!) and a birthday cake. everything was moist and so cute and delicious! The shop was clean and adorable and it smells so good in there! The service was great and our family was beyond happy with our purchase. I crave the pistachio macrons weekly

Brandon Parr

New to the area from 300 miles away, Walked in under a recommendation, due to my addiction to sweets and coffee So Glad I Did!Greeted with a smile, excellent customer service, Best coffee I've ever had, next time ordering 2, and the sweets are Oh So Yummy and To Die For! Wishing the owners and staff all the best, great success and many more continued years of service. Left with a smile and will be returning with one again.

Load More