My order was wrong— ordered XL pizza with sausage and regular sauce but got one with pepperoni and spicy sauce, it was delivered on time but ice cold. The delivery driver was nice and friendly..no issues with that. Wont order again
Agus
Great advice: double-check your orders before delivering them. I ordered a pizza: half cheese, half ham, pineapple, and jalapeño. It was for my son and me. My son doesn't eat anything spicy. When I picked up the pizza, I didn't double-check it because I trust their work (poor choice of action). I got home and the entire pizza had jalapeños. I called them and told them my pizza was cooked poorly, and they said it wasn't true. I have the receipt, and I know that's not how I ordered it. The guy was still doing the same thing. It's too bad they have people working there who don't provide solutions to problems. The pizza is good, but they don't make it the way the customer orders, and the employees don't provide solutions and answer poorly. I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Terri Roenfanz
Best pasta pizza I've ever had! The young men who served us were helpful and friendly. It was an all over good experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Pasta Pizza
Jozih Korotkov
I ordered couple slices over the phone walked in and I see the guy nodding out while I was walking up. Definitely was high on something I get the slices totally burnt. Disgusting actually threw the pizza slices away and there goes nine dollars. Owner should take a look at drug use on the job.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amannur Tachmyradov
One of the best places to eat ice cold pizza. If you want to eat really cold pizza, you can come here. I recommend it. It feels like eating ice cold pizza.
Z N
Some of the best pizza in town!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Tack
We had it delivered. Everyone was nauseous and concerned that it wasn’t cooked properly. It was ordered for half garlic and garlic, was on the entire pizza. It was also cold when it arrived.
Food: 2
Service: 2
adil ahmad
Great food
Zondra Hopkins
There are a lot of comments from people who don’t like NY style pizza, so to set the record straight this is a great NY slice. It’s got the well cooked crispy crust with a proper bite/chew to it. The mozzarella has a nice mild flavor and the sauce is more robust than sweet. Italian seasoning comes out well and pairs great with the red pepper flakes. The layout and location make it have a good mom and pop atmosphere with a cool NY graffiti vibe. Lots of small tables to sit and a high stop counter with bar stool seating. I do agree that since ny style pizza has thin crust, it’s gonna be better to have it straight out the oven (asap) or by the slice. If you love NY pizza, you have to try it for yourself!
NY Slices in Highland Park, IL, is an absolute gem for pizza lovers! Every Monday and Thursday, we make it a point to indulge in their unbeatable 2-for-1 large pizza deal. For just $20, you get two twelve-inch NY-style pies – an offer that Domino's can't come close to matching! The pizzas are always delicious, with the perfectly floppy crusts and mouthwatering toppings that leave us craving more.
The staff at NY Slices are always welcoming and friendly, making each visit a pleasant experience. They also offer a fantastic selection of locally brewed craft sodas, which pair perfectly with their pizzas. The decor is simple but inviting, creating a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
While we haven't had the chance to try their calzones yet, they look absolutely amazing coming out of the oven. We can't wait to sink our teeth into one soon! The garlic knots look good too, I'm curious about the "pasta on pizza" as well. If you're in Highland Park and looking for great pizza and excellent service, NY Slices is the place to go. Highly recommended!
Parking: there is free parking 100yrds or so north of the front door
Kid-friendliness: My son loves this place, they treat him like any other customer, helping him with his order, talking about the ingredients etc.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Michael Greco
Anyone who ranks this low doesn’t even know what New York pizza is. It’s good and closest you’re gonna get to ny style pizza around here
ThaTrippy1
Best pizza by slice spot ive been to in a while. The attendant Chris is very friendly. Will definately come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Nied
Very very good pizza! Recommend to try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Ransavage
From someone who grew up in north Jersey, this is delicious and legit NY style pizza.
My order was wrong— ordered XL pizza with sausage and regular sauce but got one with pepperoni and spicy sauce, it was delivered on time but ice cold. The delivery driver was nice and friendly..no issues with that. Wont order again
Great advice: double-check your orders before delivering them. I ordered a pizza: half cheese, half ham, pineapple, and jalapeño. It was for my son and me. My son doesn't eat anything spicy. When I picked up the pizza, I didn't double-check it because I trust their work (poor choice of action). I got home and the entire pizza had jalapeños. I called them and told them my pizza was cooked poorly, and they said it wasn't true. I have the receipt, and I know that's not how I ordered it. The guy was still doing the same thing. It's too bad they have people working there who don't provide solutions to problems. The pizza is good, but they don't make it the way the customer orders, and the employees don't provide solutions and answer poorly. I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pasta pizza I've ever had! The young men who served us were helpful and friendly. It was an all over good experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Pasta Pizza
I ordered couple slices over the phone walked in and I see the guy nodding out while I was walking up. Definitely was high on something I get the slices totally burnt. Disgusting actually threw the pizza slices away and there goes nine dollars. Owner should take a look at drug use on the job.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the best places to eat ice cold pizza. If you want to eat really cold pizza, you can come here. I recommend it. It feels like eating ice cold pizza.
Some of the best pizza in town!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had it delivered. Everyone was nauseous and concerned that it wasn’t cooked properly. It was ordered for half garlic and garlic, was on the entire pizza. It was also cold when it arrived.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great food
There are a lot of comments from people who don’t like NY style pizza, so to set the record straight this is a great NY slice. It’s got the well cooked crispy crust with a proper bite/chew to it. The mozzarella has a nice mild flavor and the sauce is more robust than sweet. Italian seasoning comes out well and pairs great with the red pepper flakes. The layout and location make it have a good mom and pop atmosphere with a cool NY graffiti vibe.
Lots of small tables to sit and a high stop counter with bar stool seating.
I do agree that since ny style pizza has thin crust, it’s gonna be better to have it straight out the oven (asap) or by the slice.
If you love NY pizza, you have to try it for yourself!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie, Sausage Slice, Cheese Slice
pizza good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
NY Slices in Highland Park, IL, is an absolute gem for pizza lovers! Every Monday and Thursday, we make it a point to indulge in their unbeatable 2-for-1 large pizza deal. For just $20, you get two twelve-inch NY-style pies – an offer that Domino's can't come close to matching! The pizzas are always delicious, with the perfectly floppy crusts and mouthwatering toppings that leave us craving more.
The staff at NY Slices are always welcoming and friendly, making each visit a pleasant experience. They also offer a fantastic selection of locally brewed craft sodas, which pair perfectly with their pizzas. The decor is simple but inviting, creating a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
While we haven't had the chance to try their calzones yet, they look absolutely amazing coming out of the oven. We can't wait to sink our teeth into one soon! The garlic knots look good too, I'm curious about the "pasta on pizza" as well. If you're in Highland Park and looking for great pizza and excellent service, NY Slices is the place to go. Highly recommended!
Parking: there is free parking 100yrds or so north of the front door
Kid-friendliness: My son loves this place, they treat him like any other customer, helping him with his order, talking about the ingredients etc.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Slice
Anyone who ranks this low doesn’t even know what New York pizza is. It’s good and closest you’re gonna get to ny style pizza around here
Best pizza by slice spot ive been to in a while. The attendant Chris is very friendly. Will definately come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very very good pizza! Recommend to try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From someone who grew up in north Jersey, this is delicious and legit NY style pizza.
Loading...