Papa Johns Pizza

415 Keokuk St, Lincoln
(217) 732-7363

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lora Eichel

We ordered the works and a 2 topping. The 2 top was basically uneatable. I think we may have gotten the wrong pizza. Overall, for the money, and not being able to eat it, we are very disappointed. Very disappointed.

Food: 2

Service: 3

Tammy Collins

Great experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tuesday Phillips

Placed an order for delivery. Waited over an hour just to receive a call stating they can’t deliver it. I’m a nurse on duty, so I can’t just leave to get it. Looks like I’m just out the order.

Service: 1

Thomas Martin

You order food and their app tells you it’s on the way. It’s not. They lie to you and tell you it’s on the way only for 30 minute later you check their app and they tell you your order has been cancelled. No phone call. No text. Just the app saying it’s canceled. Perhaps they shouldn’t have outsourced their delivery to door dash. Don’t trust this establishment. They’ll let you down as well.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Walt Cofer

Papa John’s never disappoints! I had the Supreme Pizza, and it was absolutely delicious—loaded with fresh toppings, flavorful sauce, and a perfectly baked crust. Great tasting pizza and always reliable for a satisfying meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mathew Huskins

Shifty service I placed a order an hr before they closed and they never showed up I say never order from here for Delivery

Erika Schick

I ordered pizza from them July either 3rd or 4th and tonight July 8th and both times the service and food have been amazing, the 1st 1 there was only 1 worker on duty and no drivers or other employees but a women working and she worked her butt off due to high volume of orders and got me taken care of fast and the food was just right, tonight was quick and good I ordered it at 9:10pm and it was delivered at 9:27pm Dominos can't compete with that! Papa Johns needs to be more appreciated for their service and food! Will forever be a customer!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sherrie Marie Carlin

just got 2 excellent pizzas!

Scott Johnston

Food is good but delivery service is horrible and customer service is absolutely non existent!! Im baffled by you saying you couldn't deliver to my job less than a half a mile straight down the same road the restaurant is on, you guy's use doordash im positive doordash delivers anywhere

Store 5343

The review below from Rachel M is the former general manger Rachel Bragg. She was fired in October 2024. Yet here she is writing reviews about the new General Manager who didn't even work the day the review was written. She ordered a large half pep through door dash. So her entire review is a lie. Making fake reviews to sabotage someone with a family says more about them then anything.

Rachel M

The absolute worst experience ever.. FRANK has no place being in management. Argumentative ... The sausage had MOLD on it. The food was cold. We were missing the dipping sauces,. Parm sticks had no sauce .. and how do you forget the cheese on a pizza??? RUDE.. Will NEVER be back again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

DEBRA GRAUE

The fact that their pizza is way to high. 28.00 they charge you 5.99 for delivery. Then they hired Door Dash and and so 40.00 dollars. He promised he would bring my change. Noone claims the blame.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

McKenzie Dasuki

Took over an hour to get delivered, food was cold. "Saucy wings" were just plain chicken nuggets with a barely there squirt of sauce. Hardly any cheese on the pizza. Huge bummer.

Food: 1

Glowy Hoyt

Delicious pizza! Frank is a great manager!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ian Crider

Ordered an XL New York Style pizza with beef. I thought the bigger pizza just might have toppings to fill the larger space. Not so. The normal measure of ingredients were just spread over a larger area. Disappointed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...