Papa Johns Pizza

415 Keokuk St, Lincoln
(217) 732-7363

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Epic Stuffed Crust Double Pepperoni and Original Crust with Pepperoni and Sausage

Pizza

Photos

+22 photos

+21 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I ordered pizza from them July either 3rd or 4th and tonight July 8th and both times the service and food have been amazing, the 1st 1 there was only 1 worker on duty and no drivers or other employees but a women working and she worked her butt off due to high volume of orders and got me taken care of fast and the food was just right, tonight was quick and good I ordered it at 9:10pm and it was delivered at 9:27pm Dominos can't compete with that! Papa Johns needs to be more...

July 2025

The review below from Rachel M is the former general manger Rachel Bragg. She was fired in October 2024. Yet here she is writing reviews about the new General Manager who didn't even work the day the review was written. She ordered a large half pep through door dash. So her entire review is a lie. Making fake reviews to sabotage someone with a family says more about them then anything.

March 2025

Ordered an XL New York Style pizza with beef. I thought the bigger pizza just might have toppings to fill the larger space. Not so. The normal measure of ingredients were just spread over a larger area. Disappointed.

October 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Lincoln, IL

Papa Johns Pizza

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Papa Johns Pizza