Old School Pizza
507 N 3rd St Unit 2, Malta
(815) 981-8805
Customers' Favorites
The Weird Al Super Duper Cheesy Supreme
Sausage Pizza with Pepperoni
Malta's Sweethaven Pizza
Where the Buffalo Roam
Freaky Tiki Hawaiian
Italian Beef Pizza
Loaded Tater Tots
The Chuck Norris
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Toppings
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We visited this Old School Pizza in Malta on Friday, December 19th, 2025. This was our third visit, the first time being in December 2024 after first hearing about it in May 2024 and trying to find time to go and the second time in July 2025. We loved our experience, the atmosphere is awesome there are so many little decorations all over the walls. The pizza was great too. Between our two visits, it did change where you place your order upfront now and bring your plates up when...
This was super fun. We decided to come out here on a cold night in December, and it was worth it! Super cool atmosphere, really fun old arcade, and delicious food. Their garlic knots are amazing, and their mozzarella sticks are super crispy. Definitely something people should check out!
The atmosphere is incredible ... but the pizza is the real reason to keep coming back! Absolutely great food served in a fantastic setting of nostalgic awesomness. GO! You'll be glad you did. :-)
You May Also Like
Tamales Los Girasoles - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Food Trucks, Tacos
Tinez Tacos - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Mexican, Food Trucks, Tacos
Fatty's Pub & Grille - 1312 W Lincoln Hwy
![]()
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, Pubs, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian