Old School Pizza
507 N 3rd St Unit 2, Malta
(815) 981-8805
Customers' Favorites
The Weird Al Super Duper Cheesy Supreme
Sausage Pizza with Pepperoni
Malta's Sweethaven Pizza
Where the Buffalo Roam
Freaky Tiki Hawaiian
Italian Beef Pizza
Loaded Tater Tots
The Chuck Norris
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Toppings
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Prices are a bit skewed, somehow a group of 3 people accrued a bill of $90, no drinks, 3 pizzas and fountain drinks. Place is pretty pricey and their pizza is all over the place. Sometimes it’s good but most times its bad, the sauce is weird.
We reserved space for a kids birthday party of 30 people. It was a great time, had arcade/quarter games for the kids, and we didnt have to work to entertain the kids every second! GOOD food and had more options than I expected. Cool location that I didn't have to assign a party theme (could have, but wasn't needed!). My family and friends felt very comfortable and didn't spend the whole time wondering where the kids were running to, decor is roped off or stable...
I've been here twice, the first time, I was hoping it was more than a gimmick, with cool stuff all around. And I was not disappointed. Their pizza is 2nd to none! Incredible ingredients, absolutely PERFECT crust with a sweet savory sauce. Hands down, the best pizza for hundreds of miles. Not to mention, pinball and air hockey on top of it all. You will not be disappointed!
You May Also Like
Tamales Los Girasoles - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Food Trucks, Tacos
Tinez Tacos - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Mexican, Food Trucks, Tacos
Remington's Gastropub - 102 S 3rd St
![]()
Gastropubs, American, Barbeque