Old School Pizza
507 N 3rd St Unit 2, Malta
(815) 981-8805
Customers' Favorites
The Weird Al Super Duper Cheesy Supreme
Sausage Pizza with Pepperoni
Malta's Sweethaven Pizza
Where the Buffalo Roam
Freaky Tiki Hawaiian
Italian Beef Pizza
Loaded Tater Tots
The Chuck Norris
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Toppings
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Love this place, a unique little hole in the wall in a town you've never heard of, filled with high end trinkets, baubles, statues, and relics from another time. Oh and the pizza is good, too.
Actually in an old school. Packed with collectibles and memorabilia and classic arcade games and pinball machines.
Normally the food would be an afterthought at a place that is this eclectic but it was the highlight.
Best version of an Italian beef pizza and a buffalo chicken pizza I've had. I'm a Chicago native, originally, so I have tried a lot of pizza. If this place were located closer to the city, you wouldn't ever get...
Normally the food would be an afterthought at a place that is this eclectic but it was the highlight.
Best version of an Italian beef pizza and a buffalo chicken pizza I've had. I'm a Chicago native, originally, so I have tried a lot of pizza. If this place were located closer to the city, you wouldn't ever get...
This place is amazing and worth a drive to check out. There are so many things to see, your eyes won't know where to look next. I also suggest switching sides of the table with your friends/family at some point so you can check out what's displayed behind you, too.
I had the Eastwood pizza, and it was amazing. I also had some of the garlic knots, they may be worth the drive alone! I will be back to try many of the other pizzas, I'm sure they are...
I had the Eastwood pizza, and it was amazing. I also had some of the garlic knots, they may be worth the drive alone! I will be back to try many of the other pizzas, I'm sure they are...
You May Also Like
Tamales Los Girasoles - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Food Trucks, Tacos
Tinez Tacos - 4199 IL-38
![]()
Mexican, Food Trucks, Tacos
Remington's Gastropub - 102 S 3rd St
![]()
Gastropubs, American, Barbeque