Angelo's Pizza

1020 Lake Land Blvd, Mattoon
(217) 258-6066

Recent Reviews

Sort by
kstev99

Some of the best Lasagna I have ever had

Briar Smith

The Chicago style stuffed pizza is fantastic! Highly recommend!!

Mike Waltz

Had this pizza many times, it never fails to be just as good as the first time. The stuffed supreme is fantastic, and my 3 yo grandson, who is very picky, ate it fresh, then asked for cold pizza the next day….he never does that.

Jeremy Rausch

We called ahead to confirm the wing portions before placing our order and were told that both bone-in and boneless wings come in 8-piece servings. However, when our order arrived, we received only 7 bone-in wings and 6 boneless. On top of that, the pizza was cold and the cheese wasn't even melted properly. When we called the store to address the issue, we spoke with Bill—who identified himself as the owner. Instead of acknowledging the mistake, he dismissed our concerns by saying, “It’s one piece of chicken, what do you want me to do about it?” But it’s not just one piece—it’s multiple issues with the entire order. As a business owner, minimizing a customer’s complaint instead of offering a solution is not only unprofessional, it reflects poorly on the business. This was a disappointing experience and a poor example of customer service.

Hulk

We called ahead to confirm the wing portions before placing our order and were told that both bone-in and boneless wings come in 8-piece servings. However, when our order arrived, we received only 7 bone-in wings and 6 boneless. On top of that, the pizza was cold and the cheese wasn't even melted properly.

When we called the store to address the issue, we spoke with Bill—who identified himself as the owner. Instead of acknowledging the mistake, he dismissed our concerns by saying, “It’s one piece of chicken, what do you want me to do about it?”

But it’s not just one piece—it’s multiple issues with the entire order. As a business owner, minimizing a customer’s complaint instead of offering a solution is not only unprofessional, it reflects poorly on the business. This was a disappointing experience and a poor example of customer service.

Dianna Miller

Great food, Great atmosphere. We had cheese ravioli & pizza. It is always on our list to stop at when in the area.

Carl Anderson

We have been to Angelo's every year while staying in Charleston for the State Meet. No matter the size of our party, dietary accommodations or time of arrival, Angelo's is fantastic! The staff are so inviting, the food is fantastic and the prices are more than reasonable! I highly recommend!

Benjamin Austin

Oh so GOOD

Wyatt Lockridge

I'm a meatball guy. If you're looking for meatballs with a great sauce here's the place. The stuffed crust takes time. The time waiting is worth every bite taken. The energy with the servers is something needed nowadays. The specials they sell are better than most markets around. Spaghetti Wednesday is a deal I think everyone should try at least once. The building gives you old family energy that makes it more comfortable and enjoyable compared to every place being a concept idea.

Kim Wheeler

We always enjoy eating here!

Mike Myers

Love the pizza and the Spaghetti is to die for both a must try

Rachel kirkley

So yummy!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charlotte Lukens

The spaghetti and lasagna was amazing. The taste was 20times better than olive garden

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rachel Champagne

First time here. The food was good. They do have a stuffed pizza. We will get this next time. The waitress said you can call ahead and have them start making it so you do not have to sit there for 45 mins while it cooks.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chili Mac

Jessica Huddleston

Their homemade sauce was amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza

Loading...