Buffalo67 Steakhouse & Grille

This place came highly recommended. We were spending the weekend in Monmouth from out of state and wanted a great place to eat. Unfortunately, this was not the place. When reading their menu it describes how their items are cooked and you imagine what their dishes might look like based on the description. Two of us ordered their homemade chicken tender dinner. When my tender meal came out the breading appeared burnt and was extremely dry. The same was done with my onion tanglers. I looked at the other meal at the table and the breading was a little lighter than mine. This was nothing as described on their menu. I cooked in a kitchen in several different establishments over the years and I know my way around a kitchen. We said something immediately to the waiter and he requested the kitchen make me new tenders. The kitchen staff argued and basically said that's how they have to be to be cooked at 165° so they chose NOT to make me new tenders. Apparently the cook/chef is not inclined to know that's what happens to breading on anything when the heat is too high or the oil is old. Another female employee tried to get staff to make me another order but was unsuccessful so she asked if I wanted something else. After hearing the cook refuse to remake my order, I was hesitant at ordering anything else so I asked if she could just remove the charge from my bill. She was a wonderful lady and full of apologies but she wasn't the one that needed to apologize as she had no control over the way the food comes out of the kitchen and no control over the cook(s) stubbornness.Our group looked over at the table next to us, and another customer ordered the chicken tenders and they were just as bad as mine. We watched him complain and he left without eating them. I hope they credited his bill.After reading reviews on line clearly there is a problem with the food. It is not as advertised and some things need to be addressed with whomever their cook(s) are. Either additional training or a replacement is needed to eliminate the bad reviews and make for a prosperous establishment.

We were so excited to try this place. Other than some stuff that irritated me, food was ok, with good portions.Placed our orders then waitress came to check wondering why we didn't get our appetizer yet!? My husband and I got our main courses, no one came to check on us. Had to call our waitress again within 5+ minutes to tell her we didn't get my toddlers chicken strips, she was like oh that's weird you didn't get it, comes back later telling us they're working on it; took another 10 minutes, came in so hot that he didn't touch it.

Decent menu and food, nice waitress, but VERY slow. A friend said we'd be there for 3 hours if we had a large group and it did take that long. Drinks and the few appetizers we ordered came out quickly, but it was a long wait for the main meals.

Our waitress, Chloe was such a sweetheart!! The food was yummy ? !!

Great atmosphere! Great music, food, and drinks! Our waitress was excellent! Super nice! Her name was Molly! Such a sweetie! We will definitely be back!

Food is absolutely disappointing!!!! Ordered fried chicken and all you can taste is the raw flour batter. Chicken was undercooked and outside was burnt. Service is terrible!!! I left that place FULL…. of regret. This place was more disappointing than my marriage. Save your money and go to Dairy Queen.

The cheeseburgers were great! Good sized portions. I loved the little extra touch the side salad had. Don't order a spicy Bloody Mary unless you're sure you want spicy! LolDidn't rate a 5 because the booth and tables could have been cleaner.Overall, a good experience. Both our waitress and our host were awesome!

Had a lunch special....smoked meatloaf (to die for!!)...with mashed red potatoes and white gravy and bacon infused green beans....for an insanely cheap $8.99.....damn near more than I could eat and so delicious!!Sat at the bar and our bartender/waitress/asst mgr. was stellar!!WILL BE GOING BACK FOR SURE...and its an hour from home!! Well done Buffalo 67!!

Worst steak I ever had took them 45min to cook it and it was so tuff could not eat it mashed potatoes where cold. The waitress was very upset about how my food was she was very nice and the manager also was very nice she did not make me pay for my dinner. Hope they can figure out there problems because it is a nice looking place.

Extremely slow & burger was 1/2 raw. Kept waiting for a new one & finally gave up & left.

The food was delicious, setting was modern eclectic and the staff was friendly!

Best meals we've had in a long time! Highly recommended!

5 out of 5 stars. Very good food and friendly atmosphere. Will definitely come back!

Awesome food! Great service and love the way u redid the place!

The steaks and wings were great, but my sautee onions and mushrooms were way over cooked (burnt). I couldn't eat them